News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by chvid on Thursday July 23, 2020 @02:56PM (#23930913)
How relevant is ARM in the long run if Apple is pursuing its own design / CPU architecture ("Apple Silicon") and the Chinese lead by Huawei are forced by US sanctions also to create their own design / architecture?
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by Alupis on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:09PM (#23931056)
The number of units Apple sells with ARM designs inside (all devices - desktops, laptops, tablets, phones, and more) are dwarfed in comparison to the ARM ecosystem at large. ARM isn't dependent on Apple for anything really.

Even your toaster and fridge probably have ARM licensed designs in them. Your Smartwatch certainly does, and the billions of non-Apple smartphones too.

> Chinese lead by Huawei are forced by US sanctions also to create their own design

Pretty sure they were heading that way even without US sanctions. Steal the IP, then make a competing product while paying zero licensing fees to ARM.

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by p1mrx on Thursday July 23, 2020 @04:19PM (#23931807)
> Pretty sure they were heading that way even without US sanctions. Steal the IP, then make a competing product while paying zero licensing fees to ARM.

Huawei would be in a better long-term position if they chose RISC-V versus IP theft.

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by Alupis on Thursday July 23, 2020 @04:21PM (#23931819)
Maybe... RISC-V might be up-and-coming, but current-day ARM designs are battle tested already and will continue to be very useful for the foreseeable future. Stealing the IP now allows them to produce great CPU's today with far less cost.

It's not trivial to build a CPU. Particularly if there is no existing industry with expertise in this field within your country.

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by ksec on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:01PM (#23930973)
Apple is still using ARM. And benefits greatly from the ARM ecosystem from compiler to software compatibilities. Having their own design doesn't mean they dont rely on ARM. No idea about the 2nd part of the question though.
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by formerly_proven on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:01PM (#23930976)
Doesn't Apple have a perpetual license to their current ISA anyway? And it's not like Apple would need external help to refine/develop the current ISA.
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by nightfly on Thursday July 23, 2020 @02:59PM (#23930954)
ARM will continue to be relevant for embedded stuff for a long time.
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by ryanmarsh on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:00PM (#23930959)
ARM is the IP house for the ARM architecture. Control of ARM means control over all the IP (lots of patents) for ARM based processors used across many industries in many devices.

You can imagine what might happen if an anti-competitive player controlled the major competing architecture to x86.

"He who controls the spice controls the universe." etc, etc...

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by chvid on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:21PM (#23931204)
Or let me ask in different way: why use ARM if you control and build the whole stack from electronics to operating system to the software running on it?

The core instruction set is from the 80es. Surely you can come up with some better today were you to design it from scratch?

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by Alupis on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:25PM (#23931259)
> Surely you can come up with some better today were you to design it from scratch?

Ya, but then you have to develop and support the entire ecosystem around just the instruction set. That means compilers, languages, runtimes, and more - which is not a trivial undertaking.

Perhaps Apple could pull it off, but it would take a very long time to get something entirely new stable enough, and performant enough, to compete with anything being offered today.

Plus, it's not Apple's focus and doesn't really benefit them much either. Nobody builds iOS apps in assembler - but they expect it to run fast. That takes a very well tuned compiler, and a very well refined CPU architecture.

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by mjw1007 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:36PM (#23931369)
The 64-bit ARM ISA was basically redone from scratch, around 2010.

It isn't "mostly the same instructions but with 64-bit registers" the way 64-bit x86 is.

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by earthscienceman on Thursday July 23, 2020 @04:32PM (#23931915)
Do you (or anyone else) know where I can read about that?
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by trasz on Thursday July 23, 2020 @06:21PM (#23933230)
Just google for "ARMv8".

(Also, it's not like ARM was a single instruction set before either. For quite some time ARM had two totally different instruction encodings, the "usual one", and Thumb2, with microcontrollers usually only supporting the latter.)

Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by mjw1007 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @06:15PM (#23933129)
Re:Report: ARM is for sale and Nvidia’s interested, Apple isn’t by nicoburns on Thursday July 23, 2020 @03:58PM (#23931605)
> why use ARM if you control and build the whole stack from electronics to operating system to the software running on it?

Why not use ARM if the alternative is to build an entire software stack from scratch. ARMs licensing fees are very reasonable, and then you get most of the free software ecosystem for free.