Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by gmuslera on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:13PM
(#23872875)
Is not a CO2 reduction, but that to the excess of CO2 that is already in the atmosphere, we worsened the situation as much as previous 2 years, not more. There is little to celebrate or feel relieved about it, we are still bleeding, but at least the cut stopped getting wider.
The other "good" news is that we lowered the increase caused by carbon and replaced it with new emissions from oil and gas that may have other side effects.
I'm a bit negative about this, even for an article that seem to have possitive news, maybe next year report will give us brigther news because there was less activity because the coronavirus.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:23PM
(#23873740)
I'm not in favor of this attitude. If the wound is widening exponentially and you stop it from widening that's a big step in solving the issue. Basically you can move from containment to treatment.
Taking steps towards solving an issue doesn't mean anyone is claiming we solved it or doesn't recognize that we still have hundreds of miles ahead in our journey. But rather you use the past success as motivation to build momentum. You should look at the past and say "hey, we've made measurable and meaningful change. Small, but it shows that what we're doing is working. Now is the time to fight harder." Revel in that success and use it to fuel your efforts. I believe putting these things in a negative light instead paints a picture that we haven't gotten far and that our efforts aren't working. Thus disheartening people and turns them apathetic. ("There's nothing I can do")
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by dmos62 on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:13PM
(#23874284)
Both of your perspectives are essential. We can't feel relieved, because there's a monumental amount of work left, and we should not discount what progress has been made, because that will discourage further progress.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by tunesmith on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:29PM
(#23874467)
I think the GP is an important point though, because for those not following it closely, that graph can look like good news when it isn't. It's like the difference between speed and acceleration - if you're accelerating toward a wall it doesn't help your situation if you switch to merely maintaining current velocity.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @07:44PM
(#23877388)
> that graph can look like good news when it isn't.
Except it IS good news. But good news doesn't mean we solved the problem. This is a small victory, but doesn't mean it isn't a victory nonetheless. We need to break away from this binary thinking. Good news and bad news are a continuous spectrum. My issue here is that people are saying "well we're not done, therefore the news isn't good." To me this is fundamentally wrong and distinctiveness the human psychology.
> if you're accelerating toward a wall it doesn't help your situation if you switch to merely maintaining current velocity.
Except it does. The force you hit the wall with is proportional to the velocity you strike it. It is better to hit the wall at 100mph than 200mph. For a more accurate analogy consider that the peddle has been stuck to the floor this entire time and we've dislodged it. This is the first major step to slowing down (there's been tons of minor steps along the way).
For a more logical view: to be effective moving forward we have to look at the past to see what has been successful so that we can better focus our resources.
A battle is not the war. Celebrating the victory of a battle is not celebrating a victory in a war. You celebrate your victories along the way because otherwise you lose hope. I think this psychology should be very apparent considering the existential crisis and hopelessness that people have. Maybe we shouldn't be encouraging that attitude.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by kiliantics on Friday July 17, 2020 @05:54PM
(#23876366)
A lot of people in the west believe that we will somehow "figure it out" and that their way of life will never have to change for a solution (or be forced to change by the consequences from the lack of a solution). I think news like this is often viewed as some kind of reassurance to people of this belief. Perspective matters, which is why these kinds of results need to be given in their proper context -- i.e. extreme alarm that we are still only stopping an increase now, decades after first understanding that this was a problem yet continuing to increase our carbon output, and only during a pandemic-induced economic slowdown.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @07:57PM
(#23877479)
I agree with what you are saying, but this is a technical document. So the perspective of "good news" or "still bad news" is in our interpretation. We are providing said context. While I'm being optimistic here it is because I'm responding to a comment which I view as too pessimistic and encouraging hopelessness. I would (and do) go after a similar comment if it was trying to claim victory over the crisis.
The thing is that if we think about climate change as a war then this is an important battle we've won. We've STOPPED the invading army. We did not push them back, we did not defeat the entire army, but for the first time we've been able to stop the invading army from gaining ground. By all accounts, before it looked hopeless. But if that kind of battle doesn't instill hope, I don't know what does. We haven't won the war, but for the first time we haven't been slaughtered in a major battle.
