I'm not sure the video that you've linked is any better. It's basically someone dismissing it saying they were bad people who deserved it. It adds zero information.
https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1283452585945583618
https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/06/17/police-targeting-street-...
If you are protesting the police, you should have every possible form of armour on that you have access to, even if you are protesting peacefully.
> the dude who got arrested has a helmet on. Why's that needed in peaceful protests?
Same reason why people wear helmets when riding a bike: even if they're not intending on smashing their head, accidents happen, so it's better to be protected. Protests do occasionally turn violent, so that's not too unreasonable. Also keep in mind there are protesters that open carry assault rifles, so in comparison a helmet us relatively tame.
>That's an attachment to break car windows:
It looks like a black stick to me? What's it supposed to be?
I couldn't identify what he had on his left side from that video. How did you come to the conclusion it was meant to break windows?
https://www.dhs.gov/news/2020/07/16/acting-secretary-wolf-co...
Media's claim that they are "unidentified" is simply false.
Since you seem to be here to reflexively argue, the only thing I have left to say is that you need to realize that the federal government deploying soldiers into American cities against the express wishes of the local governments is utterly anti-Freedom, anti-American, and straight up totalitarian. We're witnessing the destruction of our country, and you're cheerleading to the tune of Party propaganda. It's never too late to snap out of that filter bubble and come to your senses.
https://www.kut.org/post/chief-manley-says-black-man-critica...
This is a literally subversive movement. I'm not exaggerating or choosing a side. Watch the livestreams yourself - these people explicitly seek to subvert, dismantle, and replace modern "power structures" (intentionally left vague).
Whether you agree with what these people think they're fighting for, the system has safeguards against such insurrection.
The dude in the video was never told where he was or why he was arrested. He didn't know he was in the federal courthouse until after he was released.
These guys don't even have badges ffs. If someone shot these guys, I don't see how that wouldn't be considered self-defense.
Let's see what DHS is complaining about:
https://www.dhs.gov/news/2020/07/16/acting-secretary-wolf-co...
A lot of broken windows, graffiti and fireworks. Real insurrection. Raise the army. Prepare the nukes.
Those are federal property and feds have full rights to do this. Also a lot of people who are being arrested are from another state. That's been the case for at least 45 days now. There's a point where the feds have to step in since the local people in that area are being terrorized. I have friends in that area and they are all planing to move out of the city because the Mayor, DA and Governor have been useless for a long time.
So tyranny of the majority is fine? I'm sure you can apply the same justification to what's happening in Xinjiang. Also, where's this "authorization" stemming from? Did we explicitly authorize it? Or was it implied by our inaction?
Perhaps it is preferable to tyranny by the minority.
>authorization" stemming from? Did we explicitly authorize it? Or was it implied by our inaction?
Did you authorize the taxes you pay, or where they go? Isn't this the so called social contract?
And please, my family fled true tyranny, I assure you nothing the US is doing is quite comperable to the CCP. Westerners don't know tyranny. They've grown so comfortable that they can take to the streets for weeks and complain about the very government that supports them.
Try doing that in the USSR or any Chines state outside of Hong Kong or Taiwan.
You've posted repeated complaints holding that HN is moderated for ideological reasons, and that users flag posts for ideological reasons, but when you pour fuel on flames like this, you're creating the very situation you're complaining about. Any discussion that degenerates to this level will correctly get flagged, because it is not what HN is for, and it destroys what HN is for.
The truth is that both sides of ideologues are creating this problem—the other side, yes, and your side, including you yourself. All of you need to accept that (1) this community is large enough that plenty of opposing views are inevitably represented here, and (2) everyone's first responsibility is to protect the container for future discussion. When you bash each other, you're destroying the container. This needs to change, regardless of how important the issues are and how strong your passions are.
Our job is prevent this place from burning itself to the ground, and your account is unfortunately standing out as one of the burners. Even apart from the other site guidelines that you routinely break, you are plainly using HN primarily for ideological battle, which is something we ban accounts for, regardless of which ideology they're battling for. Doing that is the only way to preserve any semblance of intellectual curiosity on this site—that is, any semblance of HN's mandate.
I've held off chastising you for this way longer than we do for most accounts, but it's obviously time for that to change. No, this is not because we secretly side with the worst of your enemies, alt-right trolls or whoever else—I've banned more of those than you can imagine. At the same time, you also need to follow the rules.
Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23884888.
It doesn't matter who they're arresting and for what reason. They should announce who they are, using marked vehicles and properly arrest them if they have actually committed a crime.
Because otherwise, what's stopping someone from dressing up in military garb and straight up abducting someone? How do you know they're even part of the federal law enforcement and not actually someone taking advantage of the situation to commit crimes as well?
Demonstrators like O’Shea and Pettibone said they think they were targeted by federal officers for simply wearing black clothing in the area of the demonstration.“
That's misleading. They are being recorded while they are being violent within the peaceful protests. They are being arrested when they leave because Feds don't want to disrupt the peaceful protests - so they arrest them when they leave the area. I have watched a few videos of this happening and all of them have the person in not just all black but also with a helmet, tools to break windows and baseball bats.
Here's one example where the dude who got arrested has a helmet on. Why's that needed in peaceful protests? Also note the thing he has on his left side. That's an attachment to break car windows:
https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1283452585945583618
But I’d like a sincere response: What difference does it make what they did if they were apprehended by unidentifiable officers? That’s the topic at hand - the fact that police are apprehending people in ways that are not identifiably different from kidnappings.
That's not what I meant when I said:
rioters (not the protestors)
I meant to say that a few violent people are sneaking into the protestors. By "not the protestors", I meant "I am not referring to the protestors".
By local government, I meant the mayor, the governor and the DA. Portland, Chicago has been this way for a long time.
I’m what ways do you believe any of this justifies kidnapping people?
The officers have POLICE on their chest in big letters. People getting arrested have helmets, bats and window breaking tools on. They aren't "protestors". They are preventing peaceful protestors.
Also there's some claims of some of them being undercover agents who have infiltrated Antifa though I am not sure if that can be confirmed.
But two responses later and you’ve still ignored the question: what difference does it make what they’ve done - why defend unmarked police? I’ve taken the time to show evidence that it’s occurred, it’d be nice if you reciprocated some effort.
[0]https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.sandiegouniontribune.com/ne...
https://www.dhs.gov/news/2020/07/16/acting-secretary-wolf-co...
Media's claim that they are "unidentified" is simply false.
Does that make me identifiably a law enforcement officer?
https://www.dhs.gov/news/2020/07/16/acting-secretary-wolf-co...
Media's claim that they are "unidentified" is simply false.
Start at 9:30 timestamp:
https://youtu.be/3ptD6koTknw?t=570
People sharing videos of this share either selectively edited videos without context OR they only share the ending part where they are arrested and not the part where they were instigating violence in the peaceful protests.
https://youtu.be/ha-7SETmJD4
Also they are not unidentified. They have Police on their chest.
There's also a theory (can't confirm this) that these are undercover operatives being extracted as they have been infiltrated Antifa.