Those 17000 vessels estimated by the ODI are likely not ships whose existence the Chinese government denies, but instead ships that are not classified as part of the distant-water fishing fleet even though they do venture far off the coast.
here are 1/10 of the Chinese fishing fleet - 1/10! just outside of the Galapagos Islands. the Chinese say they have 2,600 vessels - weird how exactly 260 of those are just off the coast of a UNESCO World Heritage site fishing illegally. yes, the boatrs in international waters, but their fishing lines aren't.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/ariellasimke/2020/08/09/over-20...
it's not "inconsistent propaganda" it's under-reporting and outright lying, which is par for the course when it comes to the CCP.
In China, as near as I can tell, 2-3 generations have been raised with the understanding that truth is always subordinate to the goals of the CCP. In fact, if not in abstract.
That's one thing, internal to a country. That's very different when you're talking international diplomacy.
And yet it seems like China follows this exact playbook in that arena too.
It has to make for some awkward conversations when a diplomat is swearing (and believing, inasmuch as doublethink is possible) that the fleet numbers X, when another country is providing literal evidence that it's 5X.
Cities, provinces, and the central government all have their own agendas and different reasons to lie. They don't necessarily do cross checks before publishing their own data.
The recent episode with the Apple story on HN reveals how easy it is for emotional pile-ons to happen on something that may or may not be factual. I think cooler heads need to be prevailed upon to speak up and add some balance to discussions.
That's the thing about lies.
At first glance is the perfect solution, you simply lie and the problem goes away.
The tricky part is when the lies start you add up and you need to keep track of it, and/or when the lie is easily observable.
I think this is a bit of both: they don't even know what they are keeping track of, and the observers see the lies.
Because this isn't the simple case of propaganda when you try to reframe things, this is just made up shit.
Now the true question is: WHY THE HELL DOES CHINA KEEP THIS NARRATIVE FILLED WITH SUCH OBVIOUS LIES?
The answer is: no one does anything about it, neither did anything about it for years! Because of the short term benefits for some western countries.
Could it be an inaccurate translation? Yes.
Is China abusing their fishing fleets and actively try to dismiss that? Yes.
Is China actively implicated in lies and deception, and are observed doing it? Yes.
>Eh, my observation is about a recurring behavior from China
Can you clarify which behaviour you are referring to? It's been pointed out that the Chinese goal was to stabilize their fishing fleet size to around 3000, which given their normal growth focused policies seemed like some thing worthy of planning. And not propaganda as the parent comment was implying
If you're that itchy for a quarrel, just have at it.
Furthermore, it says restrict to under 3000, while you have changed it to reduce.
http://jiuban.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/ghjh/201712/t20171221_5985078...
Also for more details about the ODI estimate: https://www.cffacape.org/publications-blog/how-large-is-the-...
> 12,490 vessels without IMO or RFMO registrations but with active AIS signals outside Chinese waters at some point between 1 January 2017 and 31 December 2018.
AND
>AIS signal outside Chinese EEZ in 2017 or 2018
CTRL+F entire report "South China Sea", 1 hit from references. The fact that this point doesn't get any elaboration makes this report suspect as hell. That leaves 4,476 vessels, 927 foreign flagged (20.7%) consistent with Chinese numbers. Under 4.3.1 (pg 21): "around 20% of the world’s fishing vessels are registered in states to which they have no other connection". In that same paragraph it tries to use 927/16,966 to show Chinese share of foreign vessels is relatively small at 5.5% when using 4,447 its right at the 20% mark.
Also shifty eyes at 2.2.1 that tries to do a nominal comparison to EU/US DWF fleets but conveniently leaves out the other countries with the largested DWF fleet size (Taiwan, SK, Japan, Spain) [1]. Taiwan adjusted per capita would have a DWF fleet the size of 24k ships. S.Korea is around 5K ships which is in line with China, per capita, but it seems like relative numbers lke per capita is frowned upon if it doesn't make China look bad relative to regional peers.
https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-document...
[1] https://www.stimson.org/wp-content/files/file-attachments/St...
A good rule of thumb when dealing with the CCP - multiply or divided all publicly-released stats and numbers by 10 to get closer to reality.
I've written a great deal about this if you want some explanation about why we moderate HN this way (no, it's not because we're secret Communists):
https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=a...
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-shanghai-population...
According to your logic, they are lying about the population size of Shanghai as well? LOL
“The Chinese government says its distant-water fishing fleet, or those vessels that travel far from China’s coast, numbers roughly 2,600, but other research, such as this study by the Overseas Development Institute (ODI), puts this number closer to 17,000”.
Several paragraphs later:
“More recently, the Chinese government has stopped calling for an expansion of its distant-water fishing fleet and released a five-year plan in 2017 that restricts the total number of offshore fishing vessels to under 3,000 by 2021.“
Why would you need to announce a plan to reduce your fleet to below 3,000 if it’s only “officially“ at 2,700? Is this a case of inconsistent propaganda?