We need to stop believing that anything that isn't complete victory is bad news. All that does is create a hopeless future, which turns people apathetic. Just because you haven't won the war doesn't mean you shouldn't celebrate your small victories and improve moral. That is the issue, moral.
> and only during a pandemic-induced economic slowdown.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by briandear on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:27PM
(#23874451)
> maybe next year report will give us brigther news because there was less activity because the coronavirus.
That “brighter news” would be at the expense of millions of jobs and livelihoods destroyed. In the US over 40% of black owned businesses are not expected to survive. Thousands of restaurants have been closed forever, and the toll keeps climbing.
That isn’t “brighter news” by any stretch.
Those safely ensconced in their work from home jobs might not get it, but the millions of small businesses are struggling and many are dying. Claiming “brighter news” for this is macabre.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by kiliantics on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:33PM
(#23873153)
Yes, any news that is not about massive reductions in total CO2 emissions (not just from energy sector) should be considered extremely bad news. Because that's what it is. Our collective apathy and resignation to continued destruction needs to stop. We need to be mad as hell and not take it anymore.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @08:01PM
(#23877517)
Get mad as hell, yes. But also revel in your victories. This is a long and arduous journey. People don't have the energy to be mad through all of it. They give up when we don't show how we're making progress. NO ONE IS SAYING STOP WE'VE WON. No one. But recognize that moral is low and it needs to improve. So let's celebrate the small victory and with our new and improved moral continue pushing forward.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by dmos62 on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:23PM
(#23874404)
I would like to ask fellow readers to not downvote this line of comments. I may disagree with the sentiment, but meeting it with hostility would only cause apathy and resignation that the commentor talks about. It would be great to see important discussions happening with inclusiveness and understanding. That's what it takes to not fall apart when bad things happen.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by nicc on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:51PM
(#23873361)
Wrong website for saying this.
You'll be cancelled and flagged (and so will I). COULD NOT AGREE MORE!
I also want to see what happens after in 2020 the whole world has stopped. Let's how many degrees the temperature lowers even with most factories and economical activity gone for months.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by cmrdporcupine on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:15PM
(#23874303)
I hope you're joking. Pretty much all the potentially usable land in Canada is already in use, regardless of climate change. The issue with Canadian agricultural lands isn't climate it's soil quality. Almost everything else isn't going to be arable because it's thin soils over granite bedrock (Canadian shield). If you go really far north there's areas in permafrost but that's a) arid and b) would be poor fertility anyways. Likely to desertify if it actually got that warm.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Waterfall on Saturday July 18, 2020 @01:20AM
(#23879198)
It isn't about just fertility, it can have other uses, and its also possible to make it more fertile (although it is a poor choice as farmland). Las Vegas for example is very inhospitable, as was the ancient Persepolis.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by moultano on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:40PM
(#23873224)
One unfortunate side effect of this is that methane leaks are growing due to the switch from coal to natural gas, and we don't know how much. The impact of that natural gas may make this switch net negative in terms of its climate impact, and we just don't know.
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/12/12/climate/texas...
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Aunche on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:26PM
(#23873766)
Natural gas is releases half as much CO2 as coal, and methane is roughly 28x worse as a greenhouse gas and other natural gases sink. Natural gas would be better than coal as long as if we aren't leaking 1/28th of our natural gas. That would be an awful lot of wasted money, so I'm inclined to believe that natural gas is still better than coal.
