News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by aardvark179 on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:02AM (#23811879)
Yeah. I was going to type more about the Shannon-Nyquist limit, but was on my phone, and I've heard several people over the years assert that the 44100 sample rate was a very early form of DRM since "anybody sensible" would have picked 48000, and indeed did for various other formats where this restriction didn't apply.
Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by chiph on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:40PM (#23813133)
I bought a Sony CDP-101 in 1984 (their first commercial CD player). Unlike hifi components today that are mostly air and a small embedded processor, it was densely packed with circuitry and weighed a surprising amount (10kg? maybe more?). For cost and packaging reasons, Sony only put a single DA converter in it. This meant that they had to alternate converting the left + right channels, which introduced a 11µs delay between them. Not ideal, but it was what was what they were able to do given the technology of the time. Much like Technics was with the SV-P100.

Anyone saying the 44.1 kHz sampling rate was because of DRM [0] and that they should have used a more sensible rate like 48 kHz is just mistaken. DAT was the first commercial product to have 48 kHz sampling, and that wasn't available until 1987.

[0] The Red Book CD Digital Audio specification obviously existed and was available, otherwise other equipment makers couldn't create compatible players.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by slashink on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:14AM (#23811971)
Yeah also you are technically right. The specific reason we ended up at 44100 is a VHS constraint but the 44* ballpark was what I wanted to clarify. Nevertheless always fun to see this pop up on HN, there is so much forgotten reasoning about standards that we’ve carried over into the modern world.
Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by segfaultbuserr on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:48PM (#23813184)
> the 44100 sample rate was a very early form of DRM

Can you elaborate? How could it be a form of DRM? Did you mean that 44100 Hz was incompatible with existing designs using 48000 Hz, or that 44100 Hz created technical challenge for replication due to its smaller frequency margin?

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by garganzol on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:08PM (#23813868)
44.1 kHz sample rate limits the audio frequency response to 22 kHz. The popular knowledge says that the human hearing "stops" at 20 kHz, but in reality this is not a flush cut off. It may go way beyond that: some people are able to hear up to 27 kHz, depending on age and personal physiology.

Limiting frequency response at 22 kHz ensures that you get a high quality material, but not the highest quality.

Record labels still have the leverage to extract some pennies in the future by selling a higher quality record and this makes them feel comfortable.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by klodolph on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:27PM (#23814045)
I don’t find this argument particularly compelling. You can hear up to 27kHz if the sound is loud enough, under laboratory conditions. However, from a psychoacoustic standpoint, you are unlikely to be able to hear those frequencies under normal listening conditions, and typical program material doesn’t make use of those frequencies anyway.

In other words, 20 kHz is good enough.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by garganzol on Sunday July 12, 2020 @04:03PM (#23814306)
There is a bit of difference between 48 and 44.1 tracks, and it is a bit deeper than expected.

44.1 tracks tend to be "normalized" at the highest portion of the spectrum trying to squeeze the juice right at the studio.

Tracks mastered for 48+ kHz are usually more relaxed in this regard, they just let the sound flow.

Both sound exceptionally well, but tracks with higher sample rate sound a bit more natural, a bit softer if you prefer. Higher sample rate tends to add a pleasant edge to some kinds of music: live performances, jazz, minimal techno.

If you happen to live in a part of the world where crickets are active in the summer then take a closer look. Their audio spectrum goes way beyond 20 kHz and if you try to listen carefully then you may spot the point where it goes beyond 20 kHz limit.

Not everybody is physically capable to experience this. Personally I can hear a bit of those frequencies, so it's amusing to realize that a little bug can be such a masterful audio source. Nature is beautiful. And this beauty is a selling point when it comes to music.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by klodolph on Sunday July 12, 2020 @07:21PM (#23815572)
> 44.1 tracks tend to be "normalized" at the highest portion of the spectrum trying to squeeze the juice right at the studio.

