News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by n1vz3r on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:14PM (#24326395)
The article is just an opinion and some claims, supported by zero evidence. Yes, Google is interested that Web continues to live. But article omits that Google only wants the Web that exists on Google's terms. That's why they practically rebuilt the web themselves, on all levels, from protocol to the client (spdy, webp, amp, dart, chromeos & android, chromium).
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by badrabbit on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:29PM (#24326915)
They make changes to web standards and force it's adoption. Innovation is one thing but this is far from a democractic internet.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by blinkingled on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:41PM (#24326985)
But that is also progress. If it wasn't for Google's investment we would still maybe running Flash. People have had a lot of time to advance the web before Google came along.

The standard is open, the code is open - I don't understand how "is Chrome the new IE?" even a question. It's not like they're bundling it only on ChromeOS and Android , it's not like they have the equivalent of VbScript /ActiveX and plenty of people are making browsers based on Chromium.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by badrabbit on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:57PM (#24327099)
I do think google innovated a lot but I think htlm5 killed flash not google. Html5 is a web standard. Chrome is very much the new IE, it use to be I was forced to run IE for some b.s. legacy corporate webapp now I am forced to run Chrome. Why? Because devs have to prioritize a browser and the amount of non standard supposed engineering by google means they can't support other browsers.

Google is playing a winner takes all game of dominance. Imagine if Ford became so popular that mechanics can't be bothered to fix other cars because Ford does everything differently.

People are being forced to base browsers on Chromium because no one will use anything else due to sites depending on Chromium only features! This is very anti-innovation.

You came up with a cool new feature in firefox (like containers) and you want to standardize it? Well if uncle google says no you're out of luck. Standards exist for a reason and engineers(even at google) use to have enough professionalism to respect the concept and process of having an internet where everyone participates democratically.

I hate to keep on coming to similar conclusions but Browsers need to be regulated if the browser industry is always being overrun by some monopoly.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by Tijdreiziger on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:04PM (#24327150)
Apple killed Flash.

HTML5 just provided a suitable replacement for Flash, but suddenly having a large browser (Mobile Safari) that just couldn't play Flash content at all provided the incentive for web devs to actually invest the effort to switch to HTML5.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by clankyclanker on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:53PM (#24327444)
This is the correct answer. To add historical perspective, I had friends who would go into Apple stores and point all the demo machines at newgrounds.com to show people that they shouldn’t waste their money on devices that couldn’t even play flash animations as well as a low end laptop.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by reaperducer on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:12PM (#24327203)
If it wasn't for Google's investment we would still maybe running Flash.

It wasn't Google, it was Apple that very famously and publicly killed Flash.

https://web.archive.org/web/20200614182254/https://www.apple...

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by blinkingled on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:43PM (#24327383)
Most browsing still happens on desktop and without the equivalent HTML5 standards there would be no replacing Flash. Last I checked Apple really isn’t a big web standards pusher or implementer. I guess people just have to romanticize everything Apple. Sure it was a factor but Apple hardly was the only factor.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by jakelazaroff on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:02AM (#24328646)
It’s very revisionist history to say that Apple has never been a big standards pusher or implementer. Basically every modern browser engine other than Gecko is descended from Apple’s Webkit.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by rudiv on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:20AM (#24328714)
Apple WebKit itself is descended from KDE's WebKit IIRC.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by jakelazaroff on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:53AM (#24331440)
KDE's browser engine wasn't called WebKit, but you're correct that WebKit began by forking it. That doesn't contradict my point, though.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by blinkingled on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:18AM (#24331682)
Porting KHTML to macOS and honoring its license to keep it open is very different than contributing to the HTML5 standard and implementing cutting edge features quickly. The latter helps with killing Flash more than declaring we are not going to support it.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by reaperducer on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:44PM (#24327722)
Apple made Flash a no-go on mobile. At the time, people had no distinction between mobile web and desktop web, so if your web site didn't work on an iPhone, it was forgotten and left in the dust.

