News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Thursday April 07, 2011 @06:09PM (#2421418)
>there's a big difference between a group with a purpose and standards and a mob.

You're implying that this group doesn't have a purpose or standards? Seems like they have a fairly obvious purpose: discourage Sony from being heavy-handed against hobbyist hackers. And they also have standards: just ones you may disagree with. I'm sure if someone shot a Sony exec's kid the bulk of Anon would disagree with this action.

The back and forth of the establishment attempting to control and elements of the population pushing back is not a new thing.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by hartror on Thursday April 07, 2011 @07:52PM (#2421750)
A lynch mob has a purpose.

It isn't necessarily even the same purpose at the end as it was in the beginning. This is the danger of mobs, people become more emotional and feel more entitled to take more drastic actions that they would otherwise eschew alone. It would only take one lone nut case with a gun and the information Anon has gathered to turn this media curiosity into the biggest story this side of Libya.

I am not against what Anon is arguing for in this case, but what they are doing is highly questionable and crosses the line. This is no longer civil disobedience but something more akin to mobster tactics. If the same was done to them, someone pursuing their families, they would be crying foul from the internet's roof tops.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by blhack on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:00PM (#2421778)
>If the same was done to them, someone pursuing their families, they would be crying foul from the internet's roof tops.

I'm not sure if you're joking here or not, but this is exactly what was done to "them" during the HbGary thing, and this is exactly what is trying to be done to "them" in the George Hotz case (Sony is seeking information on George Hotz, as well as anybody who visited his website.)

And they are crying foul from the internet's rooftops. Which is exactly where we are at now.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by hartror on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:05PM (#2421790)
So two wrongs make a right?

Because others are doing it Anon is justified in doing it as well? And justified in taking it further and exposing innocent bystanders?

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:13PM (#2421818)
>So two wrongs make a right? Because others are doing it Anon is justified in doing it as well? And justified in taking it further and exposing innocent bystanders?

Whether it's a proportional response or not is debatable, but it's an unsurprising and natural turn of events in a system where corporations, because of the degree to which they lobby political parties, are catered to by the law and the courts. All Sony execs have to do to restore their personal security is back off from attempting to abuse their power.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by sudonim on Thursday April 07, 2011 @11:14PM (#2422260)
> All Sony execs have to do to restore their personal security is back off from attempting to abuse their power.

Bam, that is this, and the wikileaks thing in a nutshell. Gov & Corps are abusing their power at the expense of individuals. Anonymous (The Internet) gives previously weak individuals a way to level the playing field.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by hartror on Thursday April 07, 2011 @11:34PM (#2422316)
Even Wikileaks redact information that could get innocent people in trouble/killed. What Wikileaks does is controlled and measured, Anon is the the school's downtrodden nerds ganging up on the bullies little sister.

Going after the loved ones of the target of your fury is a tactic of criminals and despots.

Gang up on the bully.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by dhimes on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:00AM (#2423383)
Going after the loved ones of the target of your fury is a tactic of criminals and despots.

I agree. However, as others have pointed out that's what Sony is doing. Yet they are not being prosecuted for it. So in some sense perhaps this adopting of the tactics of criminals to use against the criminals themselves (speaking hyperbolically or at least theoretically here- perhaps too strong to apply directly to Sony) is in some sense justice? Especially where the law fails.

Hey, I have a family. I sure as hell wouldn't want someone who was pissed at me to come after them. But then, I wouldn't go after their family either.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by cabalamat on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:11PM (#2422100)
> So two wrongs make a right?

Is it wrong to respond if someone is attacking you? Sony are subverting governments to make laws that take away my (and your freedom on the internet. These laws are backed by credible threats of lethal force. What anonymous are doing to Sony executives is but a small fraction of what Sony executives are doing to internet users worldwide.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by blhack on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:18PM (#2421834)
>So two wrongs make a right?

No.

>Because others are doing it Anon is justified in doing it as well?

No.

>And justified in taking it further and exposing innocent bystanders?

Absolutely not.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:41PM (#2421903)
>I am not against what Anon is arguing for in this case, but what they are doing is highly questionable and crosses the line. This is no longer civil disobedience but something more akin to mobster tactics.

