News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by learnstats2 on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:02AM (#24383598)
Your assumption that people must behave better in the presence of authority - and therefore worse in the absence of it - is exactly the assumption that is under question.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by oblio on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:04AM (#24383614)
They don't have to behave better in the presence of authority, they are forced to, that's kind of the point of authority :-)
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by __s on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:08AM (#24383637)
Unfortunately authority doesn't behave better in the presence of itself
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by oblio on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:18AM (#24383705)
True, but the real world is about compromises and lesser evils.

Formal authority is quite often better than arbitrary, informal authority. And make no mistake, humans are social, their natural congregations are hierarchical.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:33AM (#24383812)
I'm not sure this is true. Not only were humans very loosely hierarchical essentially until the invention of agriculture, but anarchism doesn't advocate for arbitrary and informal authority, but for limited in any authority at all unless absolutely necessary, in which case it must be directly kept in check.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by dragonwriter on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:59AM (#24384031)
> Not only were humans very loosely hierarchical essentially until the invention of agricultur

Even if they were both this and peaceful then, this would only imply that we merely need to dismantle agriculture and the civilization dependent on it to return to that state, which I submit is an unacceptable trade-off to most people.

And even if it was acceptable to most people, it would take only a small minority opting out to retain the power to subjugate everyone opting-in and ruin the whole effort.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:05AM (#24384076)
That doesn't follow from the principle. We don't need to dismantle agriculture or anything else, you can also have technological anarchic societies and indeed they exist.

What it means is that hierarchies are not necessary for human organization.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by dragonwriter on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:26AM (#24384247)
> you can also have technological anarchic societies and indeed they exist.

Where?

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:37AM (#24384320)
The Zapatistas are an example.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by dragonwriter on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:57PM (#24385003)
The Zapatista-governed area is at best parasitically technological (it uses imported technology, but neither creates nor maintains much of a technical base).

It certainly might be legitimately viewed as a step up for the most systemically disenfranchised, exploited, impoverished communities, but it's not a demonstration of a way that a technological society can be maintained.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by GrantSolar on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:43PM (#24384898)
That hierarchical structures became dominant after the invention of agriculture does not imply that agriculture necessitates hierarchical structures.

> And even if it was acceptable to most people, it would take only a small minority opting out to retain the power to subjugate everyone opting-in and ruin the whole effort.

Could you expand on this?

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by oblio on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:45AM (#24383911)
Regarding humans being organized very loosely until agriculture personally I wouldn't consider that as a plus.

We're on HN, just think about the pace of human development before agriculture and after. We were pretty much doing the same thing for half a million years and then in 10000 years: rockets in space! ;-)

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:57AM (#24384012)
Sure, but that still directly goes against the argument that humans are naturally hierarchical, because they aren't.

And there are ways to have agriculture and industry and compounding scientific advancements without having rigid hierarchies, are there not?

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by dragonwriter on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:40AM (#24384342)
> And there are ways to have agriculture and industry and compounding scientific advancements without having rigid hierarchies, are there not?

Sure, the absence of rigid heirarchies with strictly top-down authority in favor of fairly fluid ones with something like circular authority where the top of heirarchy is selected and changeable by the people subject to it is a hallmark of liberal society, realized to varying degrees throughout much of the world.

But that's not what anarchism is about.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:46AM (#24384400)
There are still ways to run agricultural and otherwise technological societies with minimal authority if any at all.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by oblio on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:19AM (#24384172)
They are hierarchical. All primates are. Agriculture just revealed the need for a level of social structure no other species on Earth could achieve before.

Regarding your follow-up question, maybe there are ways to achieve the same thing with a radically different social structure. The problem with social changes on this scale is that they are extremely disruptive. I'd rather reform and improve iteratively than rewrite the whole code base ;-)

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:36AM (#24384316)
You should consider the issues of iteratively improving the same code base, pushing to prod for hundreds of years!

Primate dominance hierarchies are weak, accountable, and constantly challenged, and not even necessary in humans which exhibit other behaviors depending on nature. As a consequences, hierarchy is not necessary in humans and not inherent.

That being said, there are ways to move into anarchism that aren't that disruptive as long as the dominant power structure doesn't decide to violently repress it. Syndicalism into market socialism into anarchism is a common one.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by oblio on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:12PM (#24384619)
I'd be curious where anarchism was applied on a large scale for more than a generation and the result was good.

Regarding the code analogy, I'd rather have a million pushes to prod than one huge force push that rewrites history;-)

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:49PM (#24384946)
But as I said, it's possible to transition to anarchy. You don't need to do it in one bit push. The issue is when the underlying code base is so bad that there is nothing else, but we can certainly try incrementalism.

In theory, there's no reason you couldn't go towards and anarchic society via a million small reforms, but in practice you get executed for using your already existing rights if you state that your goal is to do such reforms.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by djur on Saturday September 05, 2020 @03:26PM (#24386222)
Is it possible to transition to anarchy in a geopolitical environment of competing nation-states? How would an anarchizing state in the process of gradual self-dismantlement outcompete more centralized states in economic and military terms?
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by the_other on Sunday September 06, 2020 @04:31AM (#24389932)
The same ways any small country survives more than a few years.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by djur on Monday September 07, 2020 @12:17PM (#24400421)
The way most small countries have survived in the past century is to rely on the protection of a larger state with a powerful military and/or on international treaty organizations (UN, NATO, OAS, etc.) which derive their influence from those state militaries.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by andi999 on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:51PM (#24384967)
Actually it does, just better training required. I believe the police in Germany is pretty good, but you need at least 3 years (not month) of training.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Enginerrrd on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:18AM (#24384165)
That's funny, I see people behave badly even with the authority all the time.

