> I'm not a fan of spam. Never will be
This isn't spam. It's a newsletter subscription people opt into by joining their website as a user. Users can opt-out of this specific newsletter in their FreeCodeCamp settings page and be fine and dandy afterwards.
Spam is something else entirely.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23943179
Do you seriously believe that everyone who uses C++, not necessarily by their own choice, is a bad programmer writing a bad program? Things are rarely that black and white.
For instance, a project I help to operate is a platform to help surgeons find anaesthetists for their surgeries, sometimes for emergencies at very short notice. It currently sends a few hundred emails a day, and everyone who receives them absolutely wants and needs to receive them. If the project keeps growing, the email volume could grow into the thousands per day. Is this morally reprehensible?
This project is not described by your summary. A project which could be described as such would not be immoral. But that's not what this is: this is a tool for enabling spam distribution.
> I intend to keep pushing back against wrongdoing, or else it'll keep happening
Given that it's not obvious why this project is overwhelmingly more suited to spam than legit the subscribed/responsible email distribution of the kind I described, you're not doing anything effective to keep "it" from happening, and you're only succeeding in yukking up HN.
Regarding newsletters, the majority of those are opt-out (as opposed to opt-in) and the opt-out process is intentionally convoluted ("untick this checkbox if you would prefer not to subscribe to our newsletter"), so as far as I'm concerned it's indeed spam.
https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/privacy-policy/
> We'll ask you for your email address so you can use it to sign into freeCodeCamp, and so we can send you announcements and helpful programming-related links.
Essentially, this is an "opt-in" process because you are opting to create your account and you agree with the site policies.
Granted, I'm in no way a legal professional and I could be wrong about everything I said here. Corrections are welcome.
A FreeCodeCamp account presumably offers more functionality beyond just the newsletter, and the majority of people would sign up for that functionality and not the newsletter.
Yet, there is no way to opt-out directly, and you have to go through extra steps to do so after the fact.
This is also in breach of the GDPR which mandates that consent for non-essential data processing (marketing communications fall into that) should be opt-in (so pre-ticked checkboxes are already forbidden) and freely given (so there is no penalty for declining, you can’t refuse to open an account for them if they decline consent).
I run a paid service that attempts to deal with exactly this problem - a key feature being to never think twice about giving out an email address.
I recently implemented "one touch" blocking to minimize friction in the process: https://kopi-cloud.atlassian.net/wiki/x/IoCvKg
I voluntarily subscribed some of the Cooper Press weekly newsletters https://cooperpress.com/publications/ They are definitely opt-in, not spam.
I regularly unsubscribe newsletters I didn't opt-in, usually from unknown sources. Not many of them lately and the opt-out usually works. I remember a couple of times I had to send an email with a mention of GDPR in it. It worked.
So "the majority" of newsletters are modern spam, not really.
There is definitely a minority out there like yourself that knows how to manage it and only subscribes to a few select newsletters, for I think for the majority of people, newsletters are a net negative otherwise you wouldn't see people with thousands of unread emails and there wouldn't be so much hype around tools like Hey.
This was quite disapointing.
You mean "Mail for Good"? I think it's because they are focusing on non-profits.
I don't have any details other than 1 credit card with them... So I'll never have a "balance", so their email is spam to me.
I never signed up for correspondence from PayPal about this. That they refuse to fix it is weird.
I get exactly zero bulk email in my inbox... Except for this PayPal nonsense.
> Mail for Good is fast and memory efficient, currently sending over 100 emails per second on a 1gb Digital Ocean VPS.
> We've used Mail for Good to deliver newsletters to hundreds of thousands of campers per week.
... Good? YMMV, but personally, I'm not a fan of spam. Never will be.