News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by prox on Monday August 17, 2020 @02:57AM (#24184693)
Is anyone usimg a linux phone? Love to hear use cases. I know about the PinePhone and the Librem, don’t know if there are others.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by blihp on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:08AM (#24185084)
I've got a Pinephone (the UBports CE, though I'm mainly running Mobian right now) Short term, the use cases are as hacker mobile Linux devices with most of the mobile hardware working (device drivers are still a WIP, Linux text/server software works flawlessly, GUI software is hit-or-miss right now) Long term, I'm expecting them to be perfectly serviceable basic mobile handsets. But they are still a ways off from being 'daily driver ready' (i.e. power management isn't in the same league as other mobile devices and quite a bit of flaky/missing functionality) Another area still needing work is that there are only a handful of desktop apps that have been reworked to have a scalable UI for mobile.

Generally things are still sluggish and battery life is not great yet, which is to be expected since no mobile devices really existed out in the wild for raw Linux until very recently. Now that they do exist, things are improving rapidly. For example: a month ago battery life was atrocious. Today it's merely bad (compared to what you're used to on iOS/Android)

So what does this feel like in terms of real world usage?

1) Want to use it to place/receive phone calls/text messages... it will work, to a degree... some/most (depending on distro) of the time.

2) Want to run a web server or open a terminal and ssh over to a server... pretty flawless.

3) Want to run a GUI app designed for or adapted to mobile... the list is growing weekly, if not daily.

4) Want to run a GUI app designed for desktops (i.e. no work has been done to adapt for mobile)... prepare to be disappointed, if you can use it at all.

5) Want to run your favorite iOS app? No.

6) Want to run your favorite Android app? If it's open source, probably will be possible soon-ish. Proprietary apps? Probably not if they rely on proprietary Android/Google services.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by tpxl on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:42AM (#24187120)
How is the battery life? On UBPorts a few weeks ago I got about 8 hours standby, which truly is atrocious. I would probably switch to it being my daily driver if I can get 3 days standby on a distro.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by blihp on Monday August 17, 2020 @12:12PM (#24188606)
A huge recent improvement is support for Crust firmware (https://github.com/crust-firmware/crust) which should get you 12-40 hours of standby (the low end is with wifi and cellular on, the high end is with them turned off. A day to a day and a half is the best I'm seeing) That just happened in the past month on most distros. Even with that installed and enabled, there is still significant room for improvement on power management of wifi and cellular. Mobian still has issues with things like random wakeups and not turning off the screen digitizer. I'll be very surprised if we can't see the standby time increasing to 3-7 days depending on what's enabled, but it will take time.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by RealStickman_ on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @11:28AM (#24199849)
Wasn't it close to 100h with the modem turned off?
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by blihp on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @02:51PM (#24202653)
That was reported but I've never seen anything close to that even with all wireless turned off. This could be due to other power saving issues on Mobian... I just don't know yet.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by RealStickman_ on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @03:09AM (#24207941)
I'll have to test it with my Pinephone. I thought I had it lying next to me in standby for multiple days, so more than 40h at least.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by Ardon on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:23AM (#24187515)
They recently got power management working for more components, I've heard people are getting ~40 hours standby now.

There's still some gains to be made here, so this may still improve.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by tpxl on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:42AM (#24187750)
Wow, 40 hours is a lot!
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by Ardon on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:45AM (#24187787)
To be clear, this when the phone is allowed to be in a sort of 'deep sleep' mode, this probably isn't representative of day-to-day use. The point remains though that more and more power management is working and things are improving quickly.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by tpxl on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:51AM (#24187847)
Can it receive calls/SMSs in this mode?
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by blihp on Monday August 17, 2020 @12:15PM (#24188633)
Yes... theoretically. (i.e. still a work in progress: it's buggy)
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by Vai1sail on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:53AM (#24185970)
I'm using a pinephone, and contrary to most people, it's actually my "daily driver".

This was made possible mainly because I have prepared for about a year for GNU/linux phones (thinking of the librem5 at the time) by replacing all my commonly used apps with similar webapps.

All in all, I don't have an advanced usage of my phone, so it may be what makes it possible to use the pinephone. I don't commute (no need for maps, games, durable battery), I don't often take pictures, my only real need for my phone is the hotspot (because it's my only internet connection) and calls/messaging.

