News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by harry8 on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:12AM (#24184760)
Open comment from an Australian to google:

"Pay your f#$king tax like the rest of us or shut the f%$ck up."

This comment stands apart from any and all implications of their special interest policy pleadings above which are all pretty tedious in comparison.

Google don't pay tax for profit made selling in Australia. To hell with them and literally any case they have to make.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by MertsA on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:16AM (#24186914)
I agree multinational corporation taxation is sorely in need of updating but this isn't taxing Google. This is just robbing Google and giving the proceeds to News Corp. The Australian people don't get anything from this, it's literally just taking money from one multinational and giving it to another. What would be hilarious is if Google just delisted News Corp in the US and UK and charged them a premium for adwords to offset the theft in the Australian market.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by stephen_g on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:24AM (#24186159)
We definitely do need to close up loopholes that multinationals use to avoid paying tax here (and really, everybody should have a look at Michael West’s Top 40 Tax Dodgers [1] - apparently Google avoids being on the list by directly booking a fair bit of their Australian profit offshore, but wouldn’t be that high compared to the likes of Chevron, Exxon and others). But we need to keep in mind that this proposed bill has been pushed for pretty much solely by a single American company that controls 70% of our media and also doesn’t pay tax!

In this case, I’d prefer Google wins - tax reform can come after. Or we could use it as a compromise - “OK, we’ll drop the News Corp Subsidy Bill, but in return you stop the tax avoidance”

1. https://www.michaelwest.com.au/australias-top-40-tax-dodgers...

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by knorker on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:56AM (#24185019)
To hell with "them"? Are you saying Australians should cut off their nose to spite their face?

I think you missed the whole point of this letter. Let me clarify:

"Oi mate, the government wants to force us to fuck you royally. We don't want to. Please help stop yourself getting fucked. Cheers, cunt."

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by harry8 on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:01PM (#24193747)
I think you missed the /whole/ point of the comment.

You are starting from the premise that google care about australians. This is a demonstrably false assumption. They don't pay their tax. They would destroy australians in a heartbeat for more money. It's not opinion, they've shown that themseleves. That is just a sad fact.

Now re-read your comment and tell me if there is any good reason anyone should care about what google says when they claim to be on the side of "australians" when we know they are not. No framing, nor spin from the PR agency here changes that.

Google "on the side of small players" is just vomit-making. They never have been anything other than brutal to small players in any action they have taken in business in any single way. Really. Google take everything they can, whenever they can, however they can. Ask small players who has had business squashed. Want to sell apps in the android store who have their REVENUE taxed by google while google don't pay their tax to the government. Then if you manage to make profit after paying a revenue tax to google you find you just did google's market research for them. That's one example, there are plenty.

Google are foul. This open letter foul. Even if you agree with any points the PR agency is useing to try and influence you it still foul.

The policy discussion about what constitutes good policy for Australia comes after we acknowledge how awful google are. And after we have agreed to place the intrerests of Google precisely last after every single Australian who pays their tax.

"NO representation without taxation!"

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by knorker on Saturday August 22, 2020 @07:08AM (#24243319)
> You are starting from the premise that google care about australians

I'm absolutely not. Complete misunderstanding of everything I'm saying.

"Hey that guy is about to stab you!" -"fuck you you're a .. aaaaaargh I'm being stabbed!"

> They would destroy australians in a heartbeat for more money. It's not opinion, they've shown that themseleves. That is just a sad fact.

Also 100% irrelevant.

> Now re-read your comment and tell me if there is any good reason anyone should care about what google says

Only if they are right.

Don't cut off your nose to spite your face. A fact (if indeed it is) said by the stupidest evilest entity, is true even if they said it.

Feynman has a great bit about that. No matter who says it, if it's right it's right, if it's wrong it's wrong.

Two wrongs don't make a right.

But go ahead, be fucked by both google and the gov, if you prefer being doubly fucked.

The enemy of your enemy is not always your friend.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by chris_wot on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:14AM (#24185122)
And here is another Australian who says "Oi mate, Google don't want to pay taxes for profits they made in Australia. They don't want to invest in schools, universities, infrastructure or anything else through reasonable taxation. Google are fucking over Australians".
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by knorker on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:43AM (#24185297)
But it's orthogonal.

It's like you're saying you want to be fucked by both Google and the government.

Why do two wrongs make a right, to you? Again: cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by chris_wot on Monday August 17, 2020 @12:45PM (#24188962)
No, I want Google to pay taxes for profit they earned in Australia.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by knorker on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:09PM (#24193371)
Or-tho-go-nal.

Cutting off your nose to spite your face does not stop your face from doing whatever it did to make you spite it.

Non sequitur. Orthogonal. Unrelated. Irrelevant.

