News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by taurath on Sunday September 13, 2020 @08:51PM (#24465446)
The Hoover Foundation isn’t exactly unbiased. The thousands comes from the “2009 to 2016” period. No mention of how many businesses were created. Nor comps of other states.

I believe that lots of people wish they could move their business out of state. I also believe many don’t because they actually like it here, it’s access to a ton of well off customers with cash to burn, and while they grumble about the regulatory burden it also creates quite a nicer place to live. I’m sure the latter comment will get lots of attention as there’s innumerable people who are sick of California. I’m looking at moving back after 6 years away.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by atomi on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:08PM (#24465573)
This comment will be unpopular.

But, I and most people I've talked to have been waiting years for this prediction to materialize. We'd all love it here if we could enjoy all that California has to offer with fewer transplants around.

And I'll add, if you've extracted your wealth off the back of California and it's people, it's only fair you pay back some of that to the state if you do decide to just take the money and run.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by athms on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:25PM (#24465698)
>We'd all love it here if we could enjoy all that California has to offer with fewer transplants around.

This sentiment has been around for decades. My family moved to Southern California from Illinois in the 1970s and there were bumper stickers that said, "Welcome to California, now go back home."

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by atomi on Sunday September 13, 2020 @10:43PM (#24466234)
I'm going to bet that sentiment has been around for a lot longer than that, likely even before the gold rush and dust bowl migrations.

I think what is new are these tireless and never ending threats of leaving. It's like, ok, go already - sheesh.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by microtherion on Monday September 14, 2020 @08:20AM (#24469223)
There is a story that Elisha Stephens, for whom Stevens Creek is named, awoke one morning in the early 1860s in the Cupertino area, spotted the smoke of someone else's cooking fire somewhere in the distance, and decided that the area was getting too crowded for his taste.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by koheripbal on Monday September 14, 2020 @08:16AM (#24469191)
> if you've extracted your wealth off the back of California and it's people

So merely having wealth implies that you immorally "extracted it on the backs" of others?

Are you writing this from your 10th grade recess period?

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by atomi on Monday September 14, 2020 @12:03PM (#24471747)
You're implying that resources afforded to people have no bearing on their ability to build wealth. That's nonsensical.

> Are you writing this from your 10th grade recess period?

These types of comments don't belong here.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @08:58PM (#24465508)
> The Hoover Foundation isn’t exactly unbiased.

What does that mean? They’re a non-partisan think tank. They certainly have a free market point of view, but every source has a point of view.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by gamblor956 on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:12PM (#24465601)
The Hoover Institution is aligned with the Republican Party. It has been since it was named after Herbert Hoover, a Republican president. Like the Nixon library, it exists primarily to redeem the reputation of its namesake.

(For those who need a refresher, Hoover's policies nearly destroyed America during the Great Depression and he spent the rest of his life trying to convince the world that unrestrained free markets and supply side economics was the cure all for everything.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:29PM (#24465730)
You sound like you need a refresher on both Hoover and the Institution.
[dead]
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @10:07PM (#24466036)
I don’t know what planet you live in, but we are entering the fifth decade of the Hoover Institution’s ideas being so widely recognized as effective that countries in Western Europe have been undoing their previous approaches at top-down governance to implement decentralized free market ones. Sweden has partially privatized its social security and has cut corporate tax rates to 21%. Denmark has gotten rid of its communications regulator. Macron is preaching Hoover-Institution style reform to a sclerotic France. (Heck it’s been so popular in Europe that the US is falling behind in deregulation and privatization, such as with the Post Office.) Meanwhile, we are entering the fourth decade of the “New Democrat” party in the United States, which had to wholesale adopt small government ideas from Republicans in order to remain electorally relevant.

It’s traditionally left wing economic ideas that have been soundly repudiated over the last five decades. A return to left-wing economics was just soundly rejected again in the US (Sanders) and the U.K. (Corbyn).

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jahaja on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:02AM (#24480219)
Barely a single news media in both the UK and the US lobbied for Sander/Corbyn. Still they got a very decent results. So one could ask; repudiated by whom?
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:53PM (#24486576)
Voters?
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jahaja on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @06:20PM (#24487404)
You don't think that being both shunned and actively worked against by almost the entire main stream media doesn't have an effect? The so-called establishment are seemingly very united when it comes to stopping left-wing deviants.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by taurath on Monday September 14, 2020 @12:48AM (#24466853)
That’s an interesting way to look at the world, especially in terms of economic policy. I would surmise though that not a single person making those policies you mention from the countries you mentioned hold up unfettered supply side / unrestricted free market as an ideal endpoint.