That is only when gas has reached the supplier. Don't forget gas is also lost when drilling and also lost in huge amounts when drilling for oil. Gut feel, from the limited research I've done I would guess losses as far above the 1/28th sadly.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Aunche on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:22PM
(#23875068)
It looks like most of the leaks described in the second article are related to the gas utilities rather than gas used to generate electricity. I'd like to imagine that it's a lot cost effective and easier to make sure a big pipe that goes to a power plant is not leaking rather than a thousand small pipes that go to homes. It's an eye opening finding either way though.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by est31 on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:31PM
(#23874490)
Thawing permafrost with methane inside is also all over the place in Siberia. Ultimately it seems that we'll need an increase in several orders of magnitude of ability to do major engineering projects if we ever want to see the old climate again.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:17PM
(#23873669)
Flattening the rates is a really good sign. The issue is that we're using more an more energy each year (especially in the industrialized countries). This has been super linear growth in the past, due to lots of reinforcing feedback, and so flattening this is a major undertaking.
There's still a long way to go and a lot to do, but this itself has been a hard task and is one of the important milestones. It is a small victory, but a victory nonetheless.
So if you line up the graph in the OP on the left side of your screen/minds-eye and the graph from the IPCC on the right side, you get a feel for the dramatic swing in the second derivative that is necessary going forward.
Note that these models assume we develop massive negative emissions technology in the mid and late century. That is to say, those are already assumed, so you cant use "we'll just develop negative emissions technology" as a counterpoint to the necessary amount of change in the immediate term.
If you are at all skeptical of that technological development, then take a few hundred gigatons off the budget.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by bjoli on Friday July 17, 2020 @06:40PM
(#23876819)
I read somewhere that we need a Corona recession every year until 2030 to be on track for the 1.5c goal. I knew it wasn't going to happen before I read that, but that put it a bit in perspective.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @08:08PM
(#23877584)
I think you are misunderstanding peoples' interpretations. Hope and joy does not imply a delusion that we've succeeded. People are happy we've won a battle, not that we've won the war. People need hope and high morals to continue this fight. We can't win with everyone feeling hopeless and turning to apathy. This data shows that efforts to stop climate change are working. We can build off that momentum and continue pushing because now we can stand on data that shows the fight has been worth it and we do in fact have the power. This is contrary to the hopeless battle that many think it is. Because if it is hopeless, why not just give up.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by ericvanular on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:49PM
(#23874016)
Great to see progress, even if it is incremental and not where we need to be yet. We're really seeing the death knell in coal these days, with the power sector leading the way.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by kisamoto on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:08PM
(#23874905)
Disclaimer: Self-plug but I do feel it may be relevant to people here who wish to take responsibility for their greenhouse gas footprint.
If you're looking at CO₂ emissions and want to do something about your own footprint please consider removing your own emissions.
Reductions are great and all (definitely part of the necessary solution) however they do not address the existing excess of CO₂ in the atmosphere
I started "Carbon Removed"[0] for the exact purpose to bring carbon removal to everyone and make it easy for us all to compensate the damage we have done to the environment. We support carbon removal methods so you can turn your emissions into trees and stone.
If you're more interested in removal methods I suggest researching:
* tree planting - cheap and easy but slow to see results
* direct air capture and storage - new, innovative technology that can permanently remove CO₂ through mineralisation but is expensive at this stage. Search "climeworks"
* enhanced weathering - "olivine stones" and "project vesta" are good steps here that can slowly and naturally capture CO₂
* blue carbon - naturally removing carbon dioxide through ocean ecosystems
* biochar - "carbonise" organic material and use it as a soil supplement (as well as a carbon sink)
Personally I have been exceptionally happy to see the transition from "carbon credits" (which, IMHO provide dubious value and are hard to quantify) to net-zero emissions - the thought leading concept of today. Steps taken by Stripe[1] and Microsoft[2] to become "net zero" or even "carbon negative" help normalise this transition.
tl;dr: We can all reduce our footprints but we need to do more and remove the existing excess CO₂ in the atmosphere to get back to "normal".
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Waterfall on Saturday July 18, 2020 @01:30AM
(#23879243)
Trees do air capture and storage, they slowly and naturally capture CO2, and you can even turn them into "biochar". Blue carbon would just acidify oceans, a much worst case.