In general though, most people behave mostly good. The ones that behave badly probably would under any social construct. The people I know that got into trouble with the law were the same ones with antisocial tendencies in grade school.

I don't believe that the threat of government enforcement really encourages a significant proportion of edge cases to behave better.

Due to some unique circumstances, I actually have had the opportunity to see what a relatively anarchist society looks like in low-density areas. It honestly works about the same as it does under more supervision. When the occasional real problems develop, people band together and act as their own police force. What there isn't is a bunch of technicality type laws banning you from doing things that don't affect others.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by PaulAJ on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:06PM (#24384577)
This is all about Dunbar's Number; the number of people you can "know" in the sense of having stable social relations with. Its about 150 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number).

A society smaller than this can be effectively self-policing because everyone keeps track of how everyone else behaves. No money, police, laws or prisons are required because everyone knows what everyone else thinks of their behaviour and wants to stay on the good side of the community that they depend on. So its not a problem.

Once a society grows past Dunbar's number this system breaks down. You see people you don't know misbehaving, but they don't suffer any downside because nobody knows who they are. When you have to deal with people you don't know if you can trust them, but you do know that if they rip you off you won't have any comeback. So the communal trust breaks down and you start needing police, courts, laws and prisons.

In short, anarchism and "primitive socialism" are nice, but they don't scale.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by ClumsyPilot on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:23AM (#24383742)
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes - who polieces the authority? Mind you an authority includes medieval kings and cobstantly warrrying feudal lords - they were legitimate authority of their time.

I would argue thay society today involve s less tyrany, less authority, and is more peacefull.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by tuesdayrain on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:11AM (#24383662)
I certainly behave better in the presence of authority. It's unlikely I am the only one.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:18AM (#24383703)
How do you behave when you yourself have authority? Would you stop respecting social norms and expectations if you did, and go on an egomaniacal power trip?
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by tuesdayrain on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:01AM (#24384044)
Currently I behave because it's in my interest to abide by laws, even those I don't agree with. If all authority disappeared overnight, I believe my best course of action would be to immediately assemble an armed militia so we could enforce a set of rules within a community that we believe are the best. I would still respect many social norms, but definitely not all of them. One thing that comes to mind is that "innocent until proven guilty" goes out the window. If I perceive someone to be a threat then I will use whatever means I have to neutralize them, rather than waiting for some kind of arbitration.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by daedalus_f on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:15AM (#24384135)
And this is why anarchy can’t and dosen’t work. 10 minutes later it will be replaced by a new feudalism led by people trying to make themselves king to protect their own best interests.

(Edited to a more general statement.)

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:13AM (#24384121)
Right, so you agree that it's better for you to have very limited power and exist without authority, in which case you'd have to confirm to most social norms or suffer consequences, than for authority to exist and for people like you to accede to it?

Because in our system, if you were to accumulate enough authority it wouldn't be in your interest anymore to follow laws.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by tuesdayrain on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:22AM (#24384217)
It's only better for me in an idealistic scenario where my local militia succeeds. If a bigger and stronger one comes around then my life could quickly become horrible.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:51AM (#24384448)
I'd a bigger and stronger far away stranger militia wanted to come and invade you it wouldn't matter if you had authority or not.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by username90 on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:01PM (#24384529)
It matters a lot if the authority is big enough that a random militia cannot topple them. A lone village can be raided with impunity, id the village is a part of a big country then soldiers will move in to protect them.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:50PM (#24384954)
There is no reason to have such a small authorities. Anarchic societies managed to maintain armies strong enough to deter state actors. It comes with some small sacrifices, but it's still much better than otherwise.

In practice, your village can come to an agreement with other small villages and do military exercises together while still maintaining autonomy, and you can then maintain complex weapon systems and large armies.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by username90 on Saturday September 05, 2020 @01:03PM (#24385054)
> Anarchic societies managed to maintain armies strong enough to deter state actors.

I don't believe that, any link? City states are not anarchic nor are tribes.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by learnstats2 on Monday September 07, 2020 @07:34AM (#24398674)
I think it's very naive to think a local militia system of government would work like the game Top Trumps.

You'd still have a bunch of people thinking you are a jerk - the reason your life might quickly become horrible is because you've been a jerk to pretty much everyone by claiming that you need to rule them by force.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by agumonkey on Saturday September 05, 2020 @04:45PM (#24386722)
I'm shocked at how nicely this is wired into our brains. The slightest sight of a cop car in my surroundings cuts all desire to drive even near the speed limits.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by learnstats2 on Sunday September 06, 2020 @05:11AM (#24390063)
I'd argue this shows that you are responding to the punishment, and have complete disregard for the authority (since you don't care to obey the rule when punishment is unlikely).
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by cortic on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:40AM (#24383870)
I certainly behave worse in the presence of authority. It's unlikely I am the only one.