Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by trotsky on Saturday March 26, 2011 @11:28PM
(#2374061)
What does the security model for opening the files look like? If you specify a directory chooser the app can span the directory tree and open/parse all files readable to the user? Any idea if it will walk symbolic links? I'm a bit surprised there isn't more of a user warning from the browser.
Nice proof of concept though! Very impressive what can be done. Worked well in stable channel + openSUSE.
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by pat2man on Sunday March 27, 2011 @02:24AM
(#2374355)
Operating systems seem to care a lot about write access , less about read access. As much as browsers should care about this an OS should do some sandboxing.
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by nl on Sunday March 27, 2011 @04:48AM
(#2374561)
Exactly.
The permission is implicitly granted by the user when they select a file. (Obviously this is implementation specific, but I think all implementations behave this was)
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by nealb on Saturday March 26, 2011 @10:55PM
(#2374002)
Worked well in Chrome 10 on Windows 7 for the first few minutes then crashed. Adding files was a little bit slow but the audio playback and tagging worked well. Nicely done though, it's very cool!
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by 51Cards on Saturday March 26, 2011 @11:55PM
(#2374101)
I'm quite curious about the file reading code. With a simple directory browse from the user couldn't you start to walk the file tree and read whatever you liked? Nothing I see to stop something like this then firing off Ajax calls to send up everything it finds. I think some digging through the code is in order.
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by trotsky on Sunday March 27, 2011 @01:10AM
(#2374236)
It seems quite clear that you could package up all files and send them to the server. I've read through the code in this example though and I don't see anything that could be doing that here. Since all of the code is being served off of github I think it'd be pretty hard to switch in some malicious code at times, but I would be pretty wary of granting access to a webkitdirectory chooser type from a less transparent site.
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by pornel on Sunday March 27, 2011 @02:37PM
(#2375598)
Author of the app can read your directory listing (and whether that matters depends on what you have in this directory and whether you trust application's author)
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by aj700 on Sunday March 27, 2011 @02:34PM
(#2375592)
Not talking about this specifically, but the model:
If an app only deals with local data, does it need to be a web app?, except that thereby it becomes zero-install, zero-update, global and cross-platform.
Could or is ChromeOS going to play local mp3s before? It's not much of an OS if it can only play mp3s on a server somewhere, with a browser plugin. Will Spotify and other streaming clients work on it? Is it cloud data only?
Re:HTML5 MP3 Player - Plays local files and parses ID3 tags
by sp332 on Sunday March 27, 2011 @12:03PM
(#2375228)
Well, it doesn't read ID3 tags, but if you just drag your music folder into Firefox, you can browse around and play MP3, Vorbis etc. files. It also works with videos.
Nice proof of concept though! Very impressive what can be done. Worked well in stable channel + openSUSE.
The permission is implicitly granted by the user when they select a file. (Obviously this is implementation specific, but I think all implementations behave this was)
Having tried numerous audio players for OSX I just can't find something that I'm satisfied with. I guess I'll just start building my own now :)
If an app only deals with local data, does it need to be a web app?, except that thereby it becomes zero-install, zero-update, global and cross-platform.
Could or is ChromeOS going to play local mp3s before? It's not much of an OS if it can only play mp3s on a server somewhere, with a browser plugin. Will Spotify and other streaming clients work on it? Is it cloud data only?
Firefox 3.6: fail
Chromium 10: loads, fails to play
Opera: loads site with errors, clicking button doesn't do anything
Make sure to use OGG Vorbis audio in Chromium. I'm guessing you tried to play MP3.
Try User > Music > and select the iTunes Folder
Nice work though, antimatter15, keep it up!