News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by Hokusai on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:41PM (#24044820)
> Generally, attractive people are perceived as more intelligent, more socially skilled, more appealing personalities, more moral , more altruistic, more likely to succeed, more hirable as managers, and more competent.

I am always astonished by how much we humans mix how moral is someone and how horny that someone makes us.

And it works both ways. To tell someone that you are not attracted to them is perceived as a judgement of their value in society and morality. When we actually decide if we are horny for someone in just 1 second from a picture and zero knowledge about that person.

Many years ago, I worked for a company that hired the hot one instead of the competent one. And it was amazing to see the twisted justification. But, I believe that the hiring manager was not aware and was convinced that the decision was based on the bogus conclusions.

> Some researchers are skeptical that real jurors will have the same biases as the studies in simulated juries.

I would expect even worse bias when you do not feel observed and you are not a student that may have knowledge about the concept of biased decisions.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by BurningFrog on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:54PM (#24044930)
I believe the science is, unfair as it might be, that more attractive people are, on average, more intelligent, more socially skilled, more etc than the opposite.

What we find attractive has formed through eons of evolution, and we retain the preferences of those who managed to leave more descendants.

That's not the same as being more intelligent etc, but it's not completely unrelated either.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by garbagetime on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:24PM (#24045140)
Another aspect of the relationship, I'm sure, is that attractive people are better looked after. And people who are better looked after, especially at a young age, have more opportunities to learn, socially and otherwise, than people who are worse looked after.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by jdm2212 on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:25PM (#24045144)
There's also the simple fact that attractiveness is endogenous. An intelligent, hard-working person will realize that attractive people get treated better and work to make themself attractive.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by o-__-o on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:48PM (#24045314)
My rule of thumb is the attractive person never gets fired. I haven't thought this rule any further than that, but I've observed it to be true throughout most of my 15 years of work
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by BurningFrog on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:24PM (#24045891)
Like I've heard several gorgeous people say:

"Do you think this just happens?"

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by luckylion on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:41AM (#24046996)
To be fair, you also hear rich people inheriting money saying the same. Nobody wants their success to be based on the luck of the draw, everybody wants it to be because of their hard work and perseverance because otherwise it's not an accomplishment.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by jdm2212 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @02:27AM (#24047245)
No one who has a full time job and is in good shape, with well-maintained hair, healthy skin, and a nice wardrobe, stays that way by accident. It's a ton of work.

It comes more easily to some than others, but an hour at the gym is an hour at the gym, whether you enjoy it or not.

I say this as someone who mostly doesn't do the work, but I have plenty of friends and colleagues (and a spouse) who mostly do. It's effort and money and time and stress for them.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by luckylion on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @02:59AM (#24047418)
Sure, and there's probably some that you wouldn't ever notice as attractive if they didn't spend an hour on make-up and another hour on tuning their abs each day. But most of it is genetic lottery, not hard work.

The same is true for money. It's still work to turn a million dollars into two million, but it's not anywhere close to the work required to turn a dollar into a million dollars. But nobody wants to be successful because of a lottery, so they'll argue that their father gave them "a small loan of a million dollars" but they made it big themselves.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by jdm2212 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @11:20AM (#24050833)
> But most of it is genetic lottery, not hard work.

The luck part isn't primarily about genetics [1], it's about whether you enjoy (or at least don't hate) the routines necessary to be attractive.

For instance: my wife sticks to a strict diet because she doesn't like having to make decisions about food. If you're lucky enough to be wired like her (I'm writing this next to an empty pizza box...), you can hit any goal weight and stay there. Our bathroom is covered in lotions and creams that she spends an hour applying before bed every night. I could not tell you their names, to say nothing of their purposes. She goes to the gym every day except for planned rest days, and does a workout routine that was decided on weeks ahead of time. I maybe go for a jog, if I remember to and I'm feeling up to it.

I've tried copying what she does, and I can't even stick to it for a day. But most women I know do some version of this, and all of the really attractive men do, too.

[1] sure, it is possible to really lose the genetic lottery, but unless you would've been a 19th century circus freak, the bottleneck is probably how hard you're trying, not your genetics

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by mitchdoogle on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:22PM (#24084948)
You can be highly attractive and not very fit. And you definitely don't need to have a skin care routine to be considered attractive.

I'd also argue that there is a feedback loop, i.e. attractive people are told they're attractive starting at a young age, and so a large part of their self-esteem comes from being attractive, so they feel more pressure to do the things you mention, i.e. skin care, working out.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by jdm2212 on Saturday August 08, 2020 @04:11PM (#24094823)
Definitely agree that there's a feedback loop and strong long-term effect of initial level of natural attractiveness when you're young.

