News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by kelnos on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @02:30PM (#23772829)
> If desktop Linux is ever going to be mainstream there needs to be an easy to use "app store" where users can use a GUI to install apps which need to be sandboxed like on a mobile phone with defined permissions.

Curious... do you think that the world has moved on from the "download from website and run installer" model? Obviously that has serious drawbacks from a security perspective, but up until less than a decade ago, that was the only way to get software on Windows and macOS, and they were perfectly mainstream.

I think the majority of users out there don't understand sandboxing or permissions models or why they are useful. While I think those are the users that probably benefit from them the most, it doesn't follow that we need these things before average users will embrace a particular platform.

> A lot of people are mad at Canonical for not open sourcing the backend but no one seems to be offering to build one.

You mention Flatpak and then two sentences later claim this?

I think maybe you're just missing the point. I have been using Linux as my daily driver for a good two decades now. I don't care one bit about Linux being a mainstream desktop distro. Sure, if it was, new (and even not-so-new) hardware would get better support, and that would be a win. But getting that is not a fair trade off if what we have to accept in return is a closed-source, walled-garden software delivery model. Hard pass, no thanks.

For the most part, the only people who really care about "the year of the Linux desktop" are people trying to build a business around desktop Linux. Those aren't the sorts of people I want making decisions like this, but, unfortunately, they're often the kinds of people who have the ability to force these things on the community.

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by throwaway8941 on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @02:57PM (#23773101)
>For the most part, the only people who really care about "the year of the Linux desktop" are people trying to build a business around desktop Linux

As another long time Linux guy, I have a feeling most of those obsessed with Linux becoming a mainstream desktop platform are Mac or Windows users.

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by mad182 on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @03:36PM (#23773446)
Same. I'm running Linux as my primary desktop and server operating system for ~16 years, and I don't really care if it's becoming more mainstream on desktops anymore. It's already working perfectly fine for my needs, so I don't even want it to change much.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by MarcellusDrum on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @04:40PM (#23774007)
But it should at least continue to grow on the same rate as Windows and Mac. Losing market share is gonna be disastrous, as it would mean less software supported, and companies give less time to ensure quality of software supported.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by wmil on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @06:22PM (#23774847)
There are a lot of web developers who aren't thrilled with Apple's current lineup.

They just want to get Chrome and VSCode running without any headaches.

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by ttgo on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:40PM (#23798306)
Flatpak is not a walled garden. Flathub totally messed up the decentralised aspect of flatpak but in theory flatpak can be totally decentralised and you would add software source like you add .debs PPA

Flatpak doesn't impose closed-source, we have distros which only use open source flatpak repos.

Models like Flatpak have the advantage of "download from website & install" i.e you get the apps directly from the producer (which is better for security) while having no walled garden app store but having the advantage of auto updates & permission systems

I do not like Flatpak for technical reasons but Flatpak itself is in no way a walled garden solution, the problem is Flathub.

> I don't care one bit about Linux being a mainstream desktop distro

If you still want to be able to run Linux at all (not even on new hardware) on a consumer hardware, then you should care.

- Linux doesn't run (decently) on Microsoft latest surfaces - Linux won't run on new Apple hardware - Linux doesn't run on Android phones (with a few exceptions) - once Google switch to Fushia no more Linux kernel on mobile hardware - on the long term Huawei will ditch Android and other OS for their own thing.

Linux will die on consumer hardware (except on servers) if it does not become more popular. According to Apple's keynote the future of Linux is in its cage, in a VM running on walled garden MacOS. According to Microsoft the future of Linux is WSL, running on top Windows.

If you do not like walled garden then you should definitively care about Linux getting more mainstream before no comsumer hardwares support it anymore

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by pjmlp on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:11AM (#23778903)
> For the most part, the only people who really care about "the year of the Linux desktop" are people trying to build a business around desktop Linux.

I used to care, nowadays I just focus on Apple, Google and Microsoft platforms instead, and leave Linux for cloud VMs.

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by pjfin123 on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @02:36PM (#23772881)
No one is offering to build an alternate store for snaps, Flatpak is building an entirely different executable.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by thekyle on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @04:26PM (#23773877)
I believe that the Canonical Snap server is hardcoded into snapd, so even if someone did implement their own you would need to recompile snapd to even use it.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by aritmo on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:22AM (#23778655)
Of course it is and of course you would need to recompile snapd. These are standard practices in software engineering.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by michaelmrose on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:21PM (#23803785)
Laying countertops is standard handyman stuff but if your coffeepot doesn't do anything truly unique and requires you to rip it up to switch coffeepots it may be ill designed.
Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by blendergeek on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @04:18PM (#23773798)
Why would anyone offer an alternate store for snaps?

Ubuntu seems to have made clear that the snap client will not be able to connect to alternative stores. What is the point of building an alternative store.

Further snap is controlled by one company. Canonical has a history of developing groundbreaking new things for the Linux community before unceremoniously killing them off.

* Ubuntu One * Unity Desktop * Ubuntu Touch * Upstart Init system

Do you see a trend here? There is a reason the community is skeptical of something completely controlled by Canonical.

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by xet7 on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @08:10PM (#23775684)
Continuing Ubuntu One was not sustainable: https://ubuntu.com/blog/shutting-down-ubuntu-one-file-servic...

Ubuntu One file syncing, also server part, has been Open Sourced with much effort from Canonical: https://ubuntu.com/blog/ubuntu-one-file-syncing-code-open-so...

Ubuntu Touch https://ubports.com is run by community and has rapid progress, it's running on PinePhone etc.

Canonical would have liked to continue Unity: https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2017/10/why-did-ubuntu-drop-unit...

I would presume Upstart Init system was changed to systemd because other distros started using systemd.

I don't see a trend here.

Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages by afiori on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:44AM (#23780079)
You have described a trend where those technologies failed to gain sustainable traction and Canonical stopped investing in them. Whether they did this because they are evil or unlucky is not the point.