We do not want people to keep secret their World changing ideas but instead release them for the betterment of society.
7 years as sole seller of your own creations, and leave to apply for 7 more years - IIRC - were the terms under Queen Anne's Statute protecting creative works (approximating copyright). Then works are freely available to all, and deposit requirements meant preservation and access was afforded.
The alternative is that corporate entities get all the money and creators get all the costs and the pubic domain gets nothing.
There's a lot wrong IMO with Western IP laws (I don't know about others) but the concept of them is not wrong.
There's specifically no protection for information in patent and copyright laws (database rights, eh, maybe ...).
Apple doesn't own all the rights to all fruit in trademarks. They know it, and they know they won't win, they're just using the courts to wage a war of attrition to get what they want. This bullshit should not be possible.
Apple needs to lose, and they need to pay $10-50M for torturing these poor, resourceless people.
This is so asymmetrically unfair it hurts.
Maybe a pear is too closely related.
I was just referring to the $10M penalty.
I agree that they should lose and that they should pay some kind of penalty.
I just think it shouldn’t be a lottery win for the people they filed against - they should definitely be made whole for the frivolous lawsuit - but not much more than that.
It’s worth pointing out too that the legal system clearly doesn’t consider the lawsuit frivolous.
Why is that, and why don’t we seem to care about it? Surely there are judges who have a responsibility to dismiss frivolous cases and prevent this kind of thing.
This theoretical amount you can then retrieve from the loser. You'll still be out the bulk of your legal fees.
In all cases I've seen first hand (in the Netherlands) the judge ordered all parties to pay their own costs. Loser pays is not a default because you almost never "win a 100%". You win for something like 70% (or maybe 90% if your lucky). So unless the case was really frivolous you will still have to pay for it yourself.
I personally know 2 people who sued the Dutch state (a somewhat similarly Goliath) and won. Both still needed to pay their own legal fees and such. It is possible to start a new case to get your legal fees from the opposing side. However if you have just concluded 5 years of court against a Goliath-style adversary your probably not really motivated for "a second round".
Also having to pay afterwards is no deterrent for a party like Apple who has unlimited money. You will have to pay lawyers and such up front for a case that can potentially drag on for years and years.
But, I do have to say, IP-related cases are an exception, and more is covered there (still not necessarily the actual costs). But that is not specific to the Netherlands but mandated by an EU directive (2004/48/EG).
Typos are mistakes.
A different set of laws, policies, and procedures are in play here.
> I'm kind of fascinated to understand what must be in your mind or experience that you think such penalties for normal legal actions are warranted.
Please don't cross-examine. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
If you think this is all “working as intended”... well... that’s unfortunate and I think the vast majority of people would disagree.