News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by marze on Saturday April 02, 2011 @11:45PM (#2401737)
When I see a story like this, it reminds me that the events in Japan represent the biggest PR challenge the nuclear industry has faced in many years. Fifty billion dollars of nuclear reactor US taxpayer-backed loan guarantees hang in the balance.

The industry has been working for the past few decades to rehabilitate the image of nuclear power after Chernobyl and Three Mile Island, and now they have to contend with videos of a 1/2 mile tall mushroom cloud over a Japanese reactor and the continuing press coverage. Talk about challenging.

I think the HN community may have difficulty appreciating the challenges of nuclear reactor design because it is so different from software. In software, you have known bugs and unknown bugs. Once you've got the known bugs down to a low enough level and aren't finding too many new ones, you might release. The consequences of a bug is generally not too bad, certainly not on the order of making 800 square miles of real estate worthless, for example.

In engineering a nuclear plant, you have 90 tons of nuclear fuel generating 3,000,000,000 J of heat every second. The only reason it doesn't immediately turn into a big bubbling blob of molten uranium is that pumps the size of SUVs are pumping water over the fuel and removing all that heat. Every nuclear plant in the world is one minute from 90 tons of fuel melting into the basement if the water flow stops and fall-back systems fail. Fortunately, the engineering on these plants is done extremely carefully, with multiple independent systems in place to prevent exactly this by halting the nuclear chain reactions with neutron absorbing rods as well as by ensuring the flow of cooling water.

However, the events in Japan exposed an "unknown bug" in the design, that if you flood the basements of the plants with water you can lose backup power and coolant flow. While this particular "bug" is relatively easy to correct, it is a reminder that other unknown bugs may exist waiting to be exposed by other unexpected sets of circumstances.

It is good to remember Richard Feynman's quote about the space shuttle Challenger disaster, "For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled."

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by billmcneale on Sunday April 03, 2011 @01:19AM (#2401886)
Number of casualties from nuclear plant accidents: a few thousands.

Number of casualties from coal mining accidents this past century [2]: 100,000.

That's accidents in coal mines alone, not even counting lung diseases and similar.

The fact that it takes a 9.0 tsunami after forty years of complete absence of nuclear accidents to bring this to the front page should be indication enough that nuclear is not just safer than most of the other energy production techniques, it's also the one that has the highest energy rendering.

Any Green voter who's done their homework should be voting for more energy to be generated by nuclear plants, not less.

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_mining

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by gnosis on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:37AM (#2402077)
"Nearly one million people around the world died from exposure to radiation released by the 1986 nuclear disaster at the Chernobyl reactor, finds a new book from the New York Academy of Sciences published today on the 24th anniversary of the meltdown at the Soviet facility."

http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2010/04/26

Excerpts of the book here:

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/nyas.2009.1181.is...

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by pella on Sunday April 03, 2011 @02:11PM (#2403370)
full book:

Chernobyl: Consequences of the Catastrophe for People and the Environment: (PDF; 4,3 MB) http://www.strahlentelex.de/Yablokov%20Chernobyl%20book.pdf

source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl:_Consequences_of_the_...

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by Ratfish on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:30AM (#2402066)
"forty years of complete absence of nuclear accidents"? The same Wikipedia has a fairly large section on accidents at nuclear power plants, stating "worldwide there have been 99 accidents at nuclear power plants from 1952 to 2009 (defined as incidents that either resulted in the loss of human life or more than US$50,000 of property damage, the amount the US federal government uses to define major energy accidents that must be reported), totaling US$20.5 billion in property damages.[4] Fifty-seven accidents have occurred since the Chernobyl disaster, and almost two-thirds (56 out of 99) of all nuclear-related accidents have occurred in the USA." On a brighter note however, "There have been comparatively few fatalities associated with nuclear power plant accidents"
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by lispm on Sunday April 03, 2011 @02:28AM (#2401988)
I vote for neither.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by asharp on Sunday April 03, 2011 @02:59AM (#2402030)
What would you suggest? Keeping in mind that basically all renewable sources sans hydroelectric can't be used to provide baseload power and hydroelectric power both has very few potential locations (most of which are in use) and has the nasty failure condition of washing away a good portion of the countryside.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by lispm on Sunday April 03, 2011 @05:08AM (#2402232)
So, if all you know is hydro-electric, why not use it NOW?