The pinephone is extremely cheap hardware and it can be felt. Opening firefox takes a good 10 seconds, and browsing with it is a pain. Gladly, GNU/linux is very good at running on poor hardware. I just replaced the browser with elinks, which I run through tor, just like on my laptop, and it does the job. Lollypop works well to listen to music while I'm out. Calls and text messages are good enough.

The real cool thing, though, is how hackable it is. After a few months with the phone, I've played a lot around the idea : how to make apps that doesn't use much power? Because, the battery is very bad. And a few months after, my answer has been to build C applications that runs as CGI apps with html static interface rendered by nginx (the idea being to only run the program when I need it rather than constantly as a daemon). This is absurd, this is fun, I love it.

So, as far as I'm concerned, GNU/linux phones are validated. Now I'll want something with better hardware, so I'll wait for the librem5 to see if it delivers, then switch to it if it does.

EDIT: oh, I forgot to mention a step, it must not be clear that way : I made webapps on the phone rather than GTK apps, because that way I can use the apps from my laptop, using the IP address of the phone on the local network.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by mpol on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:43AM (#24186265)
I am using Sailfish OS on a Sony Xperia XA2. I am using it now for about 1 year. Before that I used Sailfish OS on the original Jolla 1 for 5 years. I have also used a Nokia N9 with Meego Linux, which can be considered a forerunner of Jolla/Sailfish.

It uses Qt, Wayland, Systemd. The original Jolla 1 even used Btrfs, which was deemed a mistake. Sailfish OS is available on more devices, like the Pinephone, Fxtec, Cosmo Communicator and others. If you have the official version for Sony Xperia, you get Alien Dalvik, with which you can run Android apps. I am using Whatsapp and Firefox as Android apps this way. I am still hoping that Signal takes off for mesaging, a native app like Whisperfish is something I would really enjoy. With Whatsapp a native app is not possible, there have been threats for lawsuits.

I am very happy with Sailfish, and have been for 6 years. I enjoy having plain linux on my phone, being able to use ssh as root and having a device that I trust. There are some 'costs' involved, like having less shiny bling and less apps available. Companies like Apple and Google can spend billions on their phone platform. Jolla only has about 100 employees in total. You do have to adjust your expectations somewhat.

Jolla have received criticism about not having open sourced all their software. I do understand that criticism, but that argument doesn't make Apple or Google look any better :) I am curious about where linux phones will go in the next years, but currently Sailfish is good for me.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by gardaani on Monday August 17, 2020 @12:01PM (#24188460)
I got my Jolla 1 linux phone in 2013 and I'm still using as my daily driver. And I still love it!

The reason I'm keeping my Jolla 1 phone is that it still gets security updates after 7 years. I also have an Android phone for testing purposes (I sometimes write Android apps and web pages for work), but it only got updates for few years. I don't want to buy a new Android phone if it doesn't get updates after few years. I'll keep my Jolla.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by solarkraft on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:13AM (#24186880)
> The original Jolla 1 even used Btrfs, which was deemed a mistake.

Why is that? Was it too young or is it generally impractical on a phone?

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by mpol on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:02AM (#24187283)
What I remember (not a linux developer) is that sometimes you have to rebalance the filesystem. You can have free space in megabytes, but no inodes left. (If I am wrong someone might correct me). There have been instances, especially later on in its lifecycle, where a system update was aborted due to no space (inodes) which ended in a lot of trouble.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by solarkraft on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:51AM (#24187852)
I've been using btrfs as my main file system for about 6 years now and have run into the "no free space" issue about twice.

It's horrible. Everything stops working and freeing space is quite hard.

Other than that I had no issues with it. Subvolumes and snapshots are pretty cool to me, but I can see how the added overhead might not make sense in a processing power and space constrained environment.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by eu on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:37AM (#24187068)
Does Sailfish OS get updates regularly?
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by mpol on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:11AM (#24187380)
Yes, every few months. Communication is not always that clear, the same with the roadmap :) Early in the life of Sailfish it was decided that being behind on upstream software versions was not a problem, since in embedded software things are different then with desktop and server. In the past few years many work has been done to amend this situation.

There are some other factors in play. It is a small company which is short on developers and keeping the system Gecko browser updated has proven to not be very easy. Then there is the issue that some software is closed source, which works fine with Qt 5.6 which is LGPL, but with newer Qt versions it is either full GPL or full commercial. This is a business decision and developers don't have much say in this. What I suspect is happening now is that it gets postponed untill it can no longer be postponed, which does save money :) Then there is the issue that untill now Sailfish was tied to Android drivers and thus is using Android kernels. In that sense the Pinephone is an interesting development with mainlined drivers.

