You say it in your second paragraph. You're no biologist. But you find it strange. Very few biologists find it strange. They have in fact been warning of a ticking time bomb [0 for brevity, 1 for article].
May I respectfully suggest that you stick to your lane regarding the science? WHO ups and downs and political bickering to one side, science is a messy process of honing in on the right answer and lay-people have a hard time wrapping their heads around that when other answers fitting in more closely with their world view abound. It would be nice if scientists could come out on day 1 and tell everyone exactly what to expect but that isn't how science works.
[0] https://scitechdaily.com/scientists-warned-that-china-was-a-... [1] https://cmr.asm.org/content/cmr/20/4/660.full.pdf
HN has always felt like a good/safe place (to me) to talk about interesting things with a mix of experts and lay people.
When it gets down to science though, agree or disagree need to be left to the experts. I can’t be the expert/final arbiter because my knowledge isn’t good enough (although I have some capacity), and so I am encouraging OP to go with the experts on this one. It’s too complex a field for people to have their own opinions based on hearsays - science should not be politics and we’re seeing that in the world now. It doesn’t matter what you believe coming in with science, you have to be guided by (a best approximation of the evolving) facts.
I’m not totally sure what you disagree on, is it the rudeness of ‘stay in your lane’ or my argument?
We don't rely on experts to tell us what we know or have the capacity of knowing. The hard to access ideas have already been articulated and written down in this case. OP is absolutely right to be misapprehensive in light of these studies and the perception of "it doesn't compute". By virtue of surviving to human adulthood, and to even be here admitting there may be the makings of ignorance in themselves, they've already proven they have a higher than average meta-awareness of their own capabilities, which means they have a similar basis from which to evaluate other people's action.
What they've seen from the experts in the field is a growing rift, and far from a universal consensus. They've seen an abnormally ineffectual and particularly inexplicable reaction from official sources. As a non-expert, if they weren't consumed with misapprehension, they'd be a fool.
All "official" means of rebuttal to disprove lab origin are stymied by refusal to submit to inspection by the rest of the world by the origin nation in question, and we have evidence of official orders to obfuscate any evidence trail that may have existed in the early stages of the pandemic.
You can dismiss the motivation for why (saving face/survival), but no reasonable non-expert with even a passing interest and the capability or inclination to follow the threads laid bare in those papers should shy away from trying to reason from it. The hard part that requires an expert is done. The paper is written. The known has been hewn from the unknown. The question people should be cogitating on is as follows:
"Given what I know my species is capable of, and the circumstantial proximity of all the physically mandated ingredients for this to even be a possibility, is it unreasonable that this crisis could have an origin from the one place on earth staffed, equipped, educated, and mandated by it's reason for existence to engage in the academic pursuit of the processes that could lead to a virus such as this?"
You do not need to be an expert to consume or evaluate the output of experts. We rely on experts to handle that which no human has handled before, or to quickly handle that which few have handled before, and we are not willing to walk the path to know. This is not that. Further, if everyone left it to the experts, there would be no experts. "Stay in your lane" has no business being aired in any context in which one or the other is in the process of endeavoring to further their own understanding. If a human being has done it, a human being can do it, and not one person on Earth has the standing to tell another not to reason to the best of their ability, or through communication with peers seek to surpass their previous limitations in that department. Science has not, and never should be, only the Ph.D holders need apply. Especially when the questions being asked are far away from technical minutiae, and closer to "Given everything that would be needed to make it happen was there, should we consider lab origin as worthy of delving into?"
Given material I covered earlier in the thread (on the ill-advised endeavor of blindly deferring to the fox on matters relating to the security of the hen house), the answer should strike expert and non-expert alike as worth looking into. The expert can be forgiven for not deeming it worth it, at least, as they have much more pressing issues to attend to in trying to stop/prevent the next thing. The non-expert on the other hand should be seriously weighing how much we trust our neighbors when they say "Nope. Nothing to see here. Why are you looking anyway? How dare you! Questioning our handling of internal matters!"