Germany is building two large underwater power lines in the latest HVDC technology to Norway.

One is described here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NorGer

NorGer is one, NORD.LINK the other.

These power lines will link Germany with Hydro electric power in Norway.

Essentially technology like that will provide the base load for the huge offshore wind farms that Germany will build in the coming decades in the North Sea.

Alpha Ventus http://www.alpha-ventus.de/ is the first one of those. These are really far away from the coast and sitting in the North Sea exposed to the most severe weather conditions.

It is just that a country needs to have a plan and a will to do it.

You can imagine that the nuclear lobby does not like this project to get hydro-electric power from Norway at all. They are doing everything to delay it. Corrupt politicians like those from the FDP (Brüderle) are their puppets.

Actually there are more alternatives and base load is not the same all the time. If you have a large grid distributing wind generated electricity from a large area, that provides part of the base load for most of the days of the year.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by adrianN on Sunday April 03, 2011 @04:35AM (#2402181)
Solar thermal with molten salt heat storage might be a viable baseload alternative.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by asharp on Sunday April 03, 2011 @11:08AM (#2402865)
It still has the same problem that you can't "turn them up" to cope with higher demand over longish periods, which makes dealing with them tricky. They are a good step though.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by kalleboo on Sunday April 03, 2011 @05:13AM (#2402238)
As someone who lives in a country where half the year it's -10℃ with 2 hours of sunlight (zero hours if it's cloudy), I'd have to say it's not quite viable.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by lispm on Sunday April 03, 2011 @10:03AM (#2402686)
Most of the world's population is in more sunny areas.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by Ratfish on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:14AM (#2402046)
I know it's easy to suggest as a New Zealander (lots of mountains, lots of rain, and not that many people), but that hydro you mention is ace, wish all our power came from it.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by ctman on Sunday April 03, 2011 @05:44AM (#2402278)
Dams aren't impervious to killing lots of people either: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vajont_Dam http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam

2 incidents in 15 years: 175,000+ killed. Plus they emit methane in huge quantities (from the decay of plant materiel in the reservoir)

I would bet that for New Zealand the best form of energy would be geothermal even though the long-term effect studies around cooling the earth's crust are lacking.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by Tichy on Sunday April 03, 2011 @04:39AM (#2402191)
Your Wikipedia article also says that in China, 1000 times more people die while mining (per "coal unit") than in the US (China produces twice the coal of the US, 6000 deaths/year in China va 28/year US). So throwing numbers around like you do is dishonest. 28 deaths is still too many, but it is a big difference to the sob story you present.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by gaspard on Sunday April 03, 2011 @11:46AM (#2402972)
You guys keep amazing me. Do you forget that nuclear plants produce tons of waste that has to be kept far away from any life form for thousands of years ? Do you know any written language or sign or whatever that is 10'000 years old and which human people can understand and use cautiously ?

Nuclear waste is going to be the worst legacy we give to our children and grandchildren. They will hate us for this.

And, even if the waste is going to give trouble (and to cost) people in the future, these same people handling our radioactive waste won't have any fuel left:

Toxic waste is forever, fuel is for 50 years. Doesn't that look dumb to you ?

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Fuel_composit...