None of the countries or politicians you mentioned have the same policies. Sanders doesn’t want government control of means of production (traditional left wing economics). All the European countries have universal healthcare and will never take it away.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by thu2111 on Monday September 14, 2020 @04:16AM (#24467947)
That last statement is a bit weird. What do you mean by "universal healthcare"? Quite a few have what is basically Obamacare, i.e. mandatory health insurance purchases with subsidies for the poor.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by taurath on Monday September 14, 2020 @04:42AM (#24468094)
I mean universal as in it covers everyone. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_systems_by_count...
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by thu2111 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @03:49AM (#24490468)
But then doesn't the US have that, post Obamacare? I thought the point of that law was to make health insurance purchase mandatory.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:49AM (#24470791)
Sure, think tanks often take a more purist ideological view than is actually implemented in the real world. But if you look at the direction the developed world has headed since the 1980s, Hoover Institution and similar organizations have been tremendously successful in moving things in the directions they espouse.

In the 1960s, you had governments owning entire industries (state-owned enterprises), and micro-managing private businesses to the point where regulators were telling airlines and bus lines what fares they could charge. In Western Europe and Canada in particular, even though you didn't have "government control over the means of production" you had several countries (such as Canada) with more than 50% of the economy being the government or government-owned enterprises. That has been the "traditional left-wing" approach during the 20th century. Almost everyone moved away from those approaches starting in the 1970s and 1980s. From 1990 to 2000, Canada's government expenditures as a percentage of GDP dropped from over 50% to well under 40%. An entire tenth of the economy was returned to the private sector in just a decade. In Sweden, government spending peaked at almost 70% of the entire economy in 1995. A decade later, it was under 50%. One sixth of the economy was returned to the private sector.

To give a concrete example, licenses to use radio waves used to be awarded by bureaucrats based on their assessment of what was "in the public interest." They would evaluate applications from different companies for different uses for spectrum and decide who should get a license. (That sort of sweeping grant of regulatory authority was common in New Deal-era legislation.) Today, we and most European countries have replaced that with market-based approaches such as spectrum auctions. This has happened world-wide: the EU has issued directives requiring privatization of post offices and railroads. Macron has floated the idea of privatizing SNCF (which would be like privatizing Amtrak here). Denmark's post office is owned by a Swedish company and Stockholm's subway is operated by a Hong Kong company. These are all the kinds of policies advocated by Hoover Institution and other outfits.

You're also arguing to a degree against a straw man. Hoover Institution isn't some anarcho-capitalist outfit that advocates getting rid of the government. To use your universal healthcare example: Hoover Institution isn't suggesting to eliminate universal healthcare. But there are many different ways to implement universal healthcare. At one end you have the UK system, where the government employs the doctors and runs the hospitals. At the other end, you have systems like Switzerland's, based on mandatory private insurance.

Hoover Institution does not propose eliminating universal healthcare. Their focus has been on the cost inefficiencies created by using insurance to pay for routine medical care. Since at least the early 2000s, they have been advocating an approach that provides universal insurance coverage from the government for catastrophic medical care. But routine medical care would be paid for through health savings accounts (HSAs), where costs could be subject to market competition. Even if you don't fully agree with that approach, there is something to it. It's hard to ignore the fact that procedures that aren't covered by insurance are vastly cheaper: you can get laser eye surgery for a couple of thousand dollars per eye, while simply putting a broken arm in a cast costs insurance $2,500 on average. You don't even have to go Galt with that approach--the government could deposit money into the HSAs of low-income people to pay for routine healthcare. That would still preserve the benefits of market competition for those services.

No European country is going take away "universal healthcare." But, especially as social welfare systems get strained by aging populations, I can totally see countries adopting some of these ideas. Sweden recently partially privatized its social security system. Could they start moving some routine medical care into an HSA-type system with subsidies for lower-income people? It's totally plausible.

Likewise, European countries are currently experimenting with Universal Basic Income. One of the early proponents of that was Milton Friedman, a long-time Hoover Institution Fellow. The idea behind UBI fits the ideology. If you're going to spend government money on welfare programs, it's better to just give people money that they can spend in the marketplace instead of creating government departments and hiring government employees to provide services. I wouldn't say Hoover or similar organizations have a universal consensus in favor of UBI, but there are many in these organizations actively advocating in favor of it: https://news.stanford.edu/2018/08/08/stanford-scholar-explor...

