News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by tzs on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:07AM (#23802311)
> Surely, if it can filter heavy isotopes, coronavirus won’t fit through.

Surprisingly, that reasoning doesn't necessarily actually work.

It turns out that there are actually several different mechanisms by which a filter can stop particles.

Big particles, for example, might not fit between the gaps in the filter--think fish in a net. This is called sieving.

Particles that are too small for sieving but are heavier than the surrounding flow keep moving in a straight line when the flow goes around the filter fibers. They collide with the fibers and get stuck. This is called inertial impaction.

The smallest particles that the filter can handle are not held in place by the fluid they are flowing in and so move around a lot by diffusion. This diffusion can lead them to hitting the fibers and getting stuck.

Particles too big for diffusion but too small for inertial impaction can follow the flow around fibers, but in doing so they can still hit the fiber and get stuck. This is called interception.

There are also electrostatic effects with some filter materials that can ensnare some kinds of particles.

When you put this all together, the result is that filters do not work the way we would intuitively expect, where there is some particular size and everything above that is stopped and everything below that makes it through. That would only be true if sieving was the only mechanism in play.

The curves of efficiency vs. particle size for all of the non-electrostatic mechanisms are S curves. As size goes up, sieving, inertial impact, and interception all go up, but at different rates.

Sieving's curve rising section is almost vertical. Inertial impact's is fairly rapid but nowhere near as rapid as sieving's. Interception's is much more relaxed.

Diffusion is also an S curve, but it goes the other way, being high for small particles and dropping for large particles.

When you add them all up you end up with a curve that is high and flat for small particles, then dips down around some particular size, and then rises back up to high efficiency.

There's some nice illustrations and graphs here [1].

This is why 0.3 microns is used when rating HEPA filters. It's around the size that is hardest for them to handle.

[1] http://donaldsonaerospace-defense.com/library/files/document...

Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by sizzle on Saturday July 11, 2020 @07:58PM (#23807313)
What amount of trapped particles can be released with air current dislodging them as it flows through? If you have a really dirty filter, will the trapped particles dislodge or will it create a sort of barrier and increase filtering efficiency? Thanks for the awesome write up.

Also, I recall reading that hepa filters are the most effective at eliminating airborne particulate the higher the amount of time it has to cycle the same air in a room.

Final thoughts, is using the ozone feature effective in trapping coronavirus and what about an integrated UV light that it directed on the HEPA filter, will this eradicate trapped viruses?

Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by etrautmann on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:05PM (#23803635)
I appreciate learning things that update my physical intuition for how things work. Thanks for sharing this.
Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by cmroanirgo on Saturday July 11, 2020 @05:49PM (#23806381)
Awesome write up.

Isn't this similar to how N95 masks are rated, as well? That is, the mask will stop 95% of the particles at its worst size (if my understanding is correct). HEPA is a much better filter than N95.

Also, it's my understanding that CV itself can't exist in the atmosphere itself, but must be contained in a droplet. (Again, I'm hoping this is correct). If this is true, then it's not about the size of CV, but the range of sizes of water droplets.

Perhaps also the drying effect on droplets caught in a filter, which cause the CV 'death' is true?

Doesn't this mean that the whole argument now degrades to probabilities of a CV droplet getting through and causing a sickness?

1. How many CV exist in a droplet?

2. How many droplets must one encounter to have a good chance of being exposed?

3. How many CV does it take for a person to get sick? (Presuming the immune system will be a factor in eradicating some particles?)

There are other factors of course, the main one would be is how quickly the air in a room is scrubbed by the filter itself. If the air flow is too low, the filter would be as good as useless, because it's not trapping anything.

Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by m-ee on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:06PM (#23805435)
For anyone interested in a deep dive into the weird space of aerosol science this is the Bible for the scientists I work with

https://www.amazon.com/Aerosol-Technology-Properties-Measure...

Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by airstrike on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:32AM (#23802474)
Very insightful, thanks for sharing. You win HN today
Re:Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus by ykevinator on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:46AM (#23802560)
Applause