Because what you're saying goes both ways. The bank doesn't have the right to take money out of my account to pay a loan except for what was arranged as a payment plan.
That's not Brigade Capital's problem, and that's also not Revlon's problem.
I think it's entirely obvious brigade should return the money. But, playing devil's advocate:
Brigade gets a payment, 'out of nowhere' (it wasn't agreed upon beforehand, nor part of the repayment schedule), from the bank of Revlon, earmarked 'revlon'. Hey, the intent is clear enough, and Brigade sees this as an implicit contract. This transfer can be seen as equivalent to a note from the bank: "I, CitiBank, in my function as the bank of Revlon, hereby prepay some of the debt, and whilst revlon did not personally sign this note, that is okay because I am their bank, you can trust me."
And Revlon, having made no such agreement with citibank, also 'wins' their case and this money isn't scratched out of their accounts.
CitiBank, having made the error, is going to have to eat the 9 digit loss, but is of course allowed to recoup it, according to the normal schedule, and without charging interest (not that this matters much, what with interest being near nil), vs. revlon.
If revlon goes broke before they can, that's a bad day for citibank.
NB: To be clear I think when talking about 9 digits, this is a preposterous interpretation, but it IS one.
The only way you get anything remotely resembling something such as an implicit contract is by butchering the legal concept into unrecognizability, which admittedly, the tech sector has enabled other sectors to do with wild abandon. A contract requires a meeting of the minds, consideration for all, and to explicitly lay out mutually agreed upon terms. Unless both sides agreed to see it the same way, it isn't a contract. It's a worthy subject to resolve via litigation, and to be frank, out as the Brigade at significant risk of possible criminal charges if a judge is not amused and Citibank heads to the Attorney General.
eg, If I agree to pay my babysitter $50 and write an American-style check (aka bank draft), me and the babysitter don't need to negotiate the finer details of that payment method.
If you accidentally paid off a loan early do you think you would be able to get your money back from the bank?
My thinking is if they do this with Citibank and a hundred million, I have no confidence in being able to recover my own money in case of a dispute.
In 2018, I was laid off, lost almost everything over five months. I had one bill on autopay that I eventually ran out of funds to pay. IIRC in June 2018, WF stopped denying repeat ACH attempts if, on the first two attempts, the funds were not available and/or WF would not choose to pay it and simply overdraw the account. Every single attempt would now process. On December 3, my account was at $490 when the $600 payment attempted, then again, and again, over and over, for 9 business days. My account was closed with a -$1,800+ balance. I lost count of the number of NSF fees by day four or five. And Wells Fargo decided to pay that payment upon closure of my account. So, I went from $490 on December 3, 2018, to owing almost $2,000 in fees to Wells Fargo two weeks later.
I'll pay it off when I can, as you know, it's still my debt, but while other banks were cutting fees, WF was changing its policies to ramp them up. I ended up in an unfortunate waltz of financial doom with them. And I had a low statistical risk of running into a problem with them because I used so few of their services. Don't leave it up to luck. When you see risky behavior, grab your money and go. They're willing to keep doing crap like this because they know most people think it would never happen to their personal accounts.
Turns out her mother had been depositing the $50 each week automatically until she was about 17, but was also randomly over the years withdrawing nearly all of it. And at the time she went in, she was -$240 on the account, and they wouldn't allow her to close it until that was paid off, and they were going to continue feeing her $20 each month for having less than the required amount. By the time we finally had the income available to close the account it had accrued around $1000 in fees.
And yet, for some stupid reason, I am still with Wells Fargo today, 15 years on...
Why?
I hate to rub salt in your wounds, but they have demonstrated that they are unworthy of your business. Acting on this would play a small part in forcing them to either change, or else go out of business.
If it were me in your shoes, the amount of raw spite I would feel for Wells Fargo would be difficult to exaggerate.
Long ago I stopped all auto payments from my checking account. I do the old fashion thing of paying each bill every month on a schedule. I don't really send checks, it is all via bill pay and I can schedule them out in advance so I only really do this twice a month.
Edit: That is if it is a legitimate error-error not citibank try to pull a takesy-backsy.
What kind of duty? Not a legal one, I think.
It's like a natural process to these companies. Most likely CITI is getting it back. But it's probably a worthy gamble on the lawyering fees.
Frankly, the entire chunk of money should be considered legally tainted until legal action is resolved; which means escrow it somewhere and unleash the lawyers.
All of a sudden, we may see some consideration given to proper verification ( not just quick rubber stamp ).
Even if Revlon goes under because the courts pull what I'd call a derp, it should create the illustrative case that creates a business niche for higher reliability/risk financial transactions.
So have George Soros and Carl Icahn.
I used to think that this kind of repuational thing meant something. I pick Don as one of many examples just because he's literally gone on from that situation to become the president. Banks need to make big loans. If they make you a big loan, they owe you - go go broke it matters to them. You and me, nah. They'll burn us in a heartbeat when we're financially responsible without much reputation damage to the banks either. Reputation, it's not worth anything. And that is a sad, sad realisation and do not relish sharing it.
Conversely, Warren Buffet famously has a "halo" which means he gets favorable terms because people know that doing business with him will reflect well on them.
Different pockets of finance have different norms about who it's OK to screw and how, and even as an investment professional I don't understand the conventions in areas outside of my specialty. So it's very hard to judge as an outsider what is considered unethical and reputation-destroying, and what is considered aggressive business practices that happen to come at the expense of other sophisticated professionals.
You and me would have a lot of trouble getting that kind of financing without a hideous reputation. Don has one and got it. Now he's even the president. Bad reputations count for not all that much at all. And I hate that, fwiw.
Buffet's reputation, now that's a whole nother discussion. Yes it deserves to be better than Don's. Coke, McDonalds and buying off-market at huge discounts to support management against shareholders. Obesity, diabetes and legal resdistribution of people's retirment savings to berkshire hathaway. Yes, a reputation too good to be true nonetheless. I agree.
Edit: And this is not $500 BILLION so you can say, F it, boom or bust, let's try it. The upside isn't that much, relatively speaking, considering the blacklisting downside. Even if Revlon doesn't pay, a large % is already banked or will be in bankruptcy proceedings so it's not a 100% loss.
We would likely be guided by a sense of personal ethics and our own values, which would make us consider returning money even if through a technicality we had the legal right to keep it.
At the level these companies are interacting at, there's no such thing as ethics of this kind. The legal system is the values system, and if they can make money on a legal technicality they'll do it without further thought.
They're more like great vampire squids wrapped around the face of humanity, relentlessly jamming their blood funnels into anything that smells like money, as someone more eloquent than me once noted.
Worth remembering if you find yourself dealing with large scale financial institutions.
The allure of investing in hedge funds is the lack of regulation. As courts decide these matters I wouldn’t surprised if that results in some regulation. It will be interesting to see. The banks tend to have deep lobby connections.
Imagine a world where debtors can choose to repay lenders, and then change their minds and take the loan back again. It would make being a lender impossible. So it's sort of understandable if Brigade genuinely believe that, at one point, there was a conscious decision on the part of someone to repay the loan. Given that the sum they received was equal to the exact amount of the loan, it's not completely unreasonable.