Deductibles should be a rolling 12 month bill. If you have something major in December you should be good until next December. This would eliminate all of the issues with deductibles rolling over on Jan 1. It would even bring extra profit to the insurance companies because people might decide to stick with their provider another year since "I already made my deductible until November".
That said, I was able to take advantage of it by making sure my surgery was scheduled before end of year. Ended up paying something like $200, rather than $1500 if it had happened in January.
I did this and it was pretty close.
Of course, they don't make any guarantees that's it accurate. But hell, it's a start.
If they couldn't provide an estimate because unexpected things happen and they can't predict all services that will be required, that'd be one thing. But they can't even provide a list like, "if you need an aspirin, that costs $X. And if you need..."
And just because they "billed" your insurance $85k doesn't mean they were actually paid $85. Billable vs allowable and all that mess.
However, if you went into the hospital and asked for the cash cost of a routine procedure they very likely would be able to give you a close approximation to what you would end up paying.
In their case it was a scheduled c-section. In any case they can at the least give you a range: min-max.
Additionally, hospitals keep very accurate track of their c-section rates, so even if they are not able to predict yours in particular, they can definitely tell you what your odds are ahead of time.
And, there are other countries and healthcare systems in which they internally take care of the stats/metrics so that they make a decent amount while you pay a reasonable amount that they tell you before you choose to get the procedure.
The hospital doesn't tell you the estimate of anything because they are afraid of the liability (or maybe just accountability).
It's just lazy or maybe too convenient, to say it can't be done. I mean if already health insurance companies can give you a fixed monthly amount to pay, then they know very well how much it's going to cost them, why not tell us?
That's a difference in the financing system, which hospitals have about as much say in as consumers do.
The insurance companies (including government payers like Medicaid and Medicare) don't just control reimbursement, they control what providers can bill to customers, too. And that includes (by usual and customary charge rules) influencing what they can and need to charge to customers that aren't even being reimbursed by the payer in question.
In some ways, yes.
In other ways, it's insane that people are able to borrow 5-10x their average annual income for an item (the house) that they have very little expertise in analyzing. In that sense, it's a process that is surprising it works at all.
> You'll have tough time getting 5x.
5x isn't tough. It's easy. In fact, better.com will give it to you right now.
You spelled "profitable" wrong.
Your bank should be upfront about their lender fees, points and origination costs.
Third party fees are either fixed or a simple percentage of the sale price.
The rest can be tricky, but should not be a deal-breaker for a new homeowner. Basically you are just paying the expenses for a short while up front. Interest through the end of the month, real estate taxes through the end of the quarter, Home owners and mortgage insurance and real estate taxes for the escrow account to cover 2-3 months.
[1] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/competition-matters/20...
The FTC article you cite is actually in favor of the type of transparency lamented by the comment you are responding to.
> The staff comment explained the risk that the latter type of transparency might harm competition by enabling competing providers to coordinate or collude on price
Where "latter type" referred to "plan structures and contracted fee schedules between health plans, hospitals, and physician service entities." (The "former type" was "actual or predicted out-of-pocket expenses, co-pays, and quality and performance comparisons of plans or providers" which is what would effect parent's experiences; the FTC "encouraged" that type of legislature.)
I don't necessarily agree with the FTC here, but their comment isn't covering the lack of information that causes consumers have no idea what the bill is until they've already incurred the bill.
Most, if not all, health plans in the US have annual out of pocket maximums on the order of $10,000 per individual.
My own experience here is driven by having gone in for what I expected to be a $50-$100 visit (a doctor took a look at my vocal chords); it was $4,000. How that is justified, I still don't know. (Thankfully, insurance covered some of it, but for such a minor visit, it was still way more expensive than I expected.) I don't know that "well, it can't be more than $10,000" is much comfort when you're walking in for something that seems minor, such as lingering effects of a cold (this example) or an infected finger (I was unable to obtain any pricing for this, prior to the visit).
A few years later, surgery would have cost me ~$300. (But that was under an HMO. And I got a quote, in advance!)
(While my initial post specifically mentioned PPOs, as that is what I'm used to, there are also those without insurance, which doesn't have the max out-of-pocket of an insurance plan.)