Today, you can be on one or the other. But that wasn't the case back then.

Last I checked Apple really isn’t a big web standards pusher or implementer

I'm sorry you wasted your time checking on something that I didn't state.

people just have to romanticize everything Apple

No romanticizing needed. I was there, and lived through it.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by blinkingled on Sunday August 30, 2020 @10:14PM (#24327903)
> I'm sorry you wasted your time checking on something that I didn't state.

Just saying no Flash use our app store apps without contributing to open xp alternatives does not amount to killing Flash. Making the alternative better, accessible to all in an open way does.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by userbinator on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:50PM (#24327052)
The standard is open, the code is open

"standard" means nothing when Google is churning it every day. It coined the completely idiotic term "living standard" and has basically used its propagandic powers to drag everyone else along.

Its idea of "progress" is the exact opposite of what the web needs.

Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9961613

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by earthboundkid on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:48PM (#24327031)
If Google had succeeded we’d be using Dart (yuck) instead of ES6 (yum).
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by xrisk on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:43PM (#24326993)
it’s about the kind of ecosystem they’re attempting to build – look at AMP for example
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by MattGaiser on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:21PM (#24326448)
I would classify those threats as different. Microsoft as one of dominant neglect and Google and one of dominance.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by wlesieutre on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:25PM (#24326474)
Google has a reputation for getting bored of projects and shutting them down, if they controlled the web it’d be gone in six months and everything would have to be AMP
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by xnx on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:32PM (#24326524)
It cuts both ways. Shutting down projects that aren't core can also be seen as focusing on what matters. Google shutting down products also gives room for other companies to fill that need. The Google Reader shutdown was the besting thing ever to happen to Feedly. I wish Firefox was a little more aggressive in shutting down some of its side-projects to focus on the things where they can provide value that other strictly-commercial companies will not.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by edoceo on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:19PM (#24326860)
Looking at Pocket. Hey, FF I want to love you but I feel you lack focus. Also, fix the autocompleter on the URL bar on mobile - it should not aggressively autocomplete when I'm pressing bksp !
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by Tijdreiziger on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:08PM (#24327175)
I haven't personally encountered that problem on mobile, but Fenix (the new Firefox for Android) was rushed out, and it sadly does show.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by edoceo on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:25PM (#24327279)
I'm on Android, using Firefox 79.0.5 (Build #2015758619) - which is like freshest bits for GP - it's where they moved the address bar to the bottom.

So, go to a long URL, like paging through a forum. Then edit the URL. Place cursor at end and hit bksp. As you continue to delete chars the purple-phantom highlight where it tries to autocomplete goes crazy and flickers the heck out of the UI. It's definitely a regression.

I don't know the best way to capture screen on this device tho, and I don't have time to spin up any emulators and go through those steps

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by Tijdreiziger on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:46PM (#24327402)
> it's where they moved the address bar to the bottom

Yup, that's Fenix. By the way, you can switch it back to the top, but the (+) button (new tab) still remains at the bottom, which irks me.

I actually just tried and I'm not seeing your issue - but I have different issues (mainly that when I open the browser, the topmost tab can never seem to figure out whether it has a page loaded or it's on the new tab page).

By the way, I'm just a fellow user, so don't spend too much effort describing your bug to me, haha. It might be worth reporting it to their bug tracker, though: https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/fenix/issues

If your device happens to be a Samsung phone, it should come with a screen recorder (at least on the newest major version of Android)

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by ekianjo on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:08PM (#24327178)
> Google has a reputation for getting bored of projects and shutting them down, if they controlled the web it’d be gone in six months and everything would have to be AMP

They haven't shut down Search yet, even though it's pretty boring as a service.

