Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by undersuit on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @08:40PM
(#23854366)
The noun structure should not be clickbaity. I assume you mean because structure without the adverb cosmic would imply some sort of extraterrestrial-built structure?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by airstrike on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @08:56PM
(#23854479)
Scientists -> ok, but would prefer to omit that
Discovered -> "Observe" is better
Gigantic Structure -> "Cosmic structure" is better than the subjective "gigantic", as everything cosmic is by definition gigantic and it seems to imply some sort of amazement at its size
in a
Hidden Zone of Space -> "Obscured" zone of space would again be better
So how about "First Observation of Cosmic Structure in Obscured Zone of Space"
I'm not an editor, and if I can come up with a more accurate and less sensationalized title, one can only conclude that whichever editor was behind this specific headline was deliberate in their choice of its clickbaity feel
Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by macintux on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @09:19PM
(#23854649)
Not sure “observed” is accurate, since we can’t see it from here. Discovered seems better.
And it is one of the largest we’ve seen, and it’s very close, so there is some amazement.
Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @08:50PM
(#23854431)
that implication is, I believe, the commonly understood one.
Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by dvtrn on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @08:53PM
(#23854454)
What, "aliens" or otherwise "artificial"? Is that the 'commonly understood' implication you mean? It's okay to say it. My question is, is it “commonly understood” or is it merely a convenient and very fun implication to assume?
Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @09:01PM
(#23854511)
I suppose artificial is the commonly understood implication when one uses the term structure, but if it is found in a hidden zone of space it also somewhat implies aliens.
Re:Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zo...
by happytoexplain on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @08:56PM
(#23854472)
"Should" not, yes - though it is here, it seems to me.