News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by mindfulhack on Sunday August 23, 2020 @03:38AM (#24250287)
Bias.

It affects everything.

Science, religion, politics, public policy, company policy, policing, the judiciary, journalism, and (any)one's decision-making regarding 'facts'.

Not sure how we're going to solve it on a platform like Facebook.

The systems governing over it - government and politics - are not going so well in the bias department themselves.

As for 'the people', they're just as biased. In fact, that's where it comes from. The problem is humans, not the technology.

Even though I have low regard for them, sometimes I realise Facebook is doing the hardest job in the world.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by tails4e on Sunday August 23, 2020 @04:58AM (#24250632)
The problem is the technology too. For the first time in history can two people see the same information source (in this case Facebook) but see two completely different worlds, as each one gets their own bubble, and that bubble is biased. I often see friends Netflix accounts and prefer what they are getting suggested than mine, as Netflix presents me the bubble it thinks i'll like, and I never see the other variation that I want (unless I look at others' accounts), so can't easily expand beyond my bubble. In Netflix's case they want me to see more content, but in Facebooks case they are perfectly happy with bubbles as it makes their targeted advertising easier. Sometimes I'd like to know that the version of a site I'm seeing is the same as others as I really don't want to be in my own information bubble.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by Nextgrid on Sunday August 23, 2020 @07:31AM (#24251160)
It’s less about technology per-se and more about mismatched incentives and a toxic business model. Facebook and most social networks are not incentivised to give you a “true” or at least unbiased version of the world, they are incentivised to tweak it as much as they want in order to increase engagement.

This wouldn’t be so bad if people were aware of this and would check alternative sources or take steps to mitigate that, but a lot of people seem to not know, forget or ignore this fact.

As a less serious example, I always create new music streaming accounts and start fresh (as a perk I get unlimited free trials) every month simply because none of them offer a permanent “incognito” mode and I find my recommendations forever poisoned just because I happened to check out an irrelevant song/album (or let friends use my phone to play music for a party and their tastes differ from mine). This is actually what I miss about radio, where you get an unpersonalized view of the current musical landscape - unfortunately ads are a dealbreaker so I just stick to “hacks” like this instead.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by Lammy on Sunday August 23, 2020 @03:25PM (#24254553)
It's the technology too, down to the little things like (for example) priming somebody to want to comment on a divisive topic by surfacing those topics to their feed as "Friend commented" edge stories if there's an argument going on. FB's model doesn't know it's an argument and that asking a person to take part will increase the overall level of human-to-human hate in the world. The model only knows what to do to make Facebook the most money.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by chillacy on Sunday August 23, 2020 @06:44PM (#24255922)
What makes it worse is there are certain topics where there is no objective, unbiased view beyond believing what most of your peers believe.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by mindfulhack on Sunday August 23, 2020 @07:00AM (#24251061)
Yes, great point, absolutely. On that level, things can be done. Suppose I'm talking on a bigger / higher level. (My mind tends to go 'straight there'.) Thanks for giving some hope.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by kingkawn on Sunday August 23, 2020 @06:05AM (#24250852)
The presumption that there is a possible unbiased perspective is itself the most insidious form of bias.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by hleszek on Sunday August 23, 2020 @06:28AM (#24250921)
The presumption that there are always multiple perspectives and that they might be equally valid can be another bias. Especially in the news. Sometimes one party is clearly right and the other is clearly wrong.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by kingkawn on Sunday August 23, 2020 @01:39PM (#24253656)
I said nothing of equal validity, that’s a straw man. I am saying that the Objective position is not real, and better to assess the subjectivity for its usefulness for a given problem.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by luckylion on Sunday August 23, 2020 @07:00AM (#24251058)
That's very rare though. Usually, the impression is achieved by intentionally leaving out facts to make the picture look more clear cut. Once you go into the details, in most cases, clarity goes away and everything gets fuzzy and grey.

But nobody wants to read "it's complicated, here are some facts so you can figure out your thoughts on the matter", so we tend to cut away half and paint the rest in broad strokes to turn that into "This is reality, and here are the monsters who deny it".

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by BrianOnHN on Sunday August 23, 2020 @07:31AM (#24251161)
I'd love to hear these "details" that paint conservative-trump supporters and their quack-anon conspiracies as anything other than monsters.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by luckylion on Sunday August 23, 2020 @07:56AM (#24251266)
Incentivizing people not to work leads to people not working.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by BrianOnHN on Sunday August 23, 2020 @08:05AM (#24251303)
That's a straw man argument based on your assumption of second or third-order consequences.