The kind of person that is pro carbon credit would prefer it even if carbon had no effects on the weather.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Waterfall on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:02PM
(#23873496)
Is CO2 emissions a large issue in global warming? When I was a little kid, I was wondering why having a greenhouse effect was bad for plants since we put them in greenhouses. I've been convinced by years that people smarter than me thought it was bad and I wasn't smart enough to understand.
Freeman Dyson changed my mind when I saw his interviews, detailing how CO2 has gone up a lot but it hasn't greatly increased the temperature, how it's good for vegetation growth and diversity, and how the climate models are just fluid dynamics and they don't show the full picture.
I've heard of a lot of FUD on it but what he says makes sense to me. I don't see a reason to worry about it when there are bigger issues, ocean acidification is a much larger world worry.
None of the lower carbon emission agreements are binding either, which shows how seriously they take it. Elites simply want to use it as a control for slowing developing countries under the guise of "saving the world".
We've changed the environment with buildings, cities, America used to have skies blackened by passenger pigeons so you could shoot a shotgun randomly at the sky and kill a bunch, turtles used to roam freely until the great depression caused everyone to eat them. Mao told everyone to kill the birds until their crops were devastated by insects and they had to import them back. This is not doomsday. The fossils we use for fuel used to live in a much more diverse and warm climate.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by ben_w on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:44PM
(#23874646)
Roughly one third of the CO2 you breathe wasn’t in the atmosphere before the industrial revolution. Atmospheric CO2 is absorbed into the oceans, acidifying it.
Even though you are correct that we put plants into greenhouses and it is good for them, most of the stuff we care about isn’t plants. As one example, enough CO2 will noticeably harm your intellect, and there is enough unburned carbon in the world to make us all dull-minded.
Changing the global average temperature by “1 degree” may not sound like much, but it’s enough to bleach corals and shift agriculture patterns. Even 4.5 degrees Celsius may not seem like much, but it is the difference between an ice age and a warm period, and we’re already in a warm period.
The ice age had ~200 ppm CO2, the preindustrial level was ~280, today is ~420 ppm.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Waterfall on Saturday July 18, 2020 @01:17AM
(#23879178)
The answer to that problem was already solved then: plant a billion trees or something to that degree and there will be no excess carbon.
>As one example, enough CO2 will noticeably harm your intellect, and there is enough unburned carbon in the world to make us all dull-minded.
Has IQ been going down due to that? Is that theoretical? Seems like improper breathing is a larger issue, and people in cities with worst local air have higher IQs than those in rural areas. Seems at best a non factor.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by ben_w on Saturday July 18, 2020 @08:49AM
(#23881073)
> The answer to that problem was already solved then: plant a billion trees or something to that degree and there will be no excess carbon.
I’m glad we agree there is a problem. Although a mere “billion” trees is well short of the scale of the solution.
Solving CO2 with carbon offsetting is part of the general model of “carbon credits“ and “carbon trading”, which can only work with a government-and-trade-agreement-mandated minimum carbon price.
That’s fine by me. Anything is, so long as it works and works “soon-ish” rather than “eventually”.
I am optimistic about the technology, I am pessimistic about the politics.
> Has IQ been going down due to that? Is that theoretical?
It is directly measurable in situations where CO2 is higher than wilderness levels. The study I’ve seen had three specific tested CO2 concentrations, which were roughly comparable to various modern-life scenarios such as city center offices or wearing full-face motorcycle helmets.
> Seems like improper breathing is a larger issue, and people in cities with worst local air have higher IQs than those in rural areas. Seems at best a non factor.
The CO2 level inside cities are indeed higher. As are the CO2 level inside sealed offices inside a city. These higher levels have a demonstrable, repeatably testable, negative impact on reasoning skills.
I have seen no prior claim of correlation between location and IQ, however I have seen a claim that city dwellers walk faster which turned out to be because cities attract young, skilled, ambitious people. Therefore, you would need to show causation not just correlation — especially as there are repeated demonstrations that CO2 impairs cognitive function, and that’s hardly the only pollutant one should expect to be more common in a city.
