There are proposals for updated international taxation rules to prevent this issue - for example this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formulary_apportionment The problem is to get the OECD to agree on updating this.
Wouldn't it be simpler just to tax those things? We already collect those taxes, and can set any rates we wish. Why not just abolish the the tax on corporate profits?
And ultimately that is what happened: the money Apple made outside the US was eventually taxed when they repatriated it into the US.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/apple-to-pay-38-billion-in-repa...
Normally you tax profits, which are gross revenue minus cost of goods sold (and yeah, I'm oversimplifying a bit). But in Europe, Apple has only profits, no cost of goods sold at all, since the costs are incurred in the USA. This would seem to lead to super-high taxes everywhere else, where profits are close to 100%, but huge losses in the USA, where the costs for the whole world aren't met by enough gross revenue to cover them.
To avoid that, the European entity takes on a share of the costs by "buying" from the USA entity. And that's where the games come in. What are they buying? The physical goods? Are what markup? Are they also buying the advantages that come from the Apple name and logo?
They can basically set the cost of that IP to whatever they want, and therefore show as much or as little net profit as they choose. Which is what they've been doing. Again, oversimplifying a bit, they recorded all European revenue through Ireland, and set the cost of product + IP + ad share + everything else so high that the net profit was very, very, very low, and sad that very, very, very low number is what they had to pay taxes on.
Scenario A: Apple (USA) pays $200 for an assembled iPhone from their Chinese manufacturer. Then they turn around and sell the phone to Apple (Europe) for $1000. Apple (Europe) then sells the phone to a customer for $1000. Apple (USA) records a profit of $800, Apple (Europe) records a profit of $0.
Scenarion B: Apple (USA) pays $200 for an assembled iPhone from their Chinese manufacturer. Then they turn around and sell the phone to Apple (Europe) for $200. Apple (Europe) then sells the phone to a customer for $1000. Apple (USA) records a profit of $0, Apple (Europe) records a profit of $800.
In scenario A the money is "made" in the USA. In scenario B the money is "made" in Europe. Apple argues that since they are paying taxes on that money in the USA, they shouldn't have to double-pay taxes to Europe as well. Europe disagrees because they want a slice of those taxes.
(Note that no complex IP transfer schemes are involved here, it's solely a question of which entity records the difference in the retail price of the phone vs the cost of goods sold. Also note that in either case, sales tax/VAT is paid to the appropriate country.)
- then the remaining profits are taxed again by the US government when Apple repatriates them to the US.
- Then the remainder are taxed again by the state Apple reports them in.
- Then they are taxed again by the federal government when Apple shareholders receive the remainder as dividends.
- Then they are taxed once more by the Shareholders state, finally allowing the shareholder to spend (or reinvest) what remains.
--
What is the source of the revenue of an item sold in country A, manufactured in country B, and designed in company C?
What if it was shipped into country A, but the shipper has no nexus in that country? What if it was manufactured in country B, but the designer has no nexus in that country?
Add in parts made in one country, and assembled in another for more fun.
The new US corporate tax plan has an interesting approach of AMT on corporations of X% of global income or Y% on US income, whichever is more, with AMT credits for foreign taxes paid; and the income doesn't need to be repatriated to be taxed. (IIRC, X is 10, Y is 20). Of course, that only is effective if the company is US homed, if it only has a US subsidiary, that can't be used to levy a worldwide tax.
We have come to accept that certain tax payers (ie. corporate or well lawyered individuals) can chose where their revenue should be taxed. It think it has become obvious that this freedom distorts the spirit of taxation in most (all?) countries. I think it is fair to prevent double taxation across countries but IMHO revenue should be taxed as close to the source (revenue-generating-event) as possible.
> "We're proud to be the largest taxpayer in the world, as we know the important role tax payments play in society."
The old PR line Apple (and others) have been repeating ad nauseum... No one questions your place in the ranking, people care about the proportion (rate) you end up paying. If you're among the largest companies in the world by revenue it's not surprising that you'd be among the largest tax payers.