Tell someone they're wrong when they have facts wrong, or don't have all of them, guiding them in the right direction, but don't dare tell a person to cease in their attempts to enlighten themselves and reason from what is in front of them. Especially on a forum where the entire point is to share knowledge with the very experts who should putatively be being deferred to.
Stay in your lane. The nerve. The unabashed gall. Here, of all places.
So when scientific papers match my layman intuition (though I do know something about evolution in general, just not microbiology) and I also see the so-called 'real experts' lying about the facts, and some other experts are writing papers which seem to confirm with my intuition, then my intuition has a lot more weight.
I don't think there is a respectful way to utter this phrase. Honestly, even saying "I think you're full of shit" would be more respectful.
When COVID-19 spread, there was literally nothing different occuring at the time that could have provoked any evolutionary changes in any virus to be more evolved in infecting humans outside of normal human density levels.
Flu viruses have been evolving in humans for millenia. This has not.
There is now, though. We're selecting strains that aren't as concerned with masks and social distancing. Back in March, I remember reading some anecdotal accounts of cities' responses to H1N1, but it wasn't widespread. We've never actually stopped somethings this widespread, so it's not clear how these measures play out long-term.
Carriers of the more symptomatic strains were transported to military hospitals which acted as conduits of transmission.
The result was the virus progressively evolving to become more deadly.
The first wave of the Spanish flu had a fatality rate that is typical of the flu, with deaths preponderantly amongst the elderly, which again is typical.
The second wave was massively more deadly, and killed the young in large numbers.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu#Transmission_and_m...
Luc montagnier made a lot of money writing about how homeopathy works thanks to water memory, i'd say i would disqualify every work he's done since then if it is not peer-reviewd.
But in a way this further proves my point. How can one be expected to "stick to one's lane" when you have to check on each and every "expert" out there. It is quite valid to think by oneself!
It's surprising to me the GP looked at what a Nobel laureate said with trust and was still told to "stick to one's lane".
And if science facts need to be "voted on" by a majority of scientists then it stops being a fact and more like an informed guess. But that doesn't necessarily mean a layman could not reach the same or a better conclusion.
To be more specific, the origins of SARS-CoV-2 are still potentially unknown but if the overwhelming scientific consensus is that it has natural origin. So what does the purpose of dissenting voices, and the average joe seizing on one of these because 'it feels right'? It's the same problem that has lead to anti-vaccers - the unneecessary sewing of doubt where it is not their place to doubt.
Stay open minded, ask important questions, but for gods sake, if you are not a scientist, recognise that those that are trained people who are doing much of the hard work for you. And scientific concensus is not going to be overturned by someone listening to the president on fox news or one outlier quack peddler
Bats are mammals, and so far from “totally unrelated” to humans, but...
> be so well adapted to spreading between humans?
So, Spanish flu wasn't of avian (far less related to humans than bats) origin but was also a man-made bioweapon?
I'm also completely flabbergasted that you take 1 person's opinion, despite it being the opposite of the opinions of a general educated scientific community, and you take that one person's opinion more seriously.
And apparently you are not a historian, either, because we've had viruses spread in humans in the past. I don't see how this being a naturally-made virus is crazier than it being man-made. In fact, it's crazy if it is man-made.
Substantial evidence and compelling arguments can overcome these priors. But it’s a big claim with huge implications so I think caution is warranted.
Add also that the scientists have been warning for decades that another SARS-alike was almost inevitable, cf.
> The now-prophetic words could be found at the end of a research paper published in the journal Clinical Microbiology Reviews in October of 2007: “The presence of a large reservoir of SARS-CoV-like viruses in horseshoe bats, together with the culture of eating exotic mammals in southern China, is a time bomb.”
https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/06/scientist...
Nature in general creates amazing things on its own. Viruses are constantly mutating in animals, people are closer to these animals, and travel is ubiquitous. There’s a reason that many smart people have been warning and preparing for this to happen. No matter how unlikely, lotteries are won.
https://science.thewire.in/the-sciences/luc-montagnier-coron...
This feels like confusing weather and climate, and working backwards from a conclusion.