[1]: Given that a mere c-section (30min, super standard procedure) + 3 days at the hospital can be $85k. It's probably pretty common for hospital bills to exceed a few hundred thousands for anything more complicated or requiring a long stay at the hospital.
For 2020, it's ~$8k for an individual and ~$16k for a family. Most non-high deductible plans are a few thousand for an individual and high-deductible plans can be close to $10k.
[1]https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-li...
I think Westinghouse was the big FTC price-transparency-can-be-bad case.
That's orthogonal to the post's issue, though: he paid exactly the price he was quoted for services rendered; that he didn't understand the services he was consuming isn't really Amazon's problem but it's great they jumped in to help a $0 account (which, of course, was self-serving)...
Price fixing will only happen if there is no actual competition for customers, otherwise being the cheaper service is the easiest tool to increase your share of the market. Besides, isn’t that already the reality with prices being fixed in partnership with insurance providers?
There are simpler mechanisms for communicating price fixing - like saying "we won't be beaten on price" - that don't need to mention the price at all.
My point was that pricing transparency is not a panacea. It seemed that some people were reacting as though pricing transparency is a magical salve.
AWS: In my experience, AWS pricing has been transparent and great and they generally take steps to keep you from foot-gunning yourself. This article discusses a case in which the author foot-guns himself using a predictable mechanism AWS can't really prevent. I'm unsure of what else AWS could do to protect him from himself... (Anyone can throw out simple solutions without understanding S3's implementation complexity: they could seriously throttle their own product! ... but that might be seriously complicated and might hamper the value of the product to others. Besides, if you buy a M1A1 tank, you should be very careful about using it: it could use tons of fuel... He bought an M1A1, left the keys on the dash and then was surprised when he found got a huge fuel bill...).
I’ve been using fixed price services (they exist) just so I don’t run into what Chris did. They aren’t evangelized as well.
In my opinion, it's a very deceiving practice that could definitely be fixed if businesses really wanted to fix it. But there's no incentive, because if you show your prices including tax and fees, they'll seem more expensive than the competition.
In the case of hotels, my experience is that with a lot of them you book online, pay the total, but then when you go check out, they've added some extra fees. Sometimes this happens before booking, you browse the options and choose based on price, but when you go check out, the total has changed because they've added not only taxes but some other fees as well. My most recent experience having this issue was with AirBnb just two days ago.
I think I'm missing something when people use the excuse of "taxes are different in different places" to say "we don't show taxes out of habit, or because it requires us to change our signs".
In Brazil, the tax rate also changes city by city, and the price shown to the customer already includes that tax (together with the state tax and the federal tax).
I deal with reputable rental companies. The rental price is based on demand but everything else is a known quantity. I’ve never had the quote priced higher than the online quote. And in a few cases I’ve had it go down by using certain credit cards or loyalty programs.
Hotels have some of this but the overall uplift is usually a lot less--at least until they start adding "resort fees" to otherwise discounted rooms.
Unless you have scripts in place to nuke everything (which you will have to develop yourself since aws doesn not supply them), you have to manually login, and try to shut things of, while bill goes chaching
The only suspense left is whether I get the compact I signed up for, or some monstrous SUV because they’re all out of more sensible options. A few hints about how bad I am at backing up anything larger than a Camry has gotten results.
The last time I booked a rental car or hotel, I paid exactly what I was quoted at booking time.
[1]: https://www.ovh.com/world/dedicated-servers/rise/rise-1/
If my blog or apps are slashdotted (or HNed or whatever we should call it nowadays) they just load slower, degrading gracefully, and never stop or return an error.
At my previous employer we migrated to them and were very happy with the VMware infra they provided.
Since It's a Swedish company one can look into their economy to see that they're not going anywhere. https://www.allabolag.se/5566479241/glesys-ab
You rent a car, you don't know what the total is going to be. You go to the hospital, you don't know how much you're going to have to pay. You book a hotel and don't know the total until you check out. You go to a restaurant and even if you order just one thing and saw the exact price on the menu, that's not going to be the total. You go to the grocery store, see all the prices on the items, add them up, and then when you go pay, surprise!