News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by smabie on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:03PM (#24320522)
It's pretty common for not poor people to buy lottery tickets. When the NY lottery was really big about 3 years ago, everyone at my old firm put in a $100 (so like 7k total) to buy tickets. Ended up winning $200, so we bought some champagne.

I noticed other firms doing the same thing, with the convenience store guy telling me that the building in total spent over 100k on lottery tickets within a week or so.

Moreover, the lottery isn't a fraud. The mechanisms and payouts are all known, much like roulette or blackjack. We have a word for it, and it's called gambling (not fraud).

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by addled on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:47PM (#24320689)
I feel the fraud part is when states claim having a lottery will provide more money for schools and then in the following years they cut general education spending.

I even remember hearing ads on radio encouraging folks to "pay-it-forward" by buying more lottery tickets and framing gambling as charitable giving.

"For the children" indeed.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by Covzire on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:04PM (#24320766)
At least in the US, gross lottery revenue is only a fraction, about 1/8th the total expenditure on K-12 education.
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by smnrchrds on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:07AM (#24321501)
I think John Oliver put it best:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by protomyth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:30PM (#24320624)
I've worked at a couple of places that better than average paid folks pooled some money to buy Powerball tickets. Its low grade gambling and a little bit of team building. I do remember the big one in the late 90's we won our money back which actually was much more difficult than just losing.

I was asked to buy $120 worth of tickets in 94ish and not one damn winning number showed up on any of the tickets. It was requested I never buy for the group again.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by cainxinth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:56PM (#24320729)
I think the people buying scratch offs every week are gambling. The people who buy a Powerball or Mega Millions a few times a year, when it gets huge, are just doing it just for entertainment’s sake and have no serious expectation of winning.

It’s still problematic, but the real argument for keeping the lottery is that without it, organized crime would start running more of their own numbers games again.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by phobosanomaly on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:02AM (#24321270)
Agreed. It definitely makes sense from a harm reduction standpoint, keeping people from turning to more predatory options.

At the same time, it's pretty sickening to see the normalization of dangling a pipedream in front of people trapped in lives of 'quiet desperation.'

It's a 60% best solution, where the next best solution is 20% best.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by zaroth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:56PM (#24320728)
> It was requested I never buy for the group again.

Hah! Obviously they should have sent you to buy the tickets, scoured them all for missing numbers, and then sent someone else to buy those.

I would guess that buying $120 of tickets and not matching even a single number is extremely improbable! You were the golden goose, just inverted.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by protomyth on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:40AM (#24321412)
If I remember right, the odds were better to win the lottery than do what I did. I did pull out a probability book at the time. Born under a bad moon I guess.
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by lefstathiou on Sunday August 30, 2020 @11:10AM (#24323393)
The lottery is not gambling because the probability of winning the lottery is 1/290 million making the expected payout almost zero in most circumstances; which is significantly less than black jack and orders of magnitude harder to win.

Under what other circumstances would be possibility tolerate that low level of efficacy?

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by jrs235 on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:37PM (#24324383)
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by chinhodado on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:27PM (#24320872)
While I don't really care about the lottery and I'm fully aware about the odds, whenever there's a buy event in the office I always join. I consider that an insurance against my coworker winning.
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by WarOnPrivacy on Sunday August 30, 2020 @03:54AM (#24322018)
You might have just described an election.
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by BoorishBears on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:53PM (#24320708)
What percentage of your combined salaries was 7k?

How many people were playing the lottery weekly?

How many people were playing the lottery with the mentality it was the only way to achieve financial freedom?

-

Do you really not see the difference between poor people gambling daily and well-off people joining in on it as a spectacle?

In case you need it spelled out... it's no surprise the poorest populations consistently end up putting the most into the lottery because of weaker educations, lower financial literacy, bleaker financial outlooks

https://cnsmaryland.org/gambling/lottery/lottery.html

https://madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/wiscons...

https://southsideweekly.com/illinois-lottery-exacerbates-ine...

The story is the same all over the country. It's easy to sit back from a comfortable place on here and say "well the odds are right there, can't they see how low they are??" but it certainly doesn't show strong social awarenesses...

-

The worst part is the most vulnerable people aren't getting out nearly what they put in between a lack of social safety nets and the fact these groups tend to be the most underrepresented in their governments.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-02-21/where-cas...

> “In almost every case states either earmark the funds for education but then decrease the general fund appropriations for education by a similar amount, or, in more cases, they simply put the money in the general fund,” says Denise Runge, a dean at the University of Alaska Anchorage and editor of Resorting to Casinos: The Mississippi Gambling Industry.

In fact in some cases, these lottery are literally taking from the poor and giving to the middle and upper classes.

There's the merit-based scholarship example in the article, but even cases where funds end up being used on things like "historical preservation"... historical preservation is great, but feeding the hungry and giving the homeless places to sleep feel like much better investments in our populations. There are tons of "feel good" initiatives in a similar vein

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by smabie on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:16PM (#24321086)
I think what you're saying is that lottery tickets function as a regressive tax, along with cigarette and alcohol taxes. The poorest and disproportionately taxed with these kinds of products.

It's a good point, and many economists are against regressive taxation.

But people want to gamble and you're not going to change their behavior by eliminating the lottery. Before state run lotteries, numbers games were very popular and run by organized crime.

The government has much less power to change people's behavior that many assume. After all, the drug war has been a historic failure, just like prohibition before it.

You might as well make these kinds of activities legal in order to reduce violence and disempower organized crime.

People are gonna do what they want to do and ultimately, they are responsible for those (possibly poor) decisions. You can't protect people from themselves, only try and give them the tools to make decisions that maximize happiness over their life-time.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by BoorishBears on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:49PM (#24321221)
No one is saying gambling should be illegal or the government should somehow force people to stop gambling...

But there is so much that could be done to try and limit the damage it's doing to poorer populations, and increase the good it's doing for those populations at the same time.

Bans and restrictions on advertising lotteries, limiting points of sale per sq. mi., actually using the funds as claimed when instated, focusing on the types of gambling and their effect on addiction rates (https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/in-excess/202003/pro...), changes to the actual act of playing the lottery (even things as simple as purchasing process can have profound effects on how people get their "hit" from gambling).

Look at cigarettes, they're still legal, yet through policy America has gone from a country where the vast majority of adults smoked (almost 70%), to one where less than 15% of the population does.

Now this being HN I need to put the disclaimer that I'm not saying every piece of tobacco legislation maps perfectly to gambling if you Ctrl+F replace... but it shows how truly vast the gully between banning something and letting it proliferate is.

If there was truly interest in helping these people there are countless levers that could be used to try and balance the scale. But there's the perverse combination of financial incentive to do nothing, and political disincentive to do anything as long as politicians can get away with their treatment of these people.

Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by smabie on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:56AM (#24321464)
But cigarettes are an extreme example of a tax on the poor, just like lotteries. From your rhetoric, I would have imagined that you would be against the aggressive taxation on cigarettes. I know I am.
Re:Why does the government let a company like Herbalife stay... by BoorishBears on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:14AM (#24321518)
I even gave the disclaimer it's own paragraph.