So yes, in the community there are some complaints, but in the real world I can understand it the situation from both sides. For my practical usecase, a daily driver with whatsapp, I haven't seen a better linux phone yet. Again, I am really happy with my phone, even though the situation makes it easy to be critical towards it :)

edit: Oh, just to add to this, updates can last a long time for a hardware iteration. The Jolla 1 from 2013 is still getting updates. Ofcourse the Android layer is not updated due to old Android drivers, but the rest of the system is just the same a the newest hardware that is being supported. I hop my Sony Xperia XA2 from 2018 will last me 5 years as well, or hopefully even longer.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by kop316 on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:02AM (#24186397)
I have it in addition to my Android phone. I am actually really impressed on how well it works (I use Mobian). Email, maps, calendar, and web browsing all work. The camera sort of but not really works.

The only thing stopping me from using it as a daily driver is MMS:

https://sr.ht/~anteater/mms-stack/

Ubuntu Touch seems to be the closest to be able to have MMS (it uses Ofono,all of the other distros seem to use Modem Manager). However, it is a bit disappointing as no ground seems to be done on it. I admittedly don't have experience in that, but I would be more than willing to donate time/money if I knew how to.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by gardaani on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @03:00AM (#24195963)
Sailfish OS supports MMS. I've been using Sailfish for years without issues in MMS.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by kop316 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:25PM (#24201473)
Heh, interesting. Even on the Pinephone? I know Ubuntu Touch supports MMS but does not on the Pinephone. Same with Glodroid (the Android Port to Pinephone).

I have been doing some work with MMS on it recently: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mobile-broadband/ModemManager...

I don't think it's a far off as a lot of folks thought.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by gardaani on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @12:37AM (#24207177)
Sorry, I don't know about PinePhone. It may not work.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by kop316 on Saturday August 22, 2020 @11:51PM (#24249385)
What do you use for it?
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by gardaani on Monday August 24, 2020 @11:27AM (#24261574)
I don't use PinePhone. I have an old Jolla 1 phone.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by rhn_mk1 on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:05AM (#24186042)
The answers won't be complete without mentioning the Maemo/Meego series of phones, including the Nokia N900 and N9.

The N900 keeps its appeal today because it's fully programmable (even if toolchains are woefully outdated), and the community is still (after 10 years!) vibrant. It's also small, offers a hardware keyboard, has decent battery life, and has the usual gimmicks expected from a smart phone: camera, GPS, GUI package manager, etc.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by Mediterraneo10 on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:58AM (#24186365)
> The N900 keeps its appeal today because it's fully programmable.

While some of the userspace software has still been developed in the years since Nokia’s abandonment of the phone, the N900's kernel is stuck at an ancient version riddled with security issues, and also the SSL/TLS libraries are outdated. For some years I still used my N900 in airplane mode to listen to music because it had decent sound output on its headphone jack and ran MPD, but I would not recommend connecting an N900 to the internet in this day and age.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by mpol on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:49AM (#24186304)
Just curious, but if you enjoy a Nokia N900, would you not consider the Cosmo Communicator or the Fxtec a good follow-up? It has modern hardware, still a good hardware keyboard. Together with the more updated Sailfish OS you get something much newer and faster.

I can imagine criticism about Jolla not having everything open sourced, but what I remember it was the same situation with Nokia for the N900 and N9. Also, in some respects the UI of Sailfish is somewhat different from Maemo/Meego, not everybody will like that.

Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by numpad0 on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:00AM (#24187267)
Is the keyboard really good? I’ve tried one of Cosmo, Gemini, or Fxtec in person, can’t remember which, and utterly disappointed upon first touch. It looked like a proper laptop but keys tilted on roll and pitch axes like a TV remote. Good hardware keyboard seems to need a lot of iteration and investments to do so.
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by fsflover on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:50AM (#24184996)
There are a lot of videos on Youtube, e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bH3RbrwhNd8
Re:Linux PinePhone has physical kill switches for its camera... by chriswarbo on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:58AM (#24185672)
I've been using my Freerunner for over 10 years. I've tried it with a bunch of distros (including the first version of Android when that came out, which was nice but sluggish); I've generally stuck with QtMoko (although that was last updated in 2014).

The battery struggles to hold much charge any more, so I've been waiting for a replacement which isn't a "freedom downgrade". These newer offerings are exciting, but seem a little too beta for me to switch quite yet.