Edit: No politician anywhere ever introduced a bill with the intentions of "Incentivizing people not to work."

Even "shutting down the economy" has the intention of being able to get back to 100% sooner and thus maximizing total output/GDP/work over a period longer than the short-sighted days/weeks immediately ahead.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by luckylion on Sunday August 23, 2020 @10:00AM (#24252002)
The point is that pretending "conservatives just hate the poor" is the broad brush. The moral hazards of vast government social programs are the part that gets fuzzy and grey: it has great benefits in the moment, keeping people housed and fed. But it also has great disadvantages: making them lose their motivation and agency and making them permanently dependent on those programs.

But if you zoom out and leave away the negatives: monsters!

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by Falling3 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @10:44AM (#24252295)
Redlining, voter suppression, consistent attacks on important services (DMV, USPS, healthcare providers), drug testing for welfare recipients (despite the fact that these programs cost more than they save), anti-abortion crusades.

There is a long list of evidence for conservative attacks on the poor in the US, which is in no way limited to programs like where the criticisms you mentioned apply - although I don't believe those criticisms are made in good faith to begin with anyway.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by luckylion on Sunday August 23, 2020 @11:33AM (#24252581)
It appears that you're not interested in the point I was trying to make, but just want to fight with somebody about your political convictions. I'm not that somebody, I don't care about your domestic problems.

I care about the behavior you're showing though, because that unfortunately isn't contained to the US. "The other side are all monsters" is common, that's why it's a problem. But you must get over "... but they really are monsters" to be able to see the problem, I'm afraid.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by Falling3 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @01:18PM (#24253461)
I responded to the point you tried to make; let's not pretend otherwise.

I have a lot of problems with your analysis. Your original comment argued that conservative policies towards the poor are out of some concern for the future unintended consequences. I replied because we have mountains of evidence that is not the case. You then go on to straw man me with a false dichotomy that the Right's policies are either done out of some genuine altruism or that "they're monsters". We can acknowledge the reality of the situation without resorting to such ridiculous reductionism.

And finally, I'm not looking for a fight about my political convictions. I'm correcting one more instance or a narrative that has plagued modern political discussions for decades. Both sides are not the same. And it's either ignorant or disingenuous to claim otherwise.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by Lammy on Sunday August 23, 2020 @03:10PM (#24254449)
> correcting

I believe this is what they are trying to get at. No ill will intended, but it seems pretty futile to try to "correct" the way another person experiences the world since any viewpoint a correction comes from is inherently a property of observation at some place+time+culture. I think earlier societies' greater homogeneity tricked us all into thinking objective reality is a thing that exists.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by kingkawn on Sunday August 23, 2020 @01:40PM (#24253663)
Sorry, conservatives do hate the poor. That’s an objective fact born out by their behavior, not my bias.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by cringepirate on Sunday August 23, 2020 @06:42AM (#24250979)
Not at all.

When people normally talk about a unbiased perspective they are talking about objectively presenting, discussing or evaluating a given topic (within the realms of what is possible).

Saying it is impossible (which I think is tenuous at best, but I for the purposes of argument I will concede it) is not seeing the wood for the trees. As long as people are trying to be objective (even if they fail) it is much better than just giving up and just not even attempting.

Many people seems to think of things in terms of absolutes. Just because you cannot being completely objective it doesn't mean that one shouldn't try.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by mellow2020 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @09:03AM (#24251607)
Nobody said you shouldn't try. But part of that is calling out those who talk of being "unbiased" or "objective" not as a shorthand, but as something they seen think is actually within their possession.

> It is not the greatest of modern scientists who feel most sure that the object, stripped of its qualitative properties and reduced to mere quantity, is wholly real. Little scientists, and little unscientific followers of science, may think so. The great minds know very well that the object, so treated, is an artificial abstraction, that something of its reality has been lost.

-- C.S. Lewis

> We have to remember that what we observe is not nature herself, but nature exposed to our method of questioning.

-- Werner Heisenberg

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by cringepirate on Sunday August 23, 2020 @09:35AM (#24251830)
> Nobody said you shouldn't try.