Could you explain this to me? What does it mean to “normalize something at the highest portion of the spectrum”?

Assume I have a fairly solid background in signal processing theory and understand the fundamentals of music production / mixing / mastering.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by grawprog on Sunday July 12, 2020 @09:02PM (#23816119)
Not the original commenter, but my guess is, because the cutoff is 22khz, higher frequencies are normalized down around 20-22khz, blending them with those higher frequencies and distorting and changing them slightly.

Whereas being mastered for 27khz would allow some of those higher frequencies to remain as is and sound closer to the natural sound you'd hear.

I may be wrong but as far as I know, this is because those higher frequencies are still picked up and interpreted by us whether we actually hear them or not.

Personally, i've never really noticed the difference between 44.1kHz and 48kHz, but I do notice the difference between listening to audio on headphones with different cutoffs.

20-20000hz headphones sound noticably less good than 18-22000hz or even 24000hz. It makes even more of a difference than price point usually does. To the point where it's the only thing i really look for when looking for headphones for music.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by klodolph on Monday July 13, 2020 @12:17AM (#23817118)
> … because the cutoff is 22khz…

That’s the Nyquist frequency. The cutoff is wherever you like, but typically at 20kHz.

> …higher frequencies are normalized down around 20-22khz, blending them with those higher frequencies and distorting and changing them slightly.

Can you explain what you mean by “normalized down”? It sounds like you are describing some kind of processing done to music, something I have never heard of before, something different from aliasing.

I want to assume that you’re commenting in good faith, but are you just rewording the original comment? I don’t think the original comment makes sense, and rewording it isn’t going to change anything.

> I may be wrong but as far as I know, this is because those higher frequencies are still picked up and interpreted by us whether we actually hear them or not.

This is wrong, or at least wishful thinking—under ordinary listening conditions with typical program material, you simply can’t tell the difference between music which has those frequencies and music which doesn’t. That what experiments are testing when they test if you can “hear” something.

> Personally, i've never really noticed the difference between 44.1kHz and 48kHz, but I do notice the difference between listening to audio on headphones with different cutoffs.

Different headphones sound different, this is a known fact. There are simply too many differences between different headphones to draw conclusions here.

When I’m making music, I try to listen to it on several headphones before I release it. Each set of headphones I have imparts a unique sound on the music. Same thing applies to loudspeakers.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by ferongr on Sunday July 12, 2020 @06:21PM (#23815247)
Post your ABX logs.
Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by rasz on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:22AM (#23818812)
Makes perfect sense .. for a Bat.
Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by klodolph on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:39PM (#23814148)
Here’s my understanding.

Let’s say you want to resample from 32kHz to 48kHz with a filter that has N taps. The sample rate ratio is 3:4, so you need 4N coefficients total. Basically, what you have is four N-tap filters, where filter K has a delay of K/4 samples. With higher values for N, you get lower ripple and lower aliasing.

Resampling 44.1kHz to 48kHz, the ratio is 147:160 so you need 160N coefficients. This wasn’t a problem for very long, but it was inconvenient in the 1980s.

Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by segfaultbuserr on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:24PM (#23824580)
Why did you need to resample it? Because 48 kHz was already the most common industry standard before CD, is it correct?
Re:Digital Audio on VHS – The Technics SV-P100 [video] by klodolph on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:36PM (#23828245)
That's the way the story goes. I can't really find supporting evidence, though. When I try looking at early digital media, it seems that it was fairly common for hardware to support both 44.1kHz and 48kHz, at the very least. Stuff like DASH, ProDigi, and DAT.

I think it's more likely that 44100 was chosen for other reasons--either because it a multiple of the number of active NTSC or PAL lines per second, or because it has a convenient factorization (14x14x15x15), or both.

44.1kHz is a great sample rate for distribution. 48kHz is a little more convenient for creating sounds because it often uses less CPU power to process 48kHz signals (because the transition band is twice as large).