I'm sure you can understand there are "core" projects, and non-core ones.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by wlesieutre on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:10PM (#24327194)
They can put their ads in the AMP pages, what do they need the rest of the web for?
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by The_rationalist on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:33PM (#24326537)
I wonder when they will drop Google Search, about the time they should get bored soon! Oh unless such belief doesn't make any sense for product that are necessary to Google lucrativity? Yes, Google devs on non necessarily lucrative projects such as flutter or dart might get bored to some extent.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by ekianjo on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:07PM (#24327169)
> But article omits that Google only wants the Web that exists on Google's terms.

That's probably why the team behind Chromium is composed of so many contributors who are not at Google?

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by saagarjha on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:15PM (#24327219)
I hear this argument come up a lot and frankly it's just misleading to even bring it up. When a company controls an open source project, the project follows their vision–regardless of whether there are a couple other groups with slightly-more-than-nominal contributions. Ask yourself whether any one group could prevent a commit from going in that Google corporate had decided they wanted in Chromium–the answer is of course no. It'd be like saying Apple doesn't have essentially full control over WebKit's direction, even though this page lists a bunch of people who aren't from Apple: https://webkit.org/team/
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by ekianjo on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:22AM (#24328723)
Free and Open-Source projects, unlike IE, can be forked anytime by just anyone or any other organization. There is nothing preventing anyone to go ahead and rework Chromium for their own needs - and that's what happening in practice already with Brave, Edge, etc...

The day that people/organizations are upset with the direction Google takes with Chromium is the day where a real fork will start existing and being actively developed by a larger community.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by afiori on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:32AM (#24331824)
For this I would propose a litmus test for forkability of a project. If the original parent company disappeared would the fork be able to sustain its development and maintenance alone?

For current chromium forks (and also for firefox forks) the answer is no.

The only fork that would have the resources would be from microsoft, but it would be a huge, expensive, and non-trivial task.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by ekianjo on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @08:44AM (#24341162)
> If the original parent company disappeared would the fork be able to sustain its development and maintenance alone?

The counterexample is the Linux kernel. No single company can actually sustain its development, so in practice many companies work on it together with an agreed governance to direct where things go.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by afiori on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @09:53AM (#24341705)
Indeed Linux is not forkable in practice, most current forks rely on the cooperation and coordination of the linux foundation at least partially.

For chrome as long as google exist I don't really see an industry consortium to invest in marginal improvements (considering also how the interested industry partners are likely heavy google customers)

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:33PM (#24326939)
Don't forget WebRTC, currently on the HN front page. Web-based peer-to-peer introduced by Google.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by sebazzz on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:06AM (#24332188)
I think you forget AMP and related technologies to empower it like HTTP Signed Exchanges.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by tssva on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:18PM (#24326422)
Your comment is just an opinion and some claims supported by zero evidence.
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by zakki on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:31PM (#24326519)
Aren’t all protocols gp mentioned the evidence, are they?
Re:Chrome is not the new IE by Chyzwar on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:42PM (#24326607)
spdy become HTTP2, quic become HTTP3 it is expensive in time and money to develop and test new ideas in protocols. I think it is a bit unfair to to bundle android, chromium and AMP into same bag. AMP is clearly driven by money but there is a lot of open source that benefit everyone.

Google is big company. I think trying to paint whole google as evil is not effective.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by rhacker on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:31PM (#24326921)
It's like this beast that does these benevolent things, but at some point it catches up to them and they shut something down after getting people kinda hooked. For example Picasa - massively popular - free and pretty amazing desktop photo management tool. It slowly morphed such that all of the users of it were just folded into a cloud offering: Drive.

Chrome and all of it's open source awesomeness, again, mostly used to fold people into the bigger profitable picture. So even though there are developers that work at Google creating protocols that help everyone, including non-Chrome browsers - that benevolence has a product manager paying that developer's time. At some stage it's not all free beer.

Re:Chrome is not the new IE by tssva on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:37AM (#24332531)
It is a list of protocols, applications and operating systems which the the commenter is assigning some sort of nefarious intent to with no evidence.