Note that burning all the known carbon fuel reserves would raise CO2 levels in the wilderness to higher levels than currently found in city center offices whose windows have been closed all week.
Also note that resource consumption has historically been exponential, so this is a larger problem going forward than you might expect looking backwards.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Waterfall on Saturday July 18, 2020 @01:42PM
(#23883126)
Have you listened to Freeman Dyson talk about this matter? I call it a problem mainly because it's dealt with as an issue. Why is a billion trees short? What is it short of?
The kind of person who likes carbon taxes would prefer their use even if carbon dioxide had no effect on the environment. It again is a control for small developing countries to be overburdened, while the developed counties can happily use their advanced energy creation while the poor remain poor and in stasis. Freeman mentions that global warming is not the same evil as poverty, hunger and disease which are greater problems.
Another posted mentioned using fancy expensive contraptions to capture carbon. We have trees that do everything naturally without the need of silicon valley or other tech companies to make advanced expensive methods to capture carbon when the natural means does everything we need.
Because of the issues with the energy grid, they've been giving away LEDs and other energy saving devices to help us use less energy. I'd say that electronics use has gone up but electricity for them hasn't since we use smartphones a lot more. Air conditioners are still the worst offender for overuse of energy.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by ben_w on Saturday July 18, 2020 @03:13PM
(#23883979)
Most of those points are irrelevant.
The main relevant question is “why is a billion trees not enough?”, to which the answer is: as a rough guide, undoing emissions from 1850-2020 would require more than the total biomass of the entire planet.
It is also important to note that, even if it was physically possible to solve this problem in this way, you can tell it isn’t economical to do so, because if it was we’d already have fully (not partially) replaced fossil fuels with biofuels.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by Waterfall on Saturday July 18, 2020 @05:41PM
(#23885089)
How are they irrelevant? The reason there are countries that developed and became first world countries is precisely because they used fossil fuels. Preventing other countries from doing the same for the sake of protecting the environment (which by the way is never in stasis) is simply condemning people to poverty, disease, basically to cripple poor nations. It seems very nationalistic under the guise of protecting the environment.
>undoing emissions from 1850-2020 would require more than the total biomass of the entire planet.
So we created more carbon than existed? Are you familiar with the fact that matter and energy is neither created nor destroyed? Carbon existed before as animals and other biomass, and you are saying now that the total biomass of the planet is not enough and we generated CO2 from thin air?
>It is also important to note that, even if it was physically possible to solve this problem in this way, you can tell it isn’t economical to do so, because if it was we’d already have fully (not partially) replaced fossil fuels with biofuels.
The dearman engine is zero emissions refrigeration truck, and runs on nitrogen. It is not being adopted into more developed countries despite being better, because of legacy vehicles. There are many reasons why biofuel hasn't taken off in the US but in many other countries it has.
So making more expensive technology for carbon capture is more economical? The problem they solved then was not fuel recycling, it was carbon capture. You can look it up (I'm on mobile) and state the issues with it. Even at the cost of $50 a tree, its 50 billion to stop worrying about carbon emissions.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019
by ben_w on Sunday July 19, 2020 @05:17AM
(#23888071)
> How are they irrelevant?
To be blunt, you come across as having as shallow a grasp of this topic as I have of general relativity. I like learning about GR, but if I ask real physicists questions about it, the responses are, at best, “what are you even talking about?”
> The reason there are countries that developed and became first world countries is precisely because they used fossil fuels.
Better, cheaper, alternatives exist now. PV + battery is cheaper than new coal plants even in northern Europe, and almost everywhere has better solar than northern Europe.
> So we created more carbon than existed? Are you familiar with the fact that matter and energy is neither created nor destroyed? Carbon existed before as animals and other biomass, and you are saying now that the total biomass of the planet is not enough and we generated CO2 from thin air?
They are called “fossil fuels” for a reason. We dug up fossilised remains which were not part of the biosphere.
> The dearman engine is zero emissions refrigeration truck, and runs on nitrogen. It is not being adopted into more developed countries despite being better, because of legacy vehicles.
