News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:23PM (#23873740)
I'm not in favor of this attitude. If the wound is widening exponentially and you stop it from widening that's a big step in solving the issue. Basically you can move from containment to treatment.

Taking steps towards solving an issue doesn't mean anyone is claiming we solved it or doesn't recognize that we still have hundreds of miles ahead in our journey. But rather you use the past success as motivation to build momentum. You should look at the past and say "hey, we've made measurable and meaningful change. Small, but it shows that what we're doing is working. Now is the time to fight harder." Revel in that success and use it to fuel your efforts. I believe putting these things in a negative light instead paints a picture that we haven't gotten far and that our efforts aren't working. Thus disheartening people and turns them apathetic. ("There's nothing I can do")

Perspective matters.

Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by dmos62 on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:13PM (#23874284)
Both of your perspectives are essential. We can't feel relieved, because there's a monumental amount of work left, and we should not discount what progress has been made, because that will discourage further progress.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @07:35PM (#23877308)
But I wasn't trying to convey relief nor completion.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by dmos62 on Saturday July 18, 2020 @03:23AM (#23879702)
When I said your perspectives, I meant your perspective and the commentor your responded to perspective.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by tunesmith on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:29PM (#23874467)
I think the GP is an important point though, because for those not following it closely, that graph can look like good news when it isn't. It's like the difference between speed and acceleration - if you're accelerating toward a wall it doesn't help your situation if you switch to merely maintaining current velocity.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @07:44PM (#23877388)
> that graph can look like good news when it isn't.

Except it IS good news. But good news doesn't mean we solved the problem. This is a small victory, but doesn't mean it isn't a victory nonetheless. We need to break away from this binary thinking. Good news and bad news are a continuous spectrum. My issue here is that people are saying "well we're not done, therefore the news isn't good." To me this is fundamentally wrong and distinctiveness the human psychology.

> if you're accelerating toward a wall it doesn't help your situation if you switch to merely maintaining current velocity.

Except it does. The force you hit the wall with is proportional to the velocity you strike it. It is better to hit the wall at 100mph than 200mph. For a more accurate analogy consider that the peddle has been stuck to the floor this entire time and we've dislodged it. This is the first major step to slowing down (there's been tons of minor steps along the way).

For a more logical view: to be effective moving forward we have to look at the past to see what has been successful so that we can better focus our resources.

A battle is not the war. Celebrating the victory of a battle is not celebrating a victory in a war. You celebrate your victories along the way because otherwise you lose hope. I think this psychology should be very apparent considering the existential crisis and hopelessness that people have. Maybe we shouldn't be encouraging that attitude.

Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by tunesmith on Sunday July 19, 2020 @12:15AM (#23886956)
Here's an example - R0 dipped below 1 for several states, and they collectively said "Good news!" and immediately started opening back up again.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by godelski on Sunday July 19, 2020 @06:31PM (#23892996)
I feel like you have missed my entire point. The example is not related.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by kiliantics on Friday July 17, 2020 @05:54PM (#23876366)
A lot of people in the west believe that we will somehow "figure it out" and that their way of life will never have to change for a solution (or be forced to change by the consequences from the lack of a solution). I think news like this is often viewed as some kind of reassurance to people of this belief. Perspective matters, which is why these kinds of results need to be given in their proper context -- i.e. extreme alarm that we are still only stopping an increase now, decades after first understanding that this was a problem yet continuing to increase our carbon output, and only during a pandemic-induced economic slowdown.
Re:Global CO2 Emissions in 2019 by godelski on Friday July 17, 2020 @07:57PM (#23877479)
I agree with what you are saying, but this is a technical document. So the perspective of "good news" or "still bad news" is in our interpretation. We are providing said context. While I'm being optimistic here it is because I'm responding to a comment which I view as too pessimistic and encouraging hopelessness. I would (and do) go after a similar comment if it was trying to claim victory over the crisis.

The thing is that if we think about climate change as a war then this is an important battle we've won. We've STOPPED the invading army. We did not push them back, we did not defeat the entire army, but for the first time we've been able to stop the invading army from gaining ground. By all accounts, before it looked hopeless. But if that kind of battle doesn't instill hope, I don't know what does. We haven't won the war, but for the first time we haven't been slaughtered in a major battle.

We need to stop believing that anything that isn't complete victory is bad news. All that does is create a hopeless future, which turns people apathetic. Just because you haven't won the war doesn't mean you shouldn't celebrate your small victories and improve moral. That is the issue, moral.

> and only during a pandemic-induced economic slowdown.

The data is 2019.