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jahaja on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:48AM (#24480140)
> Sweden recently partially privatized its social security system

70% in Sweden is against this change to for-profit social security companies, but the parties in power doesn't prioritise it.

And for whatever propaganda reason you keep using Sweden as some sort of objective evidence of free market utopia when the facts on the ground are just a vast increase in inequality due to aggressive neo-liberal policies for the last ~30 years.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:26AM (#24480416)
I'm not using Sweden as an example of "utopia." I'm using it as an example of a formerly left-wing country, where more than two thirds of the economy was the government, that has, as you put it, "aggressively" embraced "neo-liberal policies for the last ~30 years." Apparently, people have been satisfied enough with the resulting increased growth and competitiveness that they keep voting in "the parties in power."

One can reasonably disagree on whether all the consequences of these policies have been good ones. But if a whole bunch of countries tried "A" and then for the last 30 years have shifted away from "A" to "B" that is powerful evidence that there must be something to "B".

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jahaja on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:10PM (#24483707)
The collapse of the Soviet Union has left the world with "only one way" and the drift into privatization have accelerated since.

But even the people in the US have been in favour of some sort of universal health care since well before USSR collapsed but still haven't been able to "vote in" people supporting that. So it's a pretty strange argument to make.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:00PM (#24486655)
"People" in the U.S. support lots of things in the abstract, until you force them to think about the trade-offs involved in actual policies. People might support universal healthcare, but nobody wants to pay the taxes to pay for it. Which is why Sanders promises not to raise taxes on people making below $250,000 (!). Biden beat Sanders because a large number of Democrats are actually quite conservative (especially people of color, who are often in the Democratic Party for reasons unrelated to economic policies). Biden, who doesn't support Medicare for All, and promises not to raise taxes on people making below $400,000 (!!). It is literally impossible to keep both promises (and people know it).
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jahaja on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @06:24PM (#24487430)
There's a lot of things included in western Europe's high taxes. Not just universal health care. The US sets a very low bar overall. At the same time, however, the US somehow always affords to fund massive wars and armies through its taxes.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by pmoriarty on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:07PM (#24465562)
Condoleeza Rice its director, John Yoo is a Visiting Fellow, Donald Rumsfeld, Ed Meese, and Henry Kissinger are Distinguished Visiting Fellows.

Non-partisan? Come on.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:08PM (#24465576)
And what percentage of the New York Times editorial board is Democrats? I would still call the Times a non-partisan paper (albeit one with liberal leanings).

A somewhat old (2000) Hoover Institution article notes that 1/4 of its Fellows are Democrats. I would be shocked if 1/4 of the Times editorial Board was Republicans. Or really if even one person on the Times editorial Board was a Republican.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by refurb on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:21PM (#24465663)
7% of reporters identify as Republicans versus 28% identify as Democrats.[1]

If we're going to play the "this source is biased" with every article published on HN, then we're going to see a lot of "people should know this paper has a Democratic bias".

[1]https://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2014/05/survey-7-percen...

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:27PM (#24465716)
One amazing fact is that the Democrat:Republican skew among reporters is higher than almost every group traditionally perceived to skew Democratic. Gay people, for example, skew Democrat versus Republican closer to 3:1.

But circling back, this is a theme. Conservative organizations and think tanks (Federalist Society is another example) have more Democrats than putatively objective professions (journalism, academia) have Republicans. That’s bad.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by taurath on Monday September 14, 2020 @12:54AM (#24466887)
Gay people are not 3:1. You’re making up statistics to further your argument, but it’s not helping. Any source I’ve seen in terms of voting record and polling it’s 5:1 or higher.

https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/record-lgbt-support-...

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:13AM (#24471110)
You're citing data for voting while the statistic for reporters above is party identification. So you're comparing apples and oranges. This survey cites data for LGBT party identification: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/20...

> Nearly nine million LGBT adults are registered and eligible to vote in the 2020 general election. Half of registered LGBT voters (50%) are Democrats, 15% are Republicans, 22% are Independent

You're also comparing the 2014 party identification data posted above to 2018 voting data, during the midterm election under perhaps the least popular Republican President in generations. Your own source shows that in 2014, LGBT votes favored Democrats 3:1, similar to the party identification data.

Moreover, many journalists register as independent to avoid perceptions of bias even if they identify strongly with one party. I haven't see data breaking down voting by party, but during the Trump era journalists donated to Clinton by a more than 20:1 margin: https://publicintegrity.org/politics/journalists-shower-hill...

