News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by asdfadsfgfdda on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:24AM (#23776924)
Natural gas is not slightly better, it's significantly better than coal for climate. Emissions are about half as much as coal per kWh. Switching from coal to natural gas has probably reduced America's CO2 footprint more than all new renewable generation combined. In the short term and without cheap storage, renewables just cannot scale compared to natural gas.
Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by bradbot on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:43AM (#23777009)
Does this take into account the amount of methane released from burn off and leaks?
Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by acidburnNSA on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:38AM (#23777237)
No. When you consider those it's about as bad as coal. Even at half coal, 490 gCO2-eq/kWh is tremendously incompatible with a climate solution. All the gas companies are trying to greenwash and say they're the perfect partner for renewables but they're terrible high-carbon fossil emitting beasts.

Still way better than coal on the deaths-from-air-pollution metric.

But not a reasonable or good option. We need to stop celebrating the transition from coal to fracked gas and get on with actual low carbon energy like solar, hydro, nuclear, wind.

Nuclear being the best of those :)

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by sunstone on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:58AM (#23777076)
Actually renewables can scale very well by covering much more area and thereby averaging out the wind and solar fluctuations across the country. The technology for achieving this is High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) a technology that has also been rapidly getting cheaper along with renewable technologies because its costs are driven by semiconductor technologies getting cheaper every year.
Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by acidburnNSA on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:39AM (#23777244)
Permitting transmission lines will get much, much harder with scale needed to do what you're saying.

With nuclear you don't need to build vast new storage and transmission, or cover the landscape with energy harvesters.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by cycomanic on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:49AM (#23777293)
With nuclear you still have to cove rthe landscape with nuclear powerplants, uranium mining pits (people like to forget these because they are not in their backyard) and nuclear storage (which is still an unsolved solution).

Then there is the problem that nuclear is terrible at anything but baseload, so you still need gas turbines for reacting to load. Everytime this is brought up nuclear proponents say research in new nuclear power generation will solve all of it. But they have been saying this for decades while renewable are there and all the solutions for its downsides exist.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by eru on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:56AM (#23777338)
You are not exactly 'covering the landscape'. See https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_161.shtml for some of the math for the example of Britain.

See the calculation starting on this page https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_166.shtml

> Land use

> Let’s imagine that Britain decides it is serious about getting off fossil fuels, and creates a lot of new nuclear reactors, even though this may not be “sustainable.” If we build enough reactors to make possible a significant decarbonization of transport and heating, can we fit the required nuclear reactors into Britain? The number we need to know is the power per unit area of nuclear power stations, which is about 1000W/m2 (figure 24.10). Let’s imagine generating 22 kWh per day per person of nuclear power – equivalent to 55 GW (roughly the same as France’s nuclear power), which could be delivered by 55 nuclear power stations, each occu- pying one square kilometre. That’s about 0.02% of the area of the country. Wind farms delivering the same average power would require 500 times as much land: 10% of the country. If the nuclear power stations were placed in pairs around the coast (length about 3000 km, at 5 km resolution), then there’d be two every 100 km. Thus while the area required is modest, the fraction of coastline gobbled by these power stations would be about 2% (2 kilometres in every 100).

The book also has sections about the economics of clean up. About fast breeder reactors and thorium designs.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by ljf on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:28AM (#23777524)
Isn't the economics of clean up that the government pays?

Is there anywhere in the world where the private operator of a nuclear power plant if covering all their own costs for clean up and decommissioning? Genuine question - I am well aware I could be wrong.

My understanding is that nuclear is always about energy independence - not cheap energy. (Don't get me wrong, the sooner we remove coal, biomass, wood and gas from our energy mix the better.)

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by eru on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:39AM (#23777586)
What's bad about biomass and wood? A country like eg Finland could probably run on wood burning, couldn't they?

> Is there anywhere in the world where the private operator of a nuclear power plant if covering all their own costs for clean up and decommissioning? Genuine question - I am well aware I could be wrong.

It's surprisingly hard to (quickly) find who is paying for those decommissioning funds. I imagine there's a levy on active nuclear power plant operations that goes into these funds.

You can find a lot of discussion online about whether those funds are big enough, and worries that they might not be.

Perhaps the most quantitative treatment I found is from https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_167.shtml

> Economics of cleanup

> What’s the cost of cleaning up nuclear power sites? The nuclear decommissioning authority has an annual budget of £2 billion for the next 25 years. The nuclear industry sold everyone in the UK 4 kWh/d for about 25 years, so the nuclear decommissioning authority’s cost is 2.3 p/kWh. That’s a hefty subsidy – though not, it must be said, as hefty as the subsidy currently given to offshore wind (7 p/kWh).

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by cycomanic on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:05AM (#23777702)
IIRC in Germany the nuclear power operators were essentially allowed to put aside large amount of money taxfree to be used for decommissioning. They used those funds to expand into many other areas (so they could use the funds for high risk investment). I will try to find a source.
Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by cycomanic on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:13AM (#23777734)
Ok adding as another comment.

The situation is actually more complicated than that see [1]. Essentially it comes to book keeping, however after 2017 the operators had to pay into a government fund to ensure sufficient funds to decommissioning (currently this holds 24 billion euro). Estimated decommissioning cost for a nuclear power plant are 1.2 billion euro (there is some dispute about the numbers though). This number does not include wast storage.

[1] https://www.iwr-institut.de/de/presse/presseinfos-kernenergi... (sorry only in German)

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by eru on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:32AM (#23777832)
Thanks!

(I'm German as well. But for other people: Google Translate has gotten really good.)

