News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by csb6 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:18PM (#24344948)
Yeah, it’s discouraging. But Hacker News is a place for capitalists (self-identified) or wannabe capitalists to hold discussions, and the site is run by a venture capital firm, so makes sense. Still discouraging to see the lack of education HNers have on unions. Maybe ignorance is a better word.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by Strang on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:40PM (#24346083)
Well-informed, good-faith disagreement is possible on a range of topics, including this one.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by grecy on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:23PM (#24347249)
I agree wholeheartedly, though I'm not seeing much disagreement or discussion, I'm just seeing downvotes on any comment that even suggests the remote possibility unions might actually be a good thing.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by umvi on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:23PM (#24345022)
> Still discouraging to see the lack of education HNers have on unions. Maybe ignorance is a better word.

In theory unions are great. In practice America's implementation of unions end up as a crappy caricature of the theoretical one and are nothing like their European counterparts.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by csb6 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:46PM (#24345311)
Maybe recently, with many American unions struggling just to survive, but historically (in the late 1800s to middle 1900s) American unions have been incredibly effective and pioneering.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by umvi on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:55PM (#24345459)
> but historically (in the late 1800s to middle 1900s) American unions have been incredibly effective

So basically unions were good for ~50 years until the Mafia infiltrated the Teamsters?

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:45PM (#24346141)
Unions in the western world in the post-war period made historical compromises with industry that helped contribute to 30-40 years of relative labour peace and high middle class prosperity. They purged communists and other radicals from their ranks, took anti-Soviet positions, and adopted cooperative and conciliatory bargaining positions that gained higher pay and job security by dropping some of the more classic demands of shopfloor control and political change.

As a result unions started to look more like guilds than classic unions, they became managerial organizations like the businesses they were attached to, and they often lost legitimacy with their own memberships as a result.

When the economy started to contract in the 70s they weren't in a good position to fight, and their influence waned. And when the Soviet Union collapsed in the late 80s they lost any kind of bargaining position -- nobody was afraid of the reds anymore, so they didn't need the unions or social democrats or Keynesian liberals to pacify the population and stomp out communist sympathy.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:38PM (#24346049)
I think it's maybe a bit more subtle. In our industry there's what I call the "California Ideology" (after the classic essay: https://www.metamute.org/editorial/articles/californian-ideo... which is a bit dated but still stands the test of time)

At one point this perspective was fairly counter cultural -- computing technology fused with Alvin Toffleresque third wavism, a tinge of libertarianism but without a suit and tie, some LSD, some cyberpunk, wear jeans to work, "change the world", etc. But that sheen is increasingly wearing off.

The reality under the surface dressing is we are part of an industry with deep military ties, and it doesn't matter if you wear jeans to work and get vegan treats in the cafe, there's nothing particularly radical about computing technology and while we're "changing the world" it's really not in any egalitarian or progressive way.

We're part of a semi-managerial class that is doing on the whole pretty damn well financially, but there's no reason to expect that to last forever.

A lot of us ran around saying "information wants to be free" in the 90s and so on, it looked a bit naive to me then, but now it just looks comical and sad.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cactus2093 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:56PM (#24346293)
> and while we're "changing the world" it's really not in any egalitarian or progressive way

There is a good argument to be made that increasing the GDP is a moral imperative [0]. I know it's increasingly trendy to think all of capitalism is evil and we should tear the whole global economic system down (and to tweet about it from your iPhone while sitting in your air conditioned home, eating your meal delivered by Doordash). As much as it is true that inequality is higher than it should be, and there are lots of things in the world that should be improved, it's also true that for the vast majority of people in the US and around the world, their living conditions today are much better than they would have been at any other time in history. Which is the simple result of compounding economic growth.

Talking about "changing the world" by building an app sounds a bit quaint and too self-serious these days, but I really don't think it's true that the average person working in tech contributes nothing positive to society.

[0] https://www.mercatus.org/bridge/essays/economic-growth-moral...

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:13PM (#24346460)
I don't fully agree with your point, but I've upvoted you anyways, because this is an entirely reasonable response argument to the points I made and that's how HN is supposed to work.

But please note I didn't say anything like "the average person working in tech contributes nothing positive to society." That's pretty ad hominem, and I don't think that, otherwise I wouldn't work in this industry.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cactus2093 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:11PM (#24347741)
Well I appreciate the good-faith discussion. And fair enough, I didn't intend to put words in your mouth, I was interpreting "not in any egalitarian or progressive way" as meaning "not in any positive way". But I can see how you might not have been making that strong of a claim.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by hehebbssjj on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:25PM (#24349435)
> As much as it is true that inequality is higher than it should be

I just spent time with a friend who is working two jobs during the pandemic and cannot afford to live on their own in our relatively low cost of living city. They have to ride the bus for 2 hours to get to one job. This isn't even global inequality, this is an order of magnitude income difference between "haves" with high tech jobs that realistically produce no value, and "have nots" who actually make society function.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by dang on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:14AM (#24362199)
Could you please stop creating accounts for every few comments you post? We ban accounts that do that. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

You needn't use your real name, of course, but for HN to be a community, users need some identity for other users to relate to. Otherwise we may as well have no usernames and no community, and that would be a different kind of forum. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cactus2093 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:56PM (#24349573)
Well I'm sorry that your friend is having a tough time. But you really didn't respond to, much less refute, any of the main points of what I wrote here.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by hehebbssjj on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @06:35AM (#24351837)
My point is extracting the maximum value from people by paying them almost nothing because it "increases the GDP" isn't a moral imperative. It's absurd on its face to say that growth at any expense is ethical because of some trickle down bullshit.
[dead]
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by csb6 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:41PM (#24345250)
It’s partially self-interest, true, but speaking for Americans, there really is no widespread, institutional education on what labor unions are or do, and what benefits they can bring. Most people simply don’t think about them or believe whatever their employers’ PSAs tell them to believe because no one else ever talks about labor organizing to them.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by cactus2093 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:40PM (#24346089)
You're talking about union education as if it's equivalent to mathematics or something, like there is an absolute truth to be learned. Surely even the most pro-union people would acknowledge that not every implementation of a union is equivalent? And that some have caused harm?