It's unfortunate that more conventional forms of civil obedience have been rendered ineffective in dealing with corporations who, by lobbying government and dominating popular media, have overcome the traditional checks and balances of a healthy civil society.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by drusenko on Friday April 08, 2011 @12:26AM (#2422454)
What evidence do you have that "the traditional checks and balances of a healthy civil society" aren't working?

Just because you aren't getting your way doesn't mean society isn't working. You have a viewpoint, but plenty of other people have a very different viewpoint on where things should stand. That we manage to arrive at a reasonable middle ground between all of these dissenting opinions seems to indicate that the system is working.

I'm tired of hearing all of this posturing and justification for Anon just because you support what they support. If it was the Montana Tea Party employing tactics like this, they would be called domestic terrorists.

So, sorry: DDoSes, stalking, harassment and vandalism are not "civil disobedience", they're just plain old despicable behavior.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:19AM (#2422826)
>What evidence do you have that "the traditional checks and balances of a healthy civil society" aren't working?

Representative democracy now represents lobbyists rather than voters. Media now represents corporate interests rather than the public interest.

This manifests in a new economic/political order: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/commentary...

>That we manage to arrive at a reasonable middle ground between all of these dissenting opinions seems to indicate that the system is working.

Pretty much anyone I talk to, regardless of their political persuasion, doesn't feel the system is working.

>I'm tired of hearing all of this posturing and justification for Anon just because you support what they support.

That's unfortunate. Laws, the economy, culture, and politics have changed since the days of a functional civil society. It's unlikely that people in present circumstances will abide by standards of behavior that don't advance their interests.

>So, sorry: DDoSes, stalking, harassment and vandalism are not "civil disobedience", they're just plain old despicable behavior.

The tactics of the American and French revolutions were likely classifed as "despicable" as well by the out of touch and complacent, but history would be much different without these tactics. Many see Sony's abuse of power as "despicable". Sony is free to withdraw their aggression at any time.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by drusenko on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:11AM (#2423409)
> The tactics of the American and French revolutions were likely classifed as "despicable" as well by the out of touch and complacent, but history would be much different without these tactics. Many see Sony's abuse of power as "despicable". Sony is free to withdraw their aggression at any time.

To compare the state we're in to those periods in time is very misleading. We have one of the highest qualities of life and some of the strongest freedoms than at any other point in time. Let's not lose perspective.

We should "fight" for what we believe in and try to effect positive change, but we are extremely far away from the extreme times that warranted extreme revolutionary measures.

> Pretty much anyone I talk to, regardless of their political persuasion, doesn't feel the system is working.

That's a great sign that it is.

Reminds me of the quote: "You know it's a great deal when both sides feel screwed."

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Friday April 08, 2011 @10:56AM (#2424035)
>To compare the state we're in to those periods in time is very misleading. We have one of the highest qualities of life and some of the strongest freedoms than at any other point in time. Let's not lose perspective.

A time like ours, in which there's a massive societal shift (the rapid shrinking of the middle class as a result of globalization) accompanied by a financial crisis, is actually quite comparable to the environments that fostered the American and French revolutions.

The French revolution was preceded by a financial crisis and enlarged public debt due to foreign wars. Back then it was nobility and the clergy that managed to avoid taxation and whose interests were overrepresented by the state. In our times the wealthy and corporations have gained this favor.

>That's a great sign that it is. Reminds me of the quote: "You know it's a great deal when both sides feel screwed."

Ah. So by this logic revolutionary America and France also had "working" systems.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by chopsueyar on Friday April 08, 2011 @09:56AM (#2423780)
That's a great sign that it is.

So what, the system only started working very recently?

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by btilly on Friday April 08, 2011 @10:00AM (#2423811)
Representative democracy now represents lobbyists rather than voters. Media now represents corporate interests rather than the public interest.

NOW represents? That suggests that it has changed sometime in the last century. But from everything that I have read, the corruption is actually less today than it was a hundred years ago.

Pretty much anyone I talk to, regardless of their political persuasion, doesn't feel the system is working.

Oh the system is working, alright. It just isn't working for _you_. :-P

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Friday April 08, 2011 @11:15AM (#2424121)
>But from everything that I have read, the corruption is actually less today than it was a hundred years ago.

If that is the case then awareness of the corruption is what has changed. If government represents the interests of an elite rather than the electorate at large than that system is dysfunctional and may be subject to a correction.

