Even though you are correct that we put plants into greenhouses and it is good for them, most of the stuff we care about isn’t plants. As one example, enough CO2 will noticeably harm your intellect, and there is enough unburned carbon in the world to make us all dull-minded.
Changing the global average temperature by “1 degree” may not sound like much, but it’s enough to bleach corals and shift agriculture patterns. Even 4.5 degrees Celsius may not seem like much, but it is the difference between an ice age and a warm period, and we’re already in a warm period.
The ice age had ~200 ppm CO2, the preindustrial level was ~280, today is ~420 ppm.
>As one example, enough CO2 will noticeably harm your intellect, and there is enough unburned carbon in the world to make us all dull-minded.
Has IQ been going down due to that? Is that theoretical? Seems like improper breathing is a larger issue, and people in cities with worst local air have higher IQs than those in rural areas. Seems at best a non factor.
I’m glad we agree there is a problem. Although a mere “billion” trees is well short of the scale of the solution.
Solving CO2 with carbon offsetting is part of the general model of “carbon credits“ and “carbon trading”, which can only work with a government-and-trade-agreement-mandated minimum carbon price.
That’s fine by me. Anything is, so long as it works and works “soon-ish” rather than “eventually”.
I am optimistic about the technology, I am pessimistic about the politics.
> Has IQ been going down due to that? Is that theoretical?
It is directly measurable in situations where CO2 is higher than wilderness levels. The study I’ve seen had three specific tested CO2 concentrations, which were roughly comparable to various modern-life scenarios such as city center offices or wearing full-face motorcycle helmets.
> Seems like improper breathing is a larger issue, and people in cities with worst local air have higher IQs than those in rural areas. Seems at best a non factor.
The CO2 level inside cities are indeed higher. As are the CO2 level inside sealed offices inside a city. These higher levels have a demonstrable, repeatably testable, negative impact on reasoning skills.
I have seen no prior claim of correlation between location and IQ, however I have seen a claim that city dwellers walk faster which turned out to be because cities attract young, skilled, ambitious people. Therefore, you would need to show causation not just correlation — especially as there are repeated demonstrations that CO2 impairs cognitive function, and that’s hardly the only pollutant one should expect to be more common in a city.
Note that burning all the known carbon fuel reserves would raise CO2 levels in the wilderness to higher levels than currently found in city center offices whose windows have been closed all week.
Also note that resource consumption has historically been exponential, so this is a larger problem going forward than you might expect looking backwards.
The main relevant question is “why is a billion trees not enough?”, to which the answer is: as a rough guide, undoing emissions from 1850-2020 would require more than the total biomass of the entire planet.
It is also important to note that, even if it was physically possible to solve this problem in this way, you can tell it isn’t economical to do so, because if it was we’d already have fully (not partially) replaced fossil fuels with biofuels.
>undoing emissions from 1850-2020 would require more than the total biomass of the entire planet.
So we created more carbon than existed? Are you familiar with the fact that matter and energy is neither created nor destroyed? Carbon existed before as animals and other biomass, and you are saying now that the total biomass of the planet is not enough and we generated CO2 from thin air?
>It is also important to note that, even if it was physically possible to solve this problem in this way, you can tell it isn’t economical to do so, because if it was we’d already have fully (not partially) replaced fossil fuels with biofuels.
The dearman engine is zero emissions refrigeration truck, and runs on nitrogen. It is not being adopted into more developed countries despite being better, because of legacy vehicles. There are many reasons why biofuel hasn't taken off in the US but in many other countries it has.
So making more expensive technology for carbon capture is more economical? The problem they solved then was not fuel recycling, it was carbon capture. You can look it up (I'm on mobile) and state the issues with it. Even at the cost of $50 a tree, its 50 billion to stop worrying about carbon emissions.
To be blunt, you come across as having as shallow a grasp of this topic as I have of general relativity. I like learning about GR, but if I ask real physicists questions about it, the responses are, at best, “what are you even talking about?”
> The reason there are countries that developed and became first world countries is precisely because they used fossil fuels.
Better, cheaper, alternatives exist now. PV + battery is cheaper than new coal plants even in northern Europe, and almost everywhere has better solar than northern Europe.
> So we created more carbon than existed? Are you familiar with the fact that matter and energy is neither created nor destroyed? Carbon existed before as animals and other biomass, and you are saying now that the total biomass of the planet is not enough and we generated CO2 from thin air?
They are called “fossil fuels” for a reason. We dug up fossilised remains which were not part of the biosphere.
> The dearman engine is zero emissions refrigeration truck, and runs on nitrogen. It is not being adopted into more developed countries despite being better, because of legacy vehicles.
It’s a heat engine, and heat engine efficiency depends on the difference between the hot side and the cold side. You maximise efficiency by running as hot as possible, not as cold as possible. Hydrogen and batteries are both better.
> So making more expensive technology for carbon capture is more economical?
You’re the one suggesting carbon capture (that’s what planting trees is); I’m saying don’t emit carbon in the first place.
> Even at the cost of $50 a tree, its 50 billion to stop worrying about carbon emissions.
Except that as I already told you, a billion trees isn’t enough. A billion trees is about three months of emissions, even assuming you prevent the trees rotting or burning at the end of their lives. If you just turn them into wood, that only delays the problem by a few centuries at best.
We've changed the environment with buildings, cities, America used to have skies blackened by passenger pigeons so you could shoot a shotgun randomly at the sky and kill a bunch, turtles used to roam freely until the great depression caused everyone to eat them. Mao told everyone to kill the birds until their crops were devastated by insects and they had to import them back. This is not doomsday. The fossils we use for fuel used to live in a much more diverse and warm climate.