News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by wisty on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:02PM (#24327497)
> Banks don't increase the total supply of money, all fraction reserve does is keep more of it in circulation.

It doesn't increase currency (M0).

But is there 'money' in your bank account? They increase money by a slightly broader definition (accounts + currency).

Even if you've got a narrower definition (and just want the physical paper to be defined as money, not entries in a database) then they don't increase the amount, but they greatly amplify its effect by increasing the velocity of circulation (which you did mention). One little bit of money is being thrown around between owners much faster, which effectively magnifies its impact.

Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by sukilot on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:10PM (#24327537)
Right, but people who get .ad that banks create "money" don't understand that "money" is not the same as "currency".

Money is literally defined simply as "currency plus bank accounts" so obviously funding a bank account creates "money".

Your post gets into the velocity and momentum of money, which is yet another concept.

Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by baobabKoodaa on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:14PM (#24327556)
No, there is no single, accepted definition of money. Money is not "literally defined as..." anything. For example, if you look at Wikipedia definitions for money, you will find multiple different definitions. The commonly used definitions seem to vary a lot by economic area.
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by jkhdigital on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:44PM (#24327725)
No, there is a definition: Money is a commonly accepted medium of exchange. The problem is not that there is no accepted definition of money, but rather that this definition actually encompasses a very broad class of assets, each of which has some interesting and unique characteristics that can be defined independently of the definition of money. Talking about "money" by itself is often not specific or helpful enough for the subject at hand. Mises does an excellent job of defining a taxonomy for money and money substitutes in his book The Theory of Money and Credit.
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by QuesnayJr on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:33AM (#24329492)
I think it's better to say that the boundary of "money" is a bit vague, and things vary in their "moneyness". So sometimes a broad definition is more appropriate, and sometimes a narrow one is more appropriate.
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by eru on Sunday August 30, 2020 @10:38PM (#24328032)
In earlier times in many jurisdictions banks could create bank notes, too. See eg https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/29/there-was-no-place-like-can...

An advantage of that system was that banks did not lose reserves when customers withdrew money, ie converted deposits to cash.

(The banks lost reserves when those notes were eventually deposited with rival banks who demanded settlement in underlying reserves.)

Of course, even that system did not multiply the amount of reserves; you might call them M(-1), if you are so inclined.

Historically the underlying base money was gold, but you could imagine a system with private bank notes built on top of the federal reserve dollar just fine. You can even leave physical Fed cash in circulation, too.

Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by AmericanChopper on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:14PM (#24327555)
What's _actually_ in my bank account is a mixture of cash, other peoples debt, and other assets, that all adds up to the value listed when I log in to check the balance. Part of the service the bank is offering me is that at any time I request, they will exchange all of that for its' cash value if I want to make a withdrawal. This is the bit that people contrive when they make silly claims like "banks can make money out of thin air". You bank balance of $x does not translate to $x of cash (physical money or not, is irrelevant) on the banks ledger, waiting for you to withdraw it. It translates to $x worth of cash + assets held by the bank.

They do it by keeping enough money laying around doing nothing, to service those withdrawals. If all of a sudden huge amount of customers started making huge withdrawals, they wouldn't be able to service them, because they wouldn't be able to liquidate those assets immediately. If banks were actually creating money out of thin air, this wouldn't be possible, because they'd just be able to create some money out of thin air to service them.

Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by baobabKoodaa on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:20PM (#24327584)
If you go and read the article you will find that it agrees with everything you posted here, with the exception of your weird conclusion that "banks do not create money out of thin air". The article uses a simple example to illustrate that, using Eurozone M1 definition for money, loaning factually increases the amount of money which exists. Perhaps you are thinking of a different definition of money?
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by AmericanChopper on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:38PM (#24327671)
Because Eurozone M1 doesn't account for the debt that backs some of those balances. That's like suggesting you can increase your net worth by taking out a loan. You can increase the amount of money you have to spend right now by taking a loan, but you're not "creating net worth out of thin air".
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by jkhdigital on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:50PM (#24327766)
But debt isn't "negative" money. In fractional reserve banking, money and debt are like matter and anti-matter: money is created along with debt, and when the debt is repaid the money is actually destroyed. The money is purchasing power now; the debt is a claim on future purchasing power.
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by esailija on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:45AM (#24329049)
The interest portion is never destroyed though. If you loan 50k you might pay back 60k and only 50k is destroyed. Another wrong assumption is that loan gets paid back.

Unpaid loans and interest are not accounted for and create a need for even more loans to create more money out of thin air but of course those additional loans also have interest and are also unpaid so it spirals out of control.

Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by imtringued on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:33AM (#24329253)
Interest is just a fee. Your bank may charge you extra to compensate defaults which "destroys" part of the interest, it may charge a processing fee, a profit margin and then finally the actual interest rate the central bank sets.

Both the processing fee and profit margin circulate within the economy. They are not part of the loan, they are fees the bank is charging and using to pay its employees and shareholders who then spend that money. It is entirely possible that you are working for a bank and receiving that money as a paycheck, or your bank is purchasing services directly or indirectly from a company that you are working at.

When you think about it, central banks are not any different. They charge a fee and then send the profit to the government which then can spend it on services that eventually employ you.

You own a farm and borrow 50k from a bank that has $10k in its reserves. The loan has a duration of 10 years at 2% interest so you have to pay back 60k in total. You pay back $6k every year. The bank purchases $1k worth of food every year. The end result is that you have paid $60k to the bank and the bank has paid you $10k.

Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by baobabKoodaa on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:45PM (#24327729)
If you go and read the article, you will find that I use terms like "due to accounting conventions" or "economists decided to count these IOUs as money [but not some other IOUs]". Is there something in the article that you disagree with?
Re:Banks create money, but it's less impressive than it sounds by eru on Sunday August 30, 2020 @10:40PM (#24328041)
Well, what's actually in your bank account is only one thing: a special kind of bank debt.

That bank debt is backed by all the kinds of bank assets that you mention. Plus perhaps some government deposit insurance.