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by pdonis on Sunday April 03, 2011 @12:12PM (#2403033)
Follow the link in the Wikipedia page to the article on reprocessing. It solves both of the issues you raise: it greatly extends the time the fuel lasts, and it greatly shortens the time that the remaining waste is dangerous. The only reason this was even an issue in the US (it isn't in other nuclear-using countries) is that the Carter administration banned reprocessing because of misplaced concerns about proliferation. In March 1999 the Clinton administration finally reversed that position (probably because it was obvious by then that reprocessing didn't increase proliferation risk--every other nuclear-using country has reprocessed its fuel from the beginning and there have been no incidents). So we can just take all the stuff that was supposed to be stored in Yucca Mountain for 10,000 years and reprocess it instead. Problem solved.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by gaspard on Sunday April 03, 2011 @12:57PM (#2403167)
I don't believe reprocessing means "no waste" but anyway, that's just half of the problem: what will we do in 50 years ?

And how do you reprocess the lives of the 200'000 people who had to leave after the nuclear accident in Tchernobyl alone ? Tell the fishermen by Fukushima to go reprocess their lives because some over-confident engineers thought they mastered what they were doing.

Nuclear power is just like the "green revolution": pure megalomania by people too afraid to consider alternatives like... a less power greedy way of living.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by pdonis on Sunday April 03, 2011 @07:11PM (#2404482)
I didn't mean to imply that reprocessing meant no waste: it means a lot less waste, that needs to be stored safely for a much shorter time. Also, since it allows you to use the fuel much more efficiently (without reprocessing, only a couple of percent of the usable fuel actually gets used; the rest ends up mixed in with the waste and is just stored without being used), it does solve the 50 year problem as well.

That said, I also didn't mean to say that we shouldn't consider all the impacts of nuclear power. But, as many others in this thread have commented, to be fair we should also consider all the impacts of other power sources as well.

As for a less power greedy way of living, I'm all for it, as long as I don't have to give up actual functionality. I'm all for having more efficient cars, but I'm not going to give up having a car; the freedom it gives me is too valuable to give up. (And no, living somewhere where I don't need a car to have that freedom is not an option. Been there, done that, prefer not to. Not everyone wants to live in that kind of environment.)

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by billybob on Sunday April 03, 2011 @08:45AM (#2402576)
Doesn't uranium get mined? How safe is that?
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by Groxx on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:56PM (#2403677)
It takes a few orders of magnitude less ore to power a nuclear plant for X time periods than it takes to power a coal plant. Even if they're equivalent in danger, you're still comparing whales and minnows.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jschrf on Sunday April 03, 2011 @12:14AM (#2401783)
One thing that blows my mind with the Fukushima plant (and presumably others) is that the spent fuel pond is seemingly built above ground. Wouldn't you want this to be at the very bottom of the reactor building, so that water could collect in it in an emergency situation like in Fukushima where water is pumped in from above? Maybe this is (was) one of the unknowns/unthoughtofs that you mention.

As an aside, if no one's seen the excellent Battle for Chernobyl, I highly recommend it. It details the insane clean-up operation that took place after the Chernobyl disaster. It's on Google Video.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by gamble on Sunday April 03, 2011 @12:41AM (#2401832)
The plant is built like that so spent fuel can be lifted out of the reactor and placed directly in the pool using one crane. A more secure spent-fuel pool would have required more elaborate fuel handling, thus a more expensive design.

Also, when these plants were built I don't think they anticipated the spent-fuel pools would become long-term storage. There was the assumption that centralized nuclear waste disposal sites would be built and the pools would only store waste until it was safe to transfer.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jorangreef on Sunday April 03, 2011 @07:44AM (#2402468)
This is often the case, a plan for the removal of waste to a disposal site is promised, and then once the plant is built, and the contractors have been paid, nothing happens. New plants are then built, it is said that a disposal plan will be put into effect, and still these plans never materialize.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by marze on Sunday April 03, 2011 @01:08AM (#2401870)
Putting the fuel storage pool on the fifth floor of the reactor does seem questionable, especially given the violence of the explosion at reactor 3.

Another "unknown bug" exposed by these events will probably motivate mitigating the risk of hydrogen explosions from hydrogen generated in a partial meltdown. As you can see in the second picture in this link,

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2399676

the force of the explosion crushed the concrete structure of the adjacent reactor building, and launched enough material into the air that it created holes 60 feet in diameter in the roof of the turbine building when it came down. This was not anticipated; if it were the reactors would have been constructed further apart.