It’s a heat engine, and heat engine efficiency depends on the difference between the hot side and the cold side. You maximise efficiency by running as hot as possible, not as cold as possible. Hydrogen and batteries are both better.
> So making more expensive technology for carbon capture is more economical?
You’re the one suggesting carbon capture (that’s what planting trees is); I’m saying don’t emit carbon in the first place.
> Even at the cost of $50 a tree, its 50 billion to stop worrying about carbon emissions.
Except that as I already told you, a billion trees isn’t enough. A billion trees is about three months of emissions, even assuming you prevent the trees rotting or burning at the end of their lives. If you just turn them into wood, that only delays the problem by a few centuries at best.
The other "good" news is that we lowered the increase caused by carbon and replaced it with new emissions from oil and gas that may have other side effects.
I'm a bit negative about this, even for an article that seem to have possitive news, maybe next year report will give us brigther news because there was less activity because the coronavirus.
Taking steps towards solving an issue doesn't mean anyone is claiming we solved it or doesn't recognize that we still have hundreds of miles ahead in our journey. But rather you use the past success as motivation to build momentum. You should look at the past and say "hey, we've made measurable and meaningful change. Small, but it shows that what we're doing is working. Now is the time to fight harder." Revel in that success and use it to fuel your efforts. I believe putting these things in a negative light instead paints a picture that we haven't gotten far and that our efforts aren't working. Thus disheartening people and turns them apathetic. ("There's nothing I can do")
Perspective matters.
Except it IS good news. But good news doesn't mean we solved the problem. This is a small victory, but doesn't mean it isn't a victory nonetheless. We need to break away from this binary thinking. Good news and bad news are a continuous spectrum. My issue here is that people are saying "well we're not done, therefore the news isn't good." To me this is fundamentally wrong and distinctiveness the human psychology.
> if you're accelerating toward a wall it doesn't help your situation if you switch to merely maintaining current velocity.
Except it does. The force you hit the wall with is proportional to the velocity you strike it. It is better to hit the wall at 100mph than 200mph. For a more accurate analogy consider that the peddle has been stuck to the floor this entire time and we've dislodged it. This is the first major step to slowing down (there's been tons of minor steps along the way).
For a more logical view: to be effective moving forward we have to look at the past to see what has been successful so that we can better focus our resources.
A battle is not the war. Celebrating the victory of a battle is not celebrating a victory in a war. You celebrate your victories along the way because otherwise you lose hope. I think this psychology should be very apparent considering the existential crisis and hopelessness that people have. Maybe we shouldn't be encouraging that attitude.
The thing is that if we think about climate change as a war then this is an important battle we've won. We've STOPPED the invading army. We did not push them back, we did not defeat the entire army, but for the first time we've been able to stop the invading army from gaining ground. By all accounts, before it looked hopeless. But if that kind of battle doesn't instill hope, I don't know what does. We haven't won the war, but for the first time we haven't been slaughtered in a major battle.
We need to stop believing that anything that isn't complete victory is bad news. All that does is create a hopeless future, which turns people apathetic. Just because you haven't won the war doesn't mean you shouldn't celebrate your small victories and improve moral. That is the issue, moral.
> and only during a pandemic-induced economic slowdown.
The data is 2019.
That “brighter news” would be at the expense of millions of jobs and livelihoods destroyed. In the US over 40% of black owned businesses are not expected to survive. Thousands of restaurants have been closed forever, and the toll keeps climbing.
That isn’t “brighter news” by any stretch.
Those safely ensconced in their work from home jobs might not get it, but the millions of small businesses are struggling and many are dying. Claiming “brighter news” for this is macabre.
You'll be cancelled and flagged (and so will I). COULD NOT AGREE MORE!
I also want to see what happens after in 2020 the whole world has stopped. Let's how many degrees the temperature lowers even with most factories and economical activity gone for months.
You might be thinking of Methane which does break down reasonably quickly.
https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2458/why-a-half-degree-tempera...