Actually a lot of people do say exactly that. I've heard it quite often both online and in my personal life.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by mellow2020 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @01:44PM (#24253699)
Sure, but that has nothing to do with the comment it was in response to, which does in fact not say that.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by cringepirate on Sunday August 23, 2020 @09:22PM (#24256784)
The rationale behind that statements leads to the attitude of not even attempting to be objective. So while you are correct the statement on its own does not state that. I believe it will lead many to believe it isn't worth the attempt. I believe that to be dangerous because it then allows you to engage in sophistry.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by mellow2020 on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:49AM (#24257835)
> The rationale behind that statements leads to the attitude of not even attempting to be objective.

What is "the rationale behind that statement", other than intellectual honesty? The statement is true, not even attempting to be objective does not follow from it. Denying it to achieve something that isn't even gained by its denial is a refusal to be more objective, plain and simple.

> So while you are correct the statement on its own does not state that

.. I'm still at -1. Not because what I said is wrong, but because some would prefer it to be wrong or something.

> I believe that to be dangerous because it then allows you to engage in sophistry.

That also doesn't follow. I would even say that is sophistry. The statement is true, it doesn't become untrue because of things you claim would follow from it, even if you had shown how they follow from it, which you did not.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by cringepirate on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:07AM (#24257908)
I don’t even believe that being unbiased is impossible so I do not even believe it is a true statement to begin with. I believe it is said by those that want to justify their sophistry.

I fundamentally don’t think you understand what I am saying from this reply. Therefore I think any discussion past this point on this matter is worthless.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by oblio on Sunday August 23, 2020 @07:47AM (#24251228)
1. It should at least be something to strive for.

2. Some biases are more harmful than others.

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by kingkawn on Sunday August 23, 2020 @01:37PM (#24253639)
1. If it is an inherent falsehood then striving for it will render its outcomes false.

2. Some ideas, some people, some foods, some air, some planets, some shoes, some economists, some...

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by bluesign on Sunday August 23, 2020 @10:14AM (#24252099)
I think the problem is ‘wrong bias’ which is directly related to overestimating self, which is basic human nature.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by swayson on Sunday August 23, 2020 @05:08AM (#24250671)
Technology amplifies the effect though.
Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by intended on Sunday August 23, 2020 @11:10AM (#24252441)
True. But not in this case.

FB and most sites which have a bias against, say conspiracy theories, regularly find themselves against conservative forces which for, whatever reason, have a willingness to expound and accept conspiracy theories.

> https://phys.org/news/2018-12-political-views-people-false-d...

Can't find the original articles which showed how conspiracies thrive in different political groups.

This then creates the new phenomenon that people here are trying to explain.

IF BOTH groups were equal, the bias in action would be then on FB's end.

Both groups are NOT equal, and frankly American conservatives (as a group) are far more often to be targetted and spreaders of conspiracy theories and misinformation.

This means they are also the subject of far more actions.

Since they are the subject of far more actions, this creates a political opportunity.

As you can see in this discussion, there is a difference between Perceived Skew of Moderation, and Actual Skew of Moderation.

Now people can say "See, we need to deal with FB in congress, because they do more against Conservatives! We suffer more action!".

Since FB is also in california, and accused of being "liberal" this accusation is even easier to sell, since it is already believed.

FB responds by giving them extra passes, so that they don't get called out or forced to handle new legislation which complicates an already complicated field.

----------

Its really interesting to see how the argument here hinges entire on people's perceptions of what the world is ("both sides are the same") and reality (one side is more affected than the other)

Re:Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to c... by EricE on Sunday August 23, 2020 @06:00PM (#24255638)
“ FB and most sites which have a bias against, say conspiracy theories, regularly find themselves against conservative forces which for, whatever reason, have a willingness to expound and accept conspiracy theories.”

lol - Conspiricy is hardly a “conservative” issue. Heck just look at the now thoroughly debunked Russian collusion hoax.

Pizzagate? Laughed out and mocked but over time more and more evidence of perversion among elites surfaces. The most recent being “Cuties”, the “award winning” movie about twerking (their word, not mine) 11 year olds Netflix just started to promote. That award, BTW was from Sundance - where one of the co-founders was convicted and faces six years to life for.... pedophilia.

Yup - all just conspiracies. Which is the fun of conspiracies - they can provide great cover if deployed appropriately.