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by pmoriarty on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:24PM (#24465685)
It's media owners who decide the direction of their holdings, not the lowly reporter on the beat.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by davidivadavid on Sunday September 13, 2020 @11:28PM (#24466471)
From what I remember from the Gentzkow/Shapiro work on media bias, media owners isn't really the source of bias. Paraphrasing, it turns out the bias comes from... the readers, who want a paper where they can read what pleases them.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by refurb on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:41PM (#24465843)
I don't think that true, but if it was, that would be even worse since every single reporter for the NYTimes would have to tow the Democratic line. Thank god it's not that bad (they still will have a right-leaning opinion column once a month or so).
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by messick on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:36PM (#24465797)
Guessing the NYTimes has less than 3 people on its board that would be put on trial for war crimes at the ICC if the US didn’t forbid it, which isn’t something an org with Yoo, Kissinger, and Rumsfeld can say.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:12PM (#24465598)
Not a single member of the NY Times editorial board ever worked in the White House (except as a reporter), worked as a full-time political operative, or the like. They’re all career journalists and scholars. It’s not remotely comparable to the Hoover Institution.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/opinion/editorialbo...

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by verylittlemeat on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:28PM (#24465725)
The parent did say editorial board but I would suggest that a criticism of the NYTimes in the same spirit that actually warrants attention is its board of directors. Many if not all of them are wealthy lifelong democrats.

I'm not trying to move the goal posts on you, just pointing out what I think was the original intent of the comment that - that left or right you should always follow the money.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:47PM (#24465895)
Not a single member of the NYT board of directors ever worked in the White House or worked as a full-time political operative either.

They’re a mix of people from the journalism industry and people who had senior management roles in other kinds of businesses: some lawyers, some finance people, etc.

https://www.nytco.com/board-of-directors/

I certainly have problems with the NYT. It is generally pro-corporate and pro-establishment. It is under strong pressure to accept bullshit at face value, and often succumbs (e.g. in the run up to the Iraq War). It tends far too strongly towards nonsensical “bothsidesism”

There are also a lot of excellent journalists working there, and they do a lot of important work. So it’s a mixed bag.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by areyousure on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:42PM (#24485042)
John W. Rogers, Jr. "was a leading campaigner for ... Bill Bradley's 2000 United States presidential campaign" and "served as a fundraising leader in Project Vote efforts led by former United States President Barack Obama". "He was part of the inner circle of the Barack Obama presidential campaign. He is a long-time Obama associate who serves as the co-chair of Obama's Illinois finance committee and who has been a major fundraiser for Democratic Party candidates. He served along with Bill Daley, Pat Ryan, Penny Pritzker and Julianna Smoot on Barack Obama 2009 presidential inauguration committee."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_W._Rogers_Jr.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:07PM (#24489177)
He’s a rich finance guy who is a major campaign contributor and fundraiser. That’s not the same as being a political operative, working in the White House, or the like.

For example, Brian McAndrews (also on the NYT board of directors) maxed out his campaign contributions to the RNC, Mitt Romney, GOP PACs, etc. But he also isn’t a political operative.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by areyousure on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:27AM (#24490975)
Seems like a very fine distinction you are making. John W. Rogers, Jr. is on the board of the Barack Obama Foundation, and his wife did literally work in the White House.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:23PM (#24465671)
Sure, because the Times is a newspaper and the Hoover Institute is a think tank. Part of the mission of a think tank requires having people with real world experience in government. I don’t think that’s a good proxy of whether the work is politically biased (rather than ideologically biased). Arguably, the Times is more overtly politically biased with its new “moral clarity” angle.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jjeaff on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:47PM (#24465891)
I think if they didn't have an agenda, at least with this specific topic, they would have included data on other states to compare to.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by dragonwriter on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:18PM (#24465648)
It's a right-wing ideological propaganda mill; it's “non-partisan” in the trivial sense that, like most “think tanks”, it has no formal control by a political party, and in the slightly more substantive (but also directly opposed to what most people try to communicate by “non-partisan” in terms of political bias) sense that, also like most ideological propaganda mills, it is devoted to an ideology much narrower than the big-tent views of either of the US’s major parties, which are both somewhat opportunistically shifting coalitions.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:31PM (#24465753)
By your metric, nearly every newspaper is a “left-wing ideological propaganda mill.” (My litmus test for that is whether the publication will credulously print the demonstrable untruth that “schools are underfunded” or “teachers are underpaid”).
[dead]
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by JamesBarney on Monday September 14, 2020 @03:11AM (#24467633)
This isn't necessarily due to underfunding.

