News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by simonh on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:37AM (#24223076)
On the other hand we have no direct evidence for Inflation and no idea what the Inflaton field is, what causes it or where it went. Yes I know the theory makes some predictions that have turned out to be correct, but if there are other theories that can also predict the same outcomes they deserve a hearing.

I don't think there's anything dogmatic about keeping an open mind. If you want to see dogma at work, see a reply to another comment of mine here where I'm ranted at about what is or isn't 'Scientific' and questions being 'non-scientific' simply for pointing out that the Big Bang isn't a complete model of the origin of the universe.

There are a lot of unanswered questions in this area and it's far from clear to me at least how they will be resolved, but I'm very excited to find out. I just don't think mud slinging about dogma and being non-scientific is going to help with that.

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by ziotom78 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:55AM (#24223232)
> Yes I know the theory makes some predictions that have turned out to be correct

However, I must say that once P. Steinhardt gave a seminar in my department, and he debunked two famous "predictions" of the inflationary theory (flat universe, scalar index n_s slightly less than ne) showing that papers published in the 90s claimed that inflation predicted "naturally" an open universe with a scalar index larger than one [1]. He used this to stress the fact that inflation can predict almost everything. I must say he sounded very convincing, he wasn't claiming that inflation is false, only that it is far from being a well-established theory, and that other hypotheses must be considered as well.

[1] http://physics.princeton.edu/~cosmo/sciam/index.html#facts