> Perhaps I'm preaching to the choir, but learning about
> entrepreneurship or practicing selling things would have
> been much more useful to me than many of the things I
> learned in high school or undergrad.
Does that have anything to do with your current life goals, by any chance?You shouldn't argue from your personal viewpoint here. Sure, in retrospect it would've been great if school had taught me statistics and neurobiology from year one. But that is not what general, state-sanctioned education is or should be about. I suspect that for 80% all kids, entrepreneurship classes would have been a costly waste of time.
There are at least two ways to look at education from a purely economical POV: signal theory (I take someone from Harvard because he was able to go to Harvard) vs human capital theory (I take someone from Harvard because of the things he learned at Harvard).
Of course, there are still many more aspects to it: I take someone at Harvard because he met people at Harvard... and I am myself coming from Harvard, etc...
More simply, I am glad most of what I have learned was "useless" in some sense. What's useful or not changes in times, you cannot necessarily know what's useful to you when you're 15, and you could argue that one of the role of education is to teach you things you will never see otherwise (to expand your horizon).
1. Converse with the great ideas of the past directly (definitely still true.)
2. Enrich one's mind by learning a superior language (like learning Haskell to write better PHP...speak better English by learning Latin. Still true.)
3. Learn a language found everywhere (not so true anymore.)
4. Learn the language of law, medicine and theology (sort of still true.)
5. Learn a foundation to learn Romance languages more quickly, as has been said.
6. Learn it just because it's there and a Renaissance Man has to take a crack at everything. Will be true as long as the language exists!
Finally, I strongly object to the idea that the purpose of Latin is to be "elite." Back then, anyone who went to school would at least learn a little Latin. So, you can say the purpose of having school is to be elite but not the purpose of Latin, because Latin wasn't taught to a subset of children until the 20th century. Today, Latin is taught to anyone who wants to learn, regardless of whether they go to school. My wife is a Latin tutor and about half of her students are below the poverty line or minorities -- and several adults are also receiving instruction from her.
The general observation is that learning ANY language eases learning the third and the fourth language, because the earliest experience in learning a non-native language reminds the speaker that each language has arbitrary features that must be distinguished from those of the learner's native language(s). Within the ambit of that general principle, learning cognate languages (for example, German for an English speaker) is easier that learning non-cognate languages (for example, Malay for a Chinese speaker).
Algebra and geometry, I feel, are still important today (see SAT). Greek and Latin are less important, although they are still in the background. The humanities have changed and we now learn about more modern authors / topics and the humanities classes in general have cooler names (i.e. Microcomputer Application in Kinesiology or Topics in African Society and Culture).
There's probably some bigger point I'm missing here like "those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it" or something similar.
Teaching kids about how to conjugate Latin verbs or some other rote activity always seemed pointless to me. Perhaps I'm preaching to the choir, but learning about entrepreneurship or practicing selling things would have been much more useful to me than many of the things I learned in high school or undergrad.