I would say I'm union agnostic, I'm not against them but I have about the same amount of faith that a union will improve things in a given situation as that the government will. Both are supposed to be a representation of the people, run by the people, and both are often too bogged down by bureaucracy and power seeking to actually do anything constructive. Sure there are great historical examples of unions accomplishing great things, just are there are great historical examples of governments passing landmark laws, but neither of those guarantees that these institutions will do the right thing in any future scenario.

And to the extent that I am going to put trust in one of these institutions, I'd rather choose the government. I'd rather see, for instance, healthcare given as a right to every citizen, than healthcare given to employees in just one industry. And in fact, unions have been some of the strongest opponents of medicare for all initiatives in the US in recent years. They've already negotiated good healthcare benefits for their members and they don't want everyone else who's not a member to get it too. This kind of "us vs them" incentive system doesn't appeal to me. And more fundamentally, I strongly believe that a lot of basic things (again, like healthcare, or disability insurance, or the ability to invest in a retirement account) should be much less coupled to employment than they are today, and unions are a force in the opposite direction.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by notJim on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:44PM (#24347985)
> You're talking about union education as if it's equivalent to mathematics or something, like there is an absolute truth to be learned. Surely even the most pro-union people would acknowledge that not every implementation of a union is equivalent

Just like in school civics class you probably learned about the concepts of the government is structured, the principals behind it, a bit about other approaches, etc, I don't see why you couldn't learn the same things for unions. Of course the government doesn't really quite work like that, but isn't it better to have a baseline understanding and shared idea? The situation with unions now is that basically the only thing people know about them is propaganda from anti-union groups, unless they happen to be in one. I fail to see how this is better. It would be like if you first learned about democracy from a monarchist telling you how bad democracy is.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:45PM (#24346148)
The government isn’t a good comparison. Unions hold no illusions about acting in the interests of the general public. Their express purpose is to protect the members of the union, even if that comes at the expense of the general public.

Police unions defending corrupt police and ensuring they can collect expensive public-funded pensions after blatant misconduct against the public is a prime example.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by mf_tomb on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @08:12PM (#24348625)
Most unions try to act in solidarity with labor in general, through organizations like the IWW and the AFL-CIO. Police unions aren't labor unions, as the role of police in society is to enforce the current capital distribution. This is counter to the goals of the rest of the labor movement, and there's currently a push to boot the IUPA from the AFL-CIO.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by Kalium on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @07:46PM (#24348454)
I routinely see people postulate that unions act primarily in the interests of the general public. Unions may not claim that, but at least some of their supporters do.
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:41PM (#24346092)
I don’t understand this desire to dismiss any criticism of unions as ignorance. This attitude that the only way someone might oppose unionization is because they’re too dumb to understand the concept is extremely condescending.

Take a look at the current situation with police unions defending bad cops, for example. The union is just doing its job in protecting the cops, right? But in reality, this can come at the expense of others who are adjacent to the unionized employees. It’s not a simple matter of employees versus their employer.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by csb6 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:57PM (#24346977)
I am not dismissing any criticism, just the problematic fact that no one talks about unions except corporate PSAs. There are no institutions or traditions to support labor organizing in the way there once was. Like the idea of joining or forming a union is alien to most Americans.

> they’re too dumb to understand the concept is extremely condescending

This is a bad faith interpretation of my post. I did not say people are dumb. I believe the opposite; working class and middle class people can absolutely understand unions. My point is that there are no movements or institutions to bring awareness or organize people, and so people forget the history of labor organizing in this country. People intuitively get what’s wrong, there’s just no longer any vocabulary to express it. It’s not stupidity, it’s a multi-decade effort by capital to erase unions from the public consciousness. People just don’t talk about organization anymore, it’s a social phenomenon, not an individual one.

> Take a look at the current situation with police unions

Police unions are not part of the unionization movement because police are not on the side of workers. Police are tasked with defending property and the owners of property are overwhelmingly capitalists or other relatively wealthy individuals. In fact, many of the most deadly anti-union activities (e.g. attacking strikers) have been performed by police.

Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by 205guy on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @09:02PM (#24348955)
Agreed. My high school economics education was limited to supply and demand curves. It would be so beneficial to having a class about household budgeting, loans and interest, credit rating, mortgages, property, investment, stocks, LLCs/corporations, capital, unions, labor law, taxes, government budget, deficit, trade balance, etc. All the things that people have to learn later in life, hear biased people/media who pretend to know the answers, or never really understand (I guess such a course wouldn't get to Quantitative Easing anyway).
Re:Amazon deletes job listings for analysts to track ‘labor ... by ThrowawayR2 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:03PM (#24349307)
> "...there really is no widespread, institutional education on what labor unions are or do, and what benefits they can bring"

I watched the UAW's behavior in Detroit for a couple of decades. That's all the education anyone needs to conclude that unions aren't in anyone's best interest.