The spent fuel rods must be actively cooled for many months after they are removed from the reactor due to heat-generating radioactive daughter products. Since the pools holding them have either boiled away due to the absence of active cooling or drained into the basement due to damage, it is likely these rods overheated. Japanese authorities have mentioned the possibility of "re-criticality", which would be a bad thing, especially in a fuel pond with no containment whatsoever.

There will probably be many lessons gained from these events that will be used to reduce risks in other operating reactors and future designs.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by bradgessler on Sunday April 03, 2011 @04:20AM (#2402159)
Link to video mentioned above http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wv3a4LXi_qc
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jbert on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:23AM (#2402057)
Out if interest, the way I'd try and design a fail-safe solution would be to have meltdown trigger a shutdown.

Picture a bunch of large, heat-proof (ceramic?) test-tubes, with their bases apart but their openings together.

Put that underneath the core - then if it melts and drops down, small pieces of it flow in different directions - until you've got a sub-critical amount in each one - so the fission reaction stops.

Anything which requires active prevention of fission seems odd, presumably passive is better?

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by asharp on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:33AM (#2402072)
I would have a look at pebble bed reactors, molten salt reactors and heavy water moderated reactors.

long story short, the designs exist, we just can't seem to get rid of the old ones that are currently built and we can't seem to get the new designs built in any sort of scale.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by GFischer on Sunday April 03, 2011 @10:11AM (#2402708)
The R&D costs for those are HUGE, as they are unproven, the countries like mine (Uruguay) that are looking into building new power plants don't want that, we want proven designs.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by russss on Sunday April 03, 2011 @10:25AM (#2402741)
The issue at Fukushima isn't criticality, though. All the reactors were safely shut down seconds after the earthquake hit, and no new fission has occurred since then.

The problem is that even a shut-down reactor core generates significant heat due to the decay of fission by-products, and that's what caused the problems.

That said, there are other reactor designs which are more inherently safe.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jbert on Sunday April 03, 2011 @02:09PM (#2403364)
> The problem is that even a shut-down reactor core generates significant heat due to the decay of fission by-products

Ah, thanks. I hadn't appreciated that.

Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jorangreef on Sunday April 03, 2011 @07:46AM (#2402473)
The way I'd try and design a fail-safe solution would be not to design it in the first place. No one is forcing us to build these things. But government contracts are lucrative and contractors exist.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jarek on Sunday April 03, 2011 @11:06AM (#2402862)
No one is forcing you. A lot of people just think refrigeration is awfully nice to have.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by jorangreef on Sunday April 03, 2011 @06:19PM (#2404314)
We will all be called to account for every careless word we have spoken.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by WalterBright on Saturday April 02, 2011 @11:57PM (#2401758)
There are a lot of parallels with airliner design. From reading articles about the nuke plant design, I think they could learn a lot from aviation engineers about how to build safe systems.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by gnosis on Sunday April 03, 2011 @03:42AM (#2402089)
I'm sure they know how to build safe systems. But equally important is whether they'll spend the money necessary to make them safe, or if they'll sacrifice safety in the name of profit.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by phlux on Sunday April 03, 2011 @12:47AM (#2401841)
So, how is nuclear fuel transported from wherever is it manufactured to the reactor? Why cant that process be implemented to transfer the fuel out of the reactor?
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by asharp on Sunday April 03, 2011 @02:43AM (#2402008)
If memory serves, the problem is that it is politically impossible to create some area to place the waste fuel. ie. it would be much safer to move the spent fuel out of the reactor, however there is nowhere for it to go to.
Re:Nuclear Power is Safest Way to Make Electricity by phlux on Sunday April 03, 2011 @06:22PM (#2404323)
I am talking about taking it out of the damaged reactor and into a sound containment/cooling unit.

That is far better politically than letting it sit in a damaged structure leaking radiation everywhere.

Sometimes nations need to STFU about politics and get shit done.