The reverse-problem is a pet-peeve of mine: It seems many people have been accidentally brainwashed by Hollywood into thinking that film-camera effects are signs of "realism."
So then the first-person game introduces something like lens-flares, and everyone goes: "OMG it's so realistic now", even though the truth is the exact opposite. If you were "really there" as Hero Protagonist, you wouldn't have camera-lenses for eyeballs except in a cyber-punk genre.
Plop a nature video next to your forest rendering and it’ll become apparent just how unsolved trees are. And everything else, for that matter.
The precise claim is this: viewers should be able to identify a rendered video no better than random chance. If you conduct this experiment, you’ll see that real videos from actual video cameras wipe the floor.
To be fair: have you run such an experiment yourself, or are you just assuming that this conclusion will always result?
(But note this is only replicating video, not reality. Truly realistic motion blur requires ultra-high displayed frame rates beyond the capabilities of current hardware.)
If you're driving at 200 mph, and there's a car next to you also going 200 mph, it shouldn't be blurry.
Also, the length of the blur should not exceed the distance an object travels on your screen in 1 frame. In other words, if an object moves 30 pixels from one frame to the next, then the blurred image shouldn't be more than 30 pixels wide.
What CG videos are you considering, what specifically have you looked at? Can you show some good faith examples of the best CG forests ever made, compared to some specific nature videos? Are you talking about attempts to match a nature video, and saying it's not possible regardless of what's in the shot?
Are you looking at the best examples of CG forests lately? There are some CG full frame video examples of forests I don't believe people would reliably identify as CG, if they didn't know before hand and you left out the explosions & spaceships.
The problem is that we can't do that in 1/60 second on consumer-priced hardware, and also both scanning real objects and manually modelling are expensive.
"The Dress" illustrates how easy it is to fool people with still images. Movement gives crucial context. Our visual system has evolved for millions of years specifically to exploit that context.
That were capable of getting pretty close isn't that surprising, because most photos have already had N layers of digital effects applied, moving them closer to renders, rather than the other way around.
The point is, currently it only works for simple scenes and needs tons of manual work otherwise. Reality is realistic effortlessly.
If you think the answer is obvious, then CGI definitely has more work to do. If not ... ??
If this is CGI, then I'm impressed and want to see more from where this came from.
Agreed with you that I'd be super impressed if anyone could render at that quality, but I haven't seen it yet.
But in the full version[0], it's clearly a photo. But it has been HDR'd which can sometimes create shading that gives a somewhat rendered look.
(Although, maybe you could argue that if the challenge is to make photorealistic renders rather than realistic renders, nailing the camera artifacts is part of the challenge.)
> we do not understand how to make graphics look real > none of those equations work
Why do you claim this, and what do you mean exactly? Surely you aren’t claiming we can’t make any graphics look real at all. Some people are getting pretty good at understanding how to make some graphics look real, even if we aren’t. The math for approximating materials and lighting is getting pretty good these days, and the equations have been changing over time. It’ll continue to improve, but it’s certainly not the main thing holding CG back today. IMO less realistic CG comes much more from low resolution or low fidelity sampling / geometry / textures / animation / input data in general. Most of that is due to lack of time & money.
I’d say we understand how to make graphics look real in many cases, but not in all cases. We understand how to make good looking graphics, but how to do it quickly and efficiently enough to be practical and done with limited time and effort is an open problem.
Making graphics that look real is almost equivalent to the Turing Test, I think plenty of people are willing to acknowledge that it's unsolved.
Amusingly relevant yet slightly off-topic: https://existentialcomics.com/comic/357
Graphics — even movie quality graphics — don’t look anything like what a camera produces. The sole exception is when you’re mixing in real video with CG elements. But try to synthesize an entire frame from scratch, then put it next to a video camera’s output, and people can tell the difference.
Also, screenshots are misleading. You have to test video, not screencaps. Video is processed differently by the brain.
10 out of 10 times, all the graphics engineers come out of the woodwork going “but actually we do know how! It’s a matter of using so and so calculations and measuring BDRF and” none of those equations work.