Parents are supposed to provide their children school supplies. And many teachers are reimbursed for that.

Probably a better metric is dollars spent per student.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by dragonwriter on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:56PM (#24465964)
>>By your metric, nearly every newspaper is a “left-wing ideological propaganda mill.”

No, my metric is whether pushing an ideology is the overt mission, which it is for ideological “think tanks”, including Hoover.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Sunday September 13, 2020 @08:54PM (#24465477)
The Hoover Institution is really a stain on Stanford’s reputation. Full of pseudo-scholars who start with their conclusions and then hunt around for cherry-picked evidence, but don’t spend too much effort worrying about the details, and never bother to admit when they were wrong. It’s fitting that Condoleeza “we don't want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud” Rice is now the director.

The example of the day is Scott Atlas, Trump’s new darling “anti-Fauci” who (without any particular expertise in epidemiology or public health, and without any kind of convincing evidence or reasoning) has concluded that we should just give up against Covid19, and disclaim any responsibility for the results.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by guscost on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:12PM (#24465602)
You make it sound like it is uncommon for a think tank to publish research that helps its backers and allies. “The example of the day” (provided by NPR?) is just one small feature of a much larger landscape.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:16PM (#24465632)
No, it’s not uncommon at all. There is a whole industry of billionaire-funded GOP “think tanks” whose business is laundering bullshit. It still reflects very poorly on Stanford though.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by guscost on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:22PM (#24465669)
You really think that this phenomenon only happens on one side of the political aisle? I can’t relate to any worldview where that situation is possible.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:26PM (#24465705)
It’s not really comparable. The difference is that scholars who aren’t GOP operatives generally live in what one senior Bush-administration official derisively called the “reality-based community.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality-based_community

Of the people who work for CAP, Brookings, or the like, which ones do you think are hack pseudo-scholars?

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by guscost on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:28PM (#24465726)
This world of yours where there are presumably only “real intellectuals” in one camp, and a plague of “hack pseudo-scholars” in the other, is simply absurd. It makes no sense to me so I cannot comment on it.

I could go into how I feel about the whole cult of NPR news-announcers going after their enemies day in and day out, but you probably wouldn’t want to hear it.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jjeaff on Sunday September 13, 2020 @11:21PM (#24466433)
I have seen very little partisanship from npr reporters. Much less "going after" specific people on the regular.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by thu2111 on Monday September 14, 2020 @04:12AM (#24467923)
There's a lot of hack pseudo-scholarship going on in universities, almost all on the political left. Just yesterday there was this article on HN:

https://fantasticanachronism.com/2020/09/11/whats-wrong-with...

And that doesn't include the various grievance studies, nor, epidemiology, which turns out to be absolutely full of hack papers that cherry pick their sources, abuse citations, make absurd assumptions and then bury them in appendices, etc etc. If Dr Fauci has been replaced (didn't know that) then that's certainly just fine given the overall level of intellectual rigour and integrity in the field. You could use a bunch of laymen and get more trustworthy output.

The problem you're decrying is the proliferation of pseudo-science in general, it's not a political problem.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jacobolus on Monday September 14, 2020 @05:20AM (#24468257)
Your argument is: using a university’s reputation to lend credibility to abject bullshit written by career GOP political operatives in return for large donations from billionaires is okay, because grad students at universities often publish piles of methodologically unsound studies in their hurry to get their credentials and get out the door, especially in fields like evolutionary psychology, marketing, management, and criminology.

Seems like a complete non sequitur to me. We were talking about poorly researched and argued advocacy/opinion, not nominally peer-reviewed scholarly papers.

Your link specifically points out that political activism is not directly related to the problems of studies that won’t replicate: “Limited Political Hackery: Some of the most highly publicized social science controversies of the last decade happened at the intersection between political activism and low scientific standards: the implicit association test, stereotype threat, racial resentment, etc. I thought these were representative of a wider phenomenon, but in reality they are exceptions. The vast majority of work is done in good faith.”

But I won’t disagree that there are many problems with academic publishing and the for-profit journal industry; the publish-or-perish career system; the exploitation of grad students, postdocs, and untenured teachers; people throughout academia using statistical tools who lack basic training/competence in data analysis and statistical inference; etc.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by thu2111 on Monday September 14, 2020 @02:56PM (#24473753)
It's pretty much the same. I'm sure the Hoover Institution uses some level of peer review for their papers, except those peers probably get paid to review it whereas academics don't. Peer review doesn't do much, it's very much getting you to first base quality wise, often not even that. It can be effective if peers are able and willing to really go deep, burn bridges and object to the core thesis of a paper. Clearly not going to be true at the Hoover Institution but equally untrue within most academic fields.