One of the advantages of not starting out on the "is attractive -> gets self-esteem from attractiveness -> tries to be more attractive" cycle is that as you get older you don't feel like you're losing anything. It's no fun when you're young, but that's a small minority of most people's lives.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by misanthropian00 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:32PM (#24052390)
There are no routines necessary to be attractive. It is something you are either born with or not born with and it is pretty obvious at a very young age.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by jdm2212 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @02:14PM (#24052836)
That gets the causality backwards. Your personality is set pretty early in life and determines characteristics like how self-aware you are, how vain you are, whether you care about how you come across to others, and more. Those qualities determine how much effort you put into being attractive.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by misanthropian00 on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:09AM (#24059412)
If you need to put in effort then you you are not attractive in the first place. Attractive people are beautiful when they wake up in the morning. I Know this from experience. I am referring to facial beauty though. Maybe you are thinking of TnA.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by viklove on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @05:59PM (#24054936)
So are you saying you're not attractive? You don't put the effort in, but she does -- so she's attractive and you're not?
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by misanthropian00 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:30PM (#24052364)
Work to make themselves attractive? What are you talking about?
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by cblconfederate on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:37PM (#24045223)
> through eons of evolution

I always wonder to what extent that attribution to slow evolutionary processes is true. There were several selective bottlenecks in our ancestry, and during historic times (from which we descend) most marriages were arranged, with attractiveness playing only a very small factor. Even in modern times, only a small percentage of the population had the luxury of breeding with a partner that we consider nowadays highly attractive.

Then there's the fact that up to 80% of marriages have been between first cousins or closer, which would would actually cause unattractive features.

So how come we think that sexual attraction is an evolutionarily shaped mechanism

There is also the feedback loop of "grooming", where, just like bees select a random bee to be groomed as a queen, humans are positively reinforcing a specific set of humans for reasons that have more to do with mass psychology than actual attraction. E.g. kings and queens are groomed as leaders and rulers, eventhough they are probably the most inbred and flawed genetic stock

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by inawarminister on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:33PM (#24045939)
Well, this is quite hush-hush, but there are indications that through history, many, many people weren't born of their legal fathers.

Either because of cheating, or of sexual rites, or because of rape...

The Greek mythology are full of heroes descended from gods yet are raised by human kings married to their mothers, after all.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by IdiocyInAction on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:49AM (#24047038)
The halo effect for attractive people is way higher than the actual, relatively weak correlation to measures of intelligence. So, while it's true what you're saying, it's also true that people think that attractive people are more intelligent than they really are and the second effect is stronger.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by joefourier on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:32PM (#24045195)
Another factor is that being more intelligent and socially skilled allows you to earn higher income, which lets you afford better clothing, stylists and healthier habits (food, exercise). And of course cosmetic surgery, for which even minor procedures can be very expensive.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by pdr2020 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @07:38AM (#24048894)
Well that's completely wrong.

Attractiveness is a trait that signals health, not intelligence/social skill/etc.

That's why we evolved to desire attractive people.

It has nothing to do with being a marker for intelligence.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by distant_hat on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @08:04AM (#24049093)
Health is strongly correlated with intelligence.
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by BurningFrog on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @10:06AM (#24050078)
Anything we evolve to desire signals genetic fitness.

Genetic fitness means anything that results in more grandchildren in the end. Physical health is a big factor, sure, but so is intelligence and social skills.

Maybe this is in part a linguistic disagreement. By "attractive" I don't just mean "looks good in a photo", but any factor that attracts a partner.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by cortesoft on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:35PM (#24045214)
> I am always astonished by how much we humans mix how moral is someone and how horny that someone makes us.

I don't think this is about 'horniness', or even sexual attraction to the person, because this works across gender and sexual preference lines. Straight men are biased in favor of attractive men, even though they don't sexually desire them.

It is deeper than just sexual attraction.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by VoiceOfWisdom on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @12:15AM (#24046527)
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by dlivingston on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:48PM (#24044881)
Being a human means that we are constantly at battle between the calm logic of our neocortex and the chaos of our primate origins.

It's all too common for people to forget that we are still very much sub-Saharan apes underneath our Calvin Klein suits.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by notspam2413 on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:59PM (#24045735)
Horniness seems completely orthogonal to me to perceiving someone as "as more intelligent, more socially skilled, more appealing personalities, more moral , more altruistic, more likely to succeed, more hirable as managers, and more competent."

In fact I'd say the more horny inducing the less appealing personalities, less moral, less altruistic, less competent, etc I'd perceive someone. Not saying that's good of me but if we're saying attractiveness causes a boost well, as a man, for me, I'm generally attracted to the nice girl next door type, not the sexy temptress type. The sexy temptress type makes me horny but it doesn't remotely make me feel like I should trust her, give her more opportunities, etc... I don't think I'm alone in that. To give a more blunt example, I'm less likely perceive someone as having those positive traits who is a stripper or porn star even though they make me horny. It's the person that makes me feel like I want to spent quality time with that I'm more likely to perceive all those qualities, not the person I want a one night stand with.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by huge87 on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:33PM (#24045204)
> I am always astonished by how much we humans mix how moral is someone and how horny that someone makes us.

Yes, it's obvious that we shouldn't base our opinions on appearance or sexual attractiveness, but it really shouldn't surprise you that that's how things usually play out. Such reactions come from a much deeper part of our biology. The fact that we can sometimes think past those reactions is much more surprising, imo.

Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by Aerroon on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:53PM (#24044925)
This got me wondering whether there is an opposite effect too. Do people that are very moral appear physically more attractive to us?
Re:Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017) by sukilot on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:39PM (#24045243)
People those personality you like become more attractive to you. This is well studied as well as common sense (see every happy marriage).