Re:Zoom Partial Outages
by hashkb on Monday August 24, 2020 @10:16AM
(#24260863)
Not because they have the best quality, most secure, or most reliable product, though. So rather than cut them some slack and wait, this is a good opportunity to explore alternatives.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That's debatable. Perhaps not the most secure, but possibly the best quality and most reliable (to this point, at least). Depends how you define quality, but the ease of use and high quality video are perhaps the leading factor in their huge success.
Re:Zoom Partial Outages
by Normal_gaussian on Monday August 24, 2020 @10:48AM
(#24261196)
This is something I've seen several say, but I totally don't get. I've been using jitsi, gmeet, slack and zoom for the last six months; and that is my order of preference with zoom dead last. Quality on zoom is definitely the worst.
I’d argue most reliable for the most people, however. Even if that’s only because many people already have the client installed and are accustomed to it. It’s not completely random that zoom is so popular.
Let's explore. What alternatives are there?
Re:Zoom Partial Outages
by Lunatic666 on Monday August 24, 2020 @10:40AM
(#24261122)
I'm actually always surprised how well AWS Chime [0] works. Probably because not too many people use it.
Re:Zoom Partial Outages
by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Monday August 24, 2020 @10:43AM
(#24261146)
The only person I know who uses Chime works at AWS, and even they hate it.
Large parts of Amazon finally got the go-ahead to use Slack internally instead of Chime.
Re:Zoom Partial Outages
by Lunatic666 on Monday August 24, 2020 @10:57AM
(#24261286)
But at least they're dogfooding – the feature list is really short, but the quality is always good. I also wouldn't want to use it as my only conference tool, but if zoom is down, it makes a good backup.
Jitsi, WebEx, Microsoft Teams
Webex. No temporary unmute. Can’t see myself, why can’t I be a full size panel?
Jisti. Can’t dial in. Utterly useless for anyone with bad internet for this reason.
> Jisti. Can’t dial in. Utterly useless for anyone with bad internet for this reason.
You can dial in (at least for a call on https://meet.jit.si - I don't about self-hosted instances).
Click the person symbol ('Invite more people') in the bottom-right of the window, and a modal dialog will appear with a phone number and PIN code to enter.
If you click 'more numbers' you will be shown alternative phone numbers for many countries (UK, US, France, Germany, Netherlands, Spain, Canada, Australia, Brazil, Japan, Switzerland).
Jitsi running on matrix/riot/element works pretty well IME. Dunno if schools would be able to provide the necessary HW/funding for full day streaming though.
Ok, they do have the best product..
I like Jitsi better than Zoom. No install needed. Only thing is that it makes my CPU run hot. Any reason you think Zoom is better?
Can't dial in to Jitsi *(without some additional setup)
Actually, you can: https://github.com/jitsi/jigasi
Needs some setup, but if you are using Jitsi that seems reasonable
Fair enough.
My university uses Blackboard Collab, its a pretty solid solution imho and apparently integrates nicely into Moodle.
Google Meet
Re:Zoom Partial Outages
by junkrat002 on Monday August 24, 2020 @10:39AM
(#24261105)
I prefer Google Meet
I find the quality of google meet is variable, especially with lots of users on the call.
I haven't had quality issues with Meet. The killer feature for me though is the seamless integration with calendaring--if you use GCal of course.
Skype
Group FaceTime.
Typically, FaceTime requires knowing people's personal contact info. Zoom,Google,etc have generic looking URL for people to join without giving up personal contact details. I don't necessarily need everyone I work with having my personal contact info.