Looks like somewhere around 3 percent of gas is lost through the system - is this leaks or other issues the article asks: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-much-natural-...
That is only when gas has reached the supplier. Don't forget gas is also lost when drilling and also lost in huge amounts when drilling for oil. Gut feel, from the limited research I've done I would guess losses as far above the 1/28th sadly.
[0]: https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/12/us/arctic-methane-gas-flare-t...
There's still a long way to go and a lot to do, but this itself has been a hard task and is one of the important milestones. It is a small victory, but a victory nonetheless.
Here is a graph of a range of different models the IPCC used in their Special Report on 1.5C in 2018: https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2019/02/SPM3...
So if you line up the graph in the OP on the left side of your screen/minds-eye and the graph from the IPCC on the right side, you get a feel for the dramatic swing in the second derivative that is necessary going forward.
Note that these models assume we develop massive negative emissions technology in the mid and late century. That is to say, those are already assumed, so you cant use "we'll just develop negative emissions technology" as a counterpoint to the necessary amount of change in the immediate term.
If you are at all skeptical of that technological development, then take a few hundred gigatons off the budget.
(ps. check out https://collective.energy for more dialogue around climate action)
If you're looking at CO₂ emissions and want to do something about your own footprint please consider removing your own emissions.
Reductions are great and all (definitely part of the necessary solution) however they do not address the existing excess of CO₂ in the atmosphere
I started "Carbon Removed"[0] for the exact purpose to bring carbon removal to everyone and make it easy for us all to compensate the damage we have done to the environment. We support carbon removal methods so you can turn your emissions into trees and stone.
If you're more interested in removal methods I suggest researching:
Personally I have been exceptionally happy to see the transition from "carbon credits" (which, IMHO provide dubious value and are hard to quantify) to net-zero emissions - the thought leading concept of today. Steps taken by Stripe[1] and Microsoft[2] to become "net zero" or even "carbon negative" help normalise this transition.tl;dr: We can all reduce our footprints but we need to do more and remove the existing excess CO₂ in the atmosphere to get back to "normal".
0. https://carbonremoved.com
1. https://stripe.com/blog/negative-emissions-commitment
2. https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2020/01/16/microsoft-will-b...
The kind of person that is pro carbon credit would prefer it even if carbon had no effects on the weather.
We've changed the environment with buildings, cities, America used to have skies blackened by passenger pigeons so you could shoot a shotgun randomly at the sky and kill a bunch, turtles used to roam freely until the great depression caused everyone to eat them. Mao told everyone to kill the birds until their crops were devastated by insects and they had to import them back. This is not doomsday. The fossils we use for fuel used to live in a much more diverse and warm climate.
Even though you are correct that we put plants into greenhouses and it is good for them, most of the stuff we care about isn’t plants. As one example, enough CO2 will noticeably harm your intellect, and there is enough unburned carbon in the world to make us all dull-minded.
Changing the global average temperature by “1 degree” may not sound like much, but it’s enough to bleach corals and shift agriculture patterns. Even 4.5 degrees Celsius may not seem like much, but it is the difference between an ice age and a warm period, and we’re already in a warm period.
The ice age had ~200 ppm CO2, the preindustrial level was ~280, today is ~420 ppm.
>As one example, enough CO2 will noticeably harm your intellect, and there is enough unburned carbon in the world to make us all dull-minded.
Has IQ been going down due to that? Is that theoretical? Seems like improper breathing is a larger issue, and people in cities with worst local air have higher IQs than those in rural areas. Seems at best a non factor.
I’m glad we agree there is a problem. Although a mere “billion” trees is well short of the scale of the solution.
Solving CO2 with carbon offsetting is part of the general model of “carbon credits“ and “carbon trading”, which can only work with a government-and-trade-agreement-mandated minimum carbon price.
That’s fine by me. Anything is, so long as it works and works “soon-ish” rather than “eventually”.
I am optimistic about the technology, I am pessimistic about the politics.
> Has IQ been going down due to that? Is that theoretical?