Many bad papers are bad because they're actually political papers dressed up to look like science, thus (ab)using a university's reputation to lend credibility to abject bullshit. I know that link claims most of them aren't. I think that's good news. But note, that's because many of the papers that replicate, only replicate because they're making vacuous observations. Of the papers that get attention because they make surprising claims, many of them are politically or ideologically motivated.

Partly this depends on how widely you define politically motivated. For instance it's common for supposedly scientific papers to run a model, and then advocate for certain government policies based on the output predictions. This is political activity. It's also often not scientific because the models haven't been validated, and in fact if/when the political recommendations are acted upon it renders their predictions unfalsifiable, which a disinterested scientist should not want.

This problem is much larger than grad students. Bad papers are routinely being written by career academics, professors, large groups of them.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by microtherion on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:35PM (#24465790)
Just look at the sourcing of this report: The number cited comes from the random blog of a Texas real estate company, citing a random (paywalled) newspaper. That's barely the quality of work of a really lazy high school student.
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by guscost on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:37PM (#24465803)
What’s your point?
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by microtherion on Sunday September 13, 2020 @10:07PM (#24466039)
This is an absolutely ridiculous lack of scholarship. There's a good reason why HN prefers primary sources, and the moderators often replace links to secondary sources with the primary source. This particular submission has, at best, FOURTH HAND information (assuming that the Dallas Business Journal did not do original research).
Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by Guthur on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:13PM (#24465612)
Starting with a hypothesis (conclusion) is pretty standard, otherwise you are just poking around blindly.

The current "strategies" have only been sustainable because our economies had grown enough to sustain the blow, for now. Many countries don't have that luxury and eventually the West will feel it as well.

The strategies are based on a hope that a meaningful vaccine can be found in a timely fashion, and that is no where near guaranteed. So no matter which way you slice it it's all gambling with our lives.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jjeaff on Sunday September 13, 2020 @11:26PM (#24466457)
There is a big difference between a hypothesis and a conclusion.

You start with your hypothesis, then, after your research and study, you formulate your conclusion as to whether your hypothesis was correct or not.

If you start with the conclusion that your hypothesis is correct and only look for supporting evidence, that's bias.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by rayiner on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:06PM (#24465551)
Dr. Atlas had some bad judgment getting involved with the Trump administration, which has a unique ability to snap defeat from the jaws of victory. But you’re misrepresenting his policy recommendation, which is actually not that different than what has been tried in other countries:

> Dr. Scott Atlas is the Robert Wesson Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution, an accomplished physician, and a scholar of public health. For several weeks, Dr. Atlas has been making the case in print and in other media that we as a society have overreacted in imposing draconian restrictions on movement, gatherings, schools, sports, and other activities. He is not a COVID-19 denier—he believes the virus is a real threat and should be managed as such. But, as Dr. Atlas argues, there are some age groups and activities that are subject to very low risk. The one-size-fits-all approach we are currently using is overly authoritarian, inefficient, and not based in science. Dr. Atlas’s prescription includes more protection for people in nursing homes, two weeks of strict self-isolation for those with mild symptoms, and most importantly, the opening of all K–12 schools.

Other countries had relatively brief shut downs, and had targeted reopenings based on risk profile. Schools have been reopened in Europe since May: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/10/world/europe/reopen-schoo...

His view is probably the correct one, at least if anybody was competent enough to implement it. We should isolate high risk patients, quarantine the sick (real quarantine, like they do in Asia, not just “go home and infect your family” we do here), and let everyone else get herd immunity.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by dragonwriter on Sunday September 13, 2020 @09:11PM (#24465590)
> Other countries had relatively brief shut downs,

And if the US had actually ever done a shutdown right (or, on a smaller scale, if the few states that did do that on a state level had the legal and practical ability to impose the kind of travel restrictions against the rest of the US that almost every country in the world has against the US because of COVID), it (or those states, in the smaller scale case) might have started to recover after a relatively brief shutdown.

Re:California Businesses Leave the State by the Thousands by jjeaff on Sunday September 13, 2020 @11:29PM (#24466481)
I'm not seeing this one size fits all policy anywhere.

Many schools are in session. Many are not. Some types of businesses are shit down and other types are not.

As for heard immunity, the high r value of this virus indicates that we would need as much as 50-60% of the population to get infected before heard immunity starts working.