Requirements are 1 in each bedroom and 1 in the hallway outside each bedroom. That adds up quickly.
Where I live, that's the minimum required by law, networked device or not. So it's not surprising that Nest requires it.
But you're right — that does add up quickly when converting from technology that's worked for 130 years to the SV "disruptor" version.
When a smoke detector goes off, I've got my system set to: 1) Turn off HVAC/heat 2) Unlock exterior doors 3) Turn on lights 4) Flush syncs of any local data to remote sources
What's the google price tag for again? Initially it was worthwhile for the panicky waving motion to cancel alarms. But then they removed that.
Don't do business with Amazon.
There is a article in German there. Linked the reddit post, since it is in English.
It's Google, so they'll probably force you to create a YouTube account to watch videos recorded by your security system, put adverts for private security services over the top, share what time you're usually out of the house with third parties, and then shut down the service after a couple of years.
Google have a reputation (rightly or wrongly) for dropping support for products quickly if they don't want them any more.
In the home security perspective installs can last decades, and changing suppliers can be expensive. that's not a good match for Google's approach.
Google has never made a product that did not collect data in a unique manner from its other products. Between that, the dark patterns, and this recent experience, google the company and the people that work there just give me the creeps.
From previous comment: "I uploaded a picture to google maps as part of a review. About a month later I get an actual notification on my phone - hey do you want to share this picture you took in City Park last weekend? It creeped me out beyond belief. Google had been rifling through my personal pictures in the background while I was going about my life. It was an enormous breach of my personal space and it is just one example of many related to google."
Additionally, I very much want an internet connected smoke alarm. But I would want something from a trustworthy company. And currently google does not fit that profile.
But I don't understand why people intentionally give their photos to a system for processing, apparently happily let it be used for advertising and government surveillance, but then get upset when it's used for features. You're rely happier with everyone spying on you and pretending they aren't?
It was a surprise for me since I forgot I left access to my photos on. iOS 14 resolves this by letting you choose which photos you allow an application to have access to. This cannot come any sooner because that was disturbing.
edit: I shared the original photo because I believe in helping other people.
Google then took liberties with that permission to an extreme. And it was personally revolting to me. I cannot overstate my absolute disgust with what happened there.
I can't think of a faster or more effective way for Google to destroy the public's trust in it than to inflict its customer service practices on the masses.
GSuite is also fairly well supported.
Which 'secret groups' are you referring to?
It it even possible to roll your own LAN solution any more? The tech giants have become so hostile to anyone who dares to try to control their own data that I never even hear it discussed any more.
I suggest this over an IP camera as you might as well be paranoid about those too. If you need live streaming that can be done with open source software fairly easily.
You would have to spend some time working on hardware, and it'd probably cost more, but technically it's just tedious rather than difficult. There are some projects to do this with the Pi camera already. You could even add object detection with ML quite easily, which is something you pay a lot for with other platforms.
What you miss out on is the level of embedded and mechanical integration that the commercial stuff has. Blink has a two year battery life (replaceable), the housings are IP rated etc.
I was amazed that not a single product in the sub $100 range on Amazon seemed to support direct LAN access. I ended up going with the Wyze cam, which still has that issue, but I'd trust a bit more over the no-name Chinese brands still running 10 year old Linux kernels on their cameras.
From my experience, many cameras won't publicize/document this information, but it's still available/possible for almost every one.
It’s entirely possible to do what you want.
Definitely Facebook. But I still wouldn't trust Google.
For home security you need to have customer trust to succeed. Google? No way. Facebook? Yeah right.
Facebook would be worse. Imagine opening your door and having it “helpfully” post an update that you’re back home.
Oh, but you should have known before to click through 63 pages of options to disable these notifications to strangers.
So sorry. We can do better™.
Apparently this was surprisingly difficult to remedy.
Imagine if your house won't let you in because it doesn't think you have gone out!
how does that work? can't he tailgate someone on the way out? or get the guy at the security desk to let him through? was he the last one out of the plant or something?
The garage had a gate that would usually require a card, but if you worked a late shift, then you might get off work just after a concert or other event let out and the gate was left up for everyone to leave. Which meant the next day, it would still think you were in the garage and not want to let you in.
At the same time, I would have a hard time naming a company that I’d trust less to integrate into my home security than Google.
Privacy, (lack of) customer service, service continuity...I know these aren’t issues that would worry most consumers but they would all be on my mind.