It is directly measurable in situations where CO2 is higher than wilderness levels. The study I’ve seen had three specific tested CO2 concentrations, which were roughly comparable to various modern-life scenarios such as city center offices or wearing full-face motorcycle helmets.
> Seems like improper breathing is a larger issue, and people in cities with worst local air have higher IQs than those in rural areas. Seems at best a non factor.
The CO2 level inside cities are indeed higher. As are the CO2 level inside sealed offices inside a city. These higher levels have a demonstrable, repeatably testable, negative impact on reasoning skills.
I have seen no prior claim of correlation between location and IQ, however I have seen a claim that city dwellers walk faster which turned out to be because cities attract young, skilled, ambitious people. Therefore, you would need to show causation not just correlation — especially as there are repeated demonstrations that CO2 impairs cognitive function, and that’s hardly the only pollutant one should expect to be more common in a city.
Note that burning all the known carbon fuel reserves would raise CO2 levels in the wilderness to higher levels than currently found in city center offices whose windows have been closed all week.
Also note that resource consumption has historically been exponential, so this is a larger problem going forward than you might expect looking backwards.
The main relevant question is “why is a billion trees not enough?”, to which the answer is: as a rough guide, undoing emissions from 1850-2020 would require more than the total biomass of the entire planet.
It is also important to note that, even if it was physically possible to solve this problem in this way, you can tell it isn’t economical to do so, because if it was we’d already have fully (not partially) replaced fossil fuels with biofuels.
>undoing emissions from 1850-2020 would require more than the total biomass of the entire planet.
So we created more carbon than existed? Are you familiar with the fact that matter and energy is neither created nor destroyed? Carbon existed before as animals and other biomass, and you are saying now that the total biomass of the planet is not enough and we generated CO2 from thin air?
>It is also important to note that, even if it was physically possible to solve this problem in this way, you can tell it isn’t economical to do so, because if it was we’d already have fully (not partially) replaced fossil fuels with biofuels.
The dearman engine is zero emissions refrigeration truck, and runs on nitrogen. It is not being adopted into more developed countries despite being better, because of legacy vehicles. There are many reasons why biofuel hasn't taken off in the US but in many other countries it has.
So making more expensive technology for carbon capture is more economical? The problem they solved then was not fuel recycling, it was carbon capture. You can look it up (I'm on mobile) and state the issues with it. Even at the cost of $50 a tree, its 50 billion to stop worrying about carbon emissions.
To be blunt, you come across as having as shallow a grasp of this topic as I have of general relativity. I like learning about GR, but if I ask real physicists questions about it, the responses are, at best, “what are you even talking about?”
> The reason there are countries that developed and became first world countries is precisely because they used fossil fuels.
Better, cheaper, alternatives exist now. PV + battery is cheaper than new coal plants even in northern Europe, and almost everywhere has better solar than northern Europe.
> So we created more carbon than existed? Are you familiar with the fact that matter and energy is neither created nor destroyed? Carbon existed before as animals and other biomass, and you are saying now that the total biomass of the planet is not enough and we generated CO2 from thin air?
They are called “fossil fuels” for a reason. We dug up fossilised remains which were not part of the biosphere.
> The dearman engine is zero emissions refrigeration truck, and runs on nitrogen. It is not being adopted into more developed countries despite being better, because of legacy vehicles.
It’s a heat engine, and heat engine efficiency depends on the difference between the hot side and the cold side. You maximise efficiency by running as hot as possible, not as cold as possible. Hydrogen and batteries are both better.
> So making more expensive technology for carbon capture is more economical?
You’re the one suggesting carbon capture (that’s what planting trees is); I’m saying don’t emit carbon in the first place.
> Even at the cost of $50 a tree, its 50 billion to stop worrying about carbon emissions.
Except that as I already told you, a billion trees isn’t enough. A billion trees is about three months of emissions, even assuming you prevent the trees rotting or burning at the end of their lives. If you just turn them into wood, that only delays the problem by a few centuries at best.