The evolutionary chance to make a single virus so well suited to human hosts is probably very small. If you take a single event and work backwards it seems very unlikely.
But in aggregate over time, it'll happen fairly regularly, hence the warnings.
Rather than simply berate as sibling comments have done, I'm going to try and explain it as I understand it (also as a layperson).
Basically, you have the compatibility at the wrong level, and the effect backwards.
Bats and humans are very different from each other when taken as a whole, but if you dive into the smaller structures, they're much more similar. Lungs, heart, blood, etc, and well as deeper to cells. Viruses adapt at those levels, able to attack cells with specific structures, so when they jump species those similar structures are what get attacked. This is why it appears well-adapted to humans, because it is well-adapted to similar cell structures shared between animals.
As for the effect: The viruses in total exist at that same level, and our bodies haven't adapted to them, so we have no strong defense* in the form of antibodies. On top of that, it's a respiratory virus, where simple breathing can spread it rather than requiring some sort of physical contact. Those two reasons combined are why it spreads so fast.
* Not exactly true, I'm simplifying. We do have defenses, they just don't seem to be as effective against this virus. See "innate immune system" for un-targeted defenses that work on a variety of invaders, and "adaptive immune system" for the one that creates antibodies.
Speaking of which, he also buys into the homeopathy thing. Yes, he did important work on HIV, but given his overall track record, his support of COVID conspiracies should make you less credulous, not more.
http://nautil.us/issue/83/intelligence/the-man-who-saw-the-p...
Even Nobel laureates are humans prone to mistakes.
It's social and cultural influences all the way down.
[0]http://www.aboutintelligence.co.uk/what-intelligence.html [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_(human_categorization)
He also never proclaimed any kind of race superiority. Pointing out a conclusion of his research can not be racists even if the facts turn out to be wrong because of an error. Or maybe the facts stay correct in case of the IQ differences but other research suggests that IQ points are horribly to measure intelligence. Either way you would need to find prejudice, discrimination or basis IN HIS RESEARCH not in his concussion to convict him of actually being racist. Errors or definition changes simply should lead to a new concision that would be that there is still a measurable difference in brains but it doesn't directly correlate to intelligence. In every other similar situation this would be common sense. For example people with Trisomy 21 have statistically significant lower IQs. Its just a fact. No one comes around and screams racism if you state that fact. Also no one who states that fact wants to express their superiority over these people. In fact people who research all this are on the front line to support these people because knowing the differences is what allows coexisting with maximal individual freedom. Denying differences does not help anyone.
>It's social and cultural influences all the way down. Plenty of research suggests otherwise. Like I said in my previous post "how likely is it actually that the brain is the same for all?" While all the rest of the human body has differences. Its actually very very unlikely and reality is almost certainly a mix between social and cultural influences and genetic differences in the brain but also in the rest of the body that affects the brain in millions of different ways.
The rest is just a lie. There are plenty known significant differences especially difference in risk for diseases that are linked to genetic differences. And that's about the only place where research is done today because if you literally are the person who tries to cure cancer you are apparently whitelisted ehm... I mean allowlisted from seeing genetic differences.
They are free to self publish, but no one should be forced to publish their work.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luc_Montagnier#Research_on_ele...
[1]https://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2012/06/27/luc-montagnier...
These are truly fascinating claims, especially the second, which despite the credibility and stature of the source, have been targeted rather than reported by traditional media outlets in the U.S.
[1] https://www.gilmorehealth.com/chinese-coronavirus-is-a-man-m...
He has made claims supporting homeopathy, and claimed to have evidence of DNA teleportation. That's reason enough to lose credibility.
I'm not a biologist but I do find it strange that COVID-19 is so infectious in humans. How can a virus which supposedly 'naturally evolved' in a totally unrelated animal species (bats) be so well adapted to spreading between humans? Intuitively, that doesn't make sense.
Also the fact that the WHO has kept changing its story about this virus from the beginning is not reassuring at all. At this stage, as crazy as it is, I'm inclined to believe the conspiracy theorists because the official version comes across as even crazier.