News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by hetspookjee on Sunday August 30, 2020 @04:34PM (#24325713)
I wonder if Google or Microsoft would stop this indirect way of copying through Google Maps. I think Google would claim copyright on the 3d scanned data that is available through Google Maps. Without this the Open Source community wouldn't be able to as easily shovel this over through programs into MSFS.

Though I think Microsoft would be out of harms way for as long as they don't blatantly paste back the user improved buildings. However, obviously not all improvements are gathered from Google Maps and dependent on the scale this might become an issue in detecting these.

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by macspoofing on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:55PM (#24326700)
Reminds me of the Bing IE toolbar 'copying' Google search results 10 years ago [1]. It turned out it wasn't that Bing was actively copying Google search results, but rather it was learning what search terms entered into the toolbar correlated with what page users went to after the query was executed.

[1]https://www.wired.com/2011/02/bing-copies-google/

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by tomerico on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:30AM (#24328749)
So they listened to the search queries configured to Google and learned the clicked results. How is that not copying Google's search results?
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by kuschku on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:18AM (#24329428)
They listened to users searching anywhere in any search engine, and just storing the correlation (search term → clicked website).

Google actually does the same, through their own analytics.

It's just that so many more people visit Google than Bing or Yahoo that automatically 90% of the (search term → clicked website) mappings are recorded on google.com

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by maxerickson on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:39PM (#24326972)
It's a violation of Google's TOS to extract the data (so copyright doesn't matter a lot).
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by ookdatnog on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:03AM (#24329636)
I don't understand copyright law particularly well, but I'd expect it does matter here.

The TOS only applies to the person extracting the data. So if person A extracts the data, violating TOS, then puts it up on a website where it is downloaded by person B (who did not necessarily ever agree to Google Maps' TOS), then only A has broken TOS, B hasn't. But B may have violated Google's copyright.

Is that right or am I missing something?

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by echelon on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:51AM (#24328596)
It's against Genius' TOS to copy their lyrics.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by vincengomes on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:12AM (#24331087)
Luckily for Google, Genius doesn't "own" any lyrics.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by echelon on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:51AM (#24332016)
Seems like the law should be written so Google doesn't "own" any of their mapping data either.

They didn't create the roads, and there's no human actively taking the photos.

It's not like the law cares about effort when it sided with Google against Genius.

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by jjeaff on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:40AM (#24339433)
And Google doesn't own those buildings nor the architectural design.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by mda on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:14AM (#24328921)
bad analogy
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by pbhjpbhj on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:21AM (#24329697)
Why do you say that, seems like a good comparison to make.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by cma on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:29PM (#24326080)
There would be no copyright on a 3D scan in most jurisdictions, but maybe on any manual cleanup work.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by sgtnoodle on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:06PM (#24326335)
A 3D scan seems like it would be as copyrightable as a photograph would be.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by roywiggins on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:19PM (#24326427)
The argument is that a photograph is a creative work (there are lots of decisions that go into it) whereas a scan is a mechanical reproduction, and therefore isn't creative, and so can't be copyrighted at all.

I don't know what the state of the law on this is.

https://boingboing.net/2016/06/01/why-3d-scans-arent-copyrig...

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by sgtnoodle on Sunday September 06, 2020 @05:03AM (#24390043)
It seems like it comes down to the content, not the form. If I arrange a scene with a bowl of fruit on my dog's head and take a photograph of it, or a 3D scan of it, I can call it a creative work either way.

If a photographer operating a photo booth at a party can claim copyright on the photos, then someone making 3D scans of party guests as they pose should be able to claim copyright also.

Taking a 3D scan of a random building should be just as copyrightable as taking a photo of the same building. One could argue that neither should be copyrightable, but all the photographers I know would say any photo they take is "creative work", even if it was done with a smartphone camera in auto mode. If simply framing or cropping a photograph is what makes a photo creative, the same concept scales to 3 dimensions just as easily. You have to decide how much of the building to capture, whether to include the parking lot, the nearby power lines, etc.

With a bulk capture of geography, I suppose the photographic equivalent of a 3D scan would be aerial photography or Google's street view or something. Is that copyrightable? I assume Google and other companies act like it is. Someone had to decide the resolution and precision to capture at, at least.

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by gerash on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:34PM (#24326943)
IANAL and I wish those who aren't either mention that. But with that line of argument images from Hubble telescope wouldn't be copyrightable either but they are: http://hubble.stsci.edu/reference_desk/faq/answer.php.id=92&...
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by javagram on Sunday August 30, 2020 @11:09PM (#24328173)
IANAL either but the images from the Hubble have “artistic” work that goes into them just like a landscape photograph does.

Choices like the the framing, color saturation levels, etc.

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by sio8ohPi on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:58PM (#24327104)
Are they actually copyrightable? STScI is of course free to assert that they are, but that doesn't make it so.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by CamperBob2 on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:24AM (#24328482)
How does that make sense for a taxpayer-funded resource? I'm sure that some projects that rent time on Hubble have private funding, but does that apply to all of them?
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by Beldin on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:40AM (#24328787)
That images taken by hubble aren't used commercially without paying a license fee to NASA? I imagine the tax payer is okay with getting some money back.
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by ben_w on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:20AM (#24329437)
NASA stuff isn’t copyrighted, and only the logo is even trademarked.

> NASA content - images, audio, video, and computer files used in the rendition of 3-dimensional models, such as texture maps and polygon data in any format - generally are not copyrighted.

(https://www.nasa.gov/multimedia/guidelines/index.html)

I believe the reasoning is that everything paid for by your tax money should be free for everyone. I think some state-level governments prefer your argument.

Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by myko on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:40PM (#24326594)
I hadn't thought of that but when you say it, it seems obviously true
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by pkaye on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:43PM (#24326615)
What about the cleanup work done on 3d scans?
Re:Players are fixing Microsoft Flight Simulator’s monuments... by greggyb on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:50PM (#24327047)
It depends on how much original creative effort went into it. Copyright is fuzzy on purpose.

Copyright vests automatically and immediately in the creator of a creative work. This can be assigned or licensed to another party in part or in whole, at the discretion of the copyright holder.

Whether a work is creative, and therefore protected, by copyright is open to interpretation.

Facts cannot be protected through copyright. A creative representation of facts may be protected. E.g. a specific map might be protected, but this wouldn't prevent someone from making another map representing the same places