You can be against google fucking you and the Australian government fucking you. These are not mutually exclusive.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by nojvek on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:37AM (#24188241)
Google is a for profit entity which is legally bound to optimize value for shareholders. Therefore they will follow whatever taxation laws there are. Same with Amazon, MSFT, Apple etc.

Change the tax laws. Google isn’t doing anything wrong (morally yes, legally no). It’s how public corporations work.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by eru on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:07AM (#24185406)
Google complies with all the relevant laws.

If Australians want Google to pay more taxes, they should change the tax laws to make them pay more taxes.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by DanBC on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:30AM (#24185528)
Tax law is what's written in acts and statutes, but also what's developed in case law.

Google's lawyers will claim that Google is compliant with tax law, but until these complex tax avoidance schemes go through the courts we won't know.

Most tax authorities use courts as a measure of last resort, and will prefer to add clarifications to the law and negotiate settlements with avoiding companies rather than spending millions on legal fees for court cases.

Some companies see a regulation and say "that's the bare knuckle minimum expected behaviour that we cannot go below". Other companies see a regulation and say "how far beyond that can we go before we get fined?"

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by LockAndLol on Monday August 17, 2020 @01:56PM (#24189841)
> Google complies with all the relevant laws.

Yeah, they use every loophole the system provides to pay the least amount possible. If I used every loophole to take advantage of a system and make it do what I want, I'd be labelled a criminal. I'd be called a hacker. But since it's a big company and the system isn't a computer, well... I guess it's OK then.

They're hacking the system and you're fine with it because "technically they're complying with relevant laws". Just because something is legally possible doesn't mean it's right.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by eru on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:18AM (#24196358)
The loopholes are part of the laws.

I am very glad that I moved to a country, Singapore, that in general has sane and simple laws that don't suffer nearly as much from loopholes as most other countries.

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by enneff on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:20PM (#24192926)
No you wouldn’t. This is what an accountant does for you.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by paulnechifor on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:25AM (#24186533)
Is this what Google is complaining about, changing laws?
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by bryan_w on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:15PM (#24190732)
If this law was a tax, you would be correct, but this is a law to force Google to pay news corp
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by eru on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:40AM (#24196469)
In some sense, yes.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by ohgodplsno on Monday August 17, 2020 @01:12PM (#24189257)
"Multinational makes money dance through 13 countries to pretend that Google Ireland is an absolutely different entity to Google Australia".

Google can legitimately fuck off. The amount of money they have stolen from states throughout the world is measured in billions. And some people have the gall to come and say "bUt It'S lEgAL!1".

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by eru on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:41AM (#24196472)
Honestly, I'd rather have Facebook have the money than most governments.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by enneff on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:29AM (#24185216)
As a fellow Australian, we must compel our government to change the laws so that the many large corporations that operate in this country, not just Google, pay an appropriate amount of tax.
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by nl on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:31AM (#24184868)
Be that as it may, News Corp doesn't pay tax in Australia either, and I don't see why Google should have to pay what is effectively a tax to them!

Make them pay tax by all means, but why should it go straight to news corp?

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by runeks on Monday August 17, 2020 @02:27PM (#24190190)
> Google don't pay tax for profit made selling in Australia.

And why should they if they don’t operate in Australia?

If I, as a European, sell something to an Australian from which I profit, should I be paying an Australian tax on this sale?

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by cyphar on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:39PM (#24193593)
Actually, yes. If you have more than $75k in revenue per year, you are legally obligated to register for, charge, and pay GST[1] -- our equivalent of VAT -- and you have to register as an Australian business (though for most overseas companies the additional taxes are minimal). If you aren't GST registered then Aussies have to do pay for it during the customs process[2]. If I wanted to sell things to customers in the EU in large enough volume, I would probably have to do something similar. Paying taxes (or more generally, following the law) is simply something that businesses have to do if they wish to have access to a country's market -- you also have to follow our consumer laws and other relevant regulations (for instance, this is why Steam has to provide much more lenient return policies here -- we have very strong regulations on warranties and return policies and they were fined for non-compliance in the past).

Not to mention that Google employs lots of people in Australia (Google Maps was first developed in the Sydney office), has a subsidiary incorporated in Australia, and sells many millions of dollars worth of products in Australia. They are no less of an Australian company than Woolworths.

[1]: https://www.ato.gov.au/Business/GST/Registering-for-GST/ [2]: https://www.ato.gov.au/Business/GST/In-detail/Rules-for-spec...

Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by brod on Monday August 17, 2020 @02:46PM (#24190420)
What if you as a European (company) employ 1000 Australians in Australia and have Australia specific resources (including sales) in Australia and use those Australian resources exclusively for Australia.. are you still not operating in Australia?
Re:Google: Open Letter to Australians by brod on Monday August 17, 2020 @02:52PM (#24190494)
Completely forgot in the other comment but your product would be subject to GST, which is a tax. I can't imagine Google paying GST %s on their Australian ad sales, but it's a starting point.