>Oh the system is working, alright. It just isn't working for _you_. :-P

My comments criticizing the system have received healthy upvoting, so it would seem that I'm not expressing a fringe opinion. Outside of Hacker News, stats showing steadily increasing economic polarization in the US are a solid indicator of an out-of-balance system.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by btilly on Friday April 08, 2011 @11:55AM (#2424317)
If that is the case then awareness of the corruption is what has changed.

Actually a century ago people were very aware of the corruption. It was the impetus for a number of important reforms.

My comments criticizing the system have received healthy upvoting, so it would seem that I'm not expressing a fringe opinion.

Tip. When someone adds a ":-P" to a comment, that indicates teasing. The people for whom the system "works" are those with power and influence. You are not one of them, and therefore it doesn't work for you.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by mcantelon on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:17PM (#2424724)
>Tip. When someone adds a ":-P" to a comment, that indicates teasing. The people for whom the system "works" are those with power and influence. You are not one of them, and therefore it doesn't work for you.

Sorry for my defective humor detector. Cheers!

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by jbooth on Friday April 08, 2011 @10:21AM (#2423901)
Petty corruption and backhanders are one thing.

Institutionalized, legitimized corruption is a different thing entirely, and yes it's at a new level these days. See Citizens United. See the recent decision allowing corporations to run ads in elections. (they broke the spending record in a MIDTERM in 2010).

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by btilly on Friday April 08, 2011 @11:52AM (#2424304)
Institutionalized, legitimized corruption is a different thing entirely, and yes it's at a new level these days.

I far prefer to have corporations run ads in elections to having corporations purchase senate seats. And when I say purchase, I do mean purchase. Prior to the 17th amendment senators were generally appointed by state legislatures, and it was surprisingly common for corporations to pay the legislatures to make their man senator. This was the impetus for the 17th amendment.

If you want institutionalized corruption, read up on Tammany Hall.

If you want legitimized corruption, read up on the history of how the 14th amendment was so narrowly interpreted to prevent enforcement of its plain intent. We are not talking about minor injustices. For example in the Colfax massacre over 100 blacks were killed. Everyone knew who did it, only 3 were convicted of anything, and those convictions were overturned by the Supreme Court. This decision was widely applauded.

If you think that things are worse today, I'll need some serious convincing.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by jbooth on Friday April 08, 2011 @12:17PM (#2424442)
Dude, what do you think the easiest way to purchase a senate seat is? In most states it costs a couple million dollars to run a campaign for a job that pays 200k.

I understand that a lot of conservatives want to go back to the 1850s but that's not what I'm talking about, I'm talking about as recently as 25-50 years ago when the current state of affairs would have been a scandal. And heck, even during Tammany Hall, such bribery was at least technically illegal, and widespread breaking of the law meant our elected officials said "how do we stop this". Now it's not only legal, it's encouraged, and our leaders are trying to enable more of it.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by btilly on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:03PM (#2424652)
Tell Carly Fiorina how easy it is to purchase a Senate seat.

About how things have changed in recent years, in Bill Clinton's book My Life one thing that he comments on is how much cleaner politics is today than it was when he was young and just getting involved, and yet how much dirtier the public thinks it is. Based on his insider account I believe that the reality is very different than your perception.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by jbooth on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:44PM (#2424860)
Yeah, Clinton was talking about the personal level, like "has a secret black baby" stories and things like that, particularly in the desegregated south where he was coming up.

Look at the income disparity in the country and look at the way the tax code, consumer protection laws, environmental protection laws and laws regarding corporate lobbying have gone in the last 20 years or so. It's all going the same direction. That's the kind of stuff I'm talking about when I say "institutionalized corruption", not small-scale backroom deals or dirty politics.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by btilly on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:58PM (#2425152)
Yes, income disparity has gotten a lot worse since 1980. We're now back to about the levels of disparity that we saw a century ago during the gilded age. Just like then, I expect to see a long term backlash. (At the height of the backlash in the 1950s the top personal income tax rate ranged from 92% to 93%. On income over $1 million/year. That was a lot more then than it would be now.)

Currently the US government takes in about 15% of GDP in taxes. That's the lowest that it has been in a century. I would expect to see that change as well at some point in the future.

Re:Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very pers... by leot on Friday April 08, 2011 @12:23AM (#2422447)
Not that I'm condoning this behavior, but it's especially unfortunate that the target here is relatively benign when there are so many more deserving targets.