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by ljf on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:14PM (#23783921)
Thanks - interested to read that. I also think people forget the hidden subsidies for oil in terms of the wars and peace keeping that we have to get involved in to keep the oil flowing.

My understanding is that much of the wood that is burnt is actually shipped half way around the world to the UK and other countries just so it can earn 'carbon credits to be burnt there. I may be wrong, it was a while since I read the article. It also generates a lot of localised air pollution.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by redis_mlc on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:38AM (#23777578)
> Is there anywhere in the world where the private operator of a nuclear power plant if covering all their own costs for clean up and decommissioning?

You have to be kidding me.

No, in the US utilities are generally privately-owned, and are "responsible" for the cleanup.

Their playbook is:

1) Extend the operating license for an additional 20 years, safe or not.

2) After that, declare bankruptcy.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by cycomanic on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:01AM (#23777688)
Land use is not the main issue, but it's worth noting that nuclear power plants can not be build in nearly as many places as wind farms or solar power (as implicitly acknowledged in your coastline example), you need sufficient cooling capability.

But the main point still remains, nuclear power is bad at everything but baseload. And pointing at breeder or thorium reactors is exactly the thing I mentioned earlier. Technology that is completely uneconomical or unproven on commercial scale. Even France stopped doing breeders.

You are still ignoring the land use of open pit mining as well.

At the end nuclear is an uneconomic technology with significant unresolved issues even after decades of heavy subsidising, while renewable are cheaper proven and continously getting cheaper. The only reason to keep nuclear on the table is to keep power generation highly centralised and monopolized thus favouring few large corporations. It's ironic that nuclear is often proposed by self-confessed libertarians even though its the epitome of centralised corporatism.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by baud147258 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:31AM (#23777828)
I don't know which countries you're talking about, but in France 'renewable' energies are heavily subsided,
Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by eru on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:55AM (#23777945)
Cycomanic never said renewables don't get any subsidies. And that assumption is not needed for their argument.

The comment you are replying to merely said that decades of subsidizing nuclear didn't remove technical issues. And perhaps you can say the comment implied that the technical issues with renewables did mostly go away, without making any comment on whether renewables got any subsidies and on whether they helped or hindered.

(I would even go so far to argue that most of nuclear's remaining technical issues are from continued government meddling. But that's down to public opinion that wants government control of nuclear power. In places like eg Germany, for a long time the government was much more pro-nuclear than the population.)

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by eru on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:50AM (#23777923)
> You are still ignoring the land use of open pit mining as well.

The book I linked to mentioned some of that. It's just not much of an issue, since you need so little fuel. (And you could filter that fuel out of the ocean, if you really needed to.)

> At the end nuclear is an uneconomic technology with significant unresolved issues even after decades of heavy subsidising, while renewable are cheaper proven and continously getting cheaper. The only reason to keep nuclear on the table is to keep power generation highly centralised and monopolized thus favouring few large corporations. It's ironic that nuclear is often proposed by self-confessed libertarians even though its the epitome of centralised corporatism.

I'm just as happy as the next guy that decentralisable renewable options like wind and solar are becoming more and more competitive. Even the ascent of shale gas is a boon for the environment as long as it is replacing coal.

Nuclear fission (and fusion) are interesting as technologies. And especially fission is contrarian enough these days to attract certain types of admirers.

I do agree that in practice given global public opinion as it is, nuclear power is nigh guaranteed to remain centralised.

I am arguing that nuclear power generation has some flaws, but also that it doesn't have all the flaws.

Nuclear energy also used to serve as a useful reminder to the peak oil doomsayers (and these days to the climate change doomsayers), that in principle we could keep living a very energy intensive lifestyle, even if we were to stop using fossil fuels completely, and even if renewable solar and wind never took off.

Some people seemed to get an almost religious elation out of predicting that our sins would need to be paid for with lots of hardship and privation. Instead of just taking a hit of perhaps 10% of GDP or so to run everything on nuclear instead of oil.

(Similar to how the Club of Rome folks predicted doom from overpopulation. To broad popular appeal.)

As you point out, we are even luckier: renewables like wind and solar haven gotten cheaper faster than expected, so we found an even better alternative to oil and coal.

But it's good to know that there's another backup that in the grand scheme of things is not much worse than cheap oil used to be.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by cycomanic on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:03AM (#23778868)
I predict we will need to stop using GDP as a measure for progress. It was invented as a measure for production in war time (WW2) and was incredibly useful for its purpose. However initially it purposefully did not include banking, advertising, military spending..., because they don't add to a countries production capabilities.

It is a terrible measure for human well being. Many things which are actually detrimental increase the GDP (accidents, obesity, depression, pollution...). The inventor of the GDP Simon Kuznets even warned against using it to judge progress, but instead it has become this metric that is the be all.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by eru on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:20AM (#23791182)
People have tried alternate measures. But basically everything good anyone cares about is usually so strongly correlated with GDP that you might as well measure GDP. See eg https://voxeu.org/article/defence-gdp-measure-wellbeing

Btw, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_domestic_product#History suggests a more nuanced history of the concept.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by acidburnNSA on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:58AM (#23777348)
Nope because nuclear fuel energy density is 2000000x higher than all chemicals the land footprint is tiny. Like 450x less than wind total system.

Nuclear can load follow but chooses not to for economics reasons. Markets are human constructs and can be adjusted as needed. Also nuclear works fine with all forms of energy storage.

Re:The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas by jellicle on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:04AM (#23777377)
Nope. Most natural gas is produced by fracking; the fracking process produces great amounts of excess methane which is released into the atmosphere; fracked natural gas is approximately as bad as, or may even be worse than, coal.