News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by orbital-decay on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:41PM (#23708187)
It's not that crazy if you consider that it was a part of the Soviet Union, where these helis were designed and produced at two different factories. Ka-26 is a fairly old and relatively simple helicopter with two radial engines, no complex turbomachinery. They probably did this with the old Soviet equipment and documentation, both either smuggled or maybe even bought legally. The experts from Buryatia or Bashkortostan who produced them back in the USSR might have also been involved in this.

So my guess these are not "fake" helicopters but probably "real" Ka-26s, it was just an unlicensed production. Still impressive though.

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by na85 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:54PM (#23708290)
The real issue (IMHO) is highlighted in the article:

>All the helicopters were produced without the necessary permits and documents of origin for the parts and equipment used.

In aerospace it's common to speak of certificates of conformance, which is a legal attestation from the manufacturer that the part is of genuine origin and complies with the specification from the aircraft's type design. The manufacturer is periodically audited/assessed for their quality control practices and parts are routinely tested to ensure they are airworthy.

The issue here, as per the above quote, is that they were probably using bootleg parts from random Chinese suppliers, which might be no big deal but might also have not been heat treated properly, for example, in order to save manufacturing cost.

If parts aren't compliant with the spec you can have structural failures in flight which is of course no bueno.

So yes, these are probably "real" Kamovs in the sense that they're probably built from real Kamov blueprints, but what many people outside the industry don't realize is that aerospace design and manufacturing encompasses much more than the blueprint. The whole program from the drawing board to the assembly line to the in-service maintenance work has to be a cohesive whole in order to produce an airworthy product.

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by heelix on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:10PM (#23709226)
My brother-in-law does fire/crop dusting with a turbine helicopter. My mentality of what an airplane annual should look like is profoundly different then what he considers 'normal maintenance' on what he uses for work. Every single part of one of those machines has a ridiculously short time to live.

I've heard rumors that parts past their time to live would ship to less rigorous countries. Likely a bunch of EOL parts in the mix too.

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by cameldrv on Thursday July 02, 2020 @12:11AM (#23709933)
Aircraft parts also generally have tighter engineering margins (strength etc) than other engineered products because there's a huge need to keep weight to a minimum. If they're not built according to the design, as you say, no bueno.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by LilBytes on Thursday July 02, 2020 @01:21AM (#23710258)
I certainly wouldn't my helicopters Jesus nut [1] to be purchased and procured through Alibaba, for sure.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesus_nut

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by buran77 on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:30AM (#23711472)
> have tighter engineering margins

But still have to cover very wide operational margins (they are overspecced) because many failures are catastrophic so they can't run on the edge of failing all the time.

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:14PM (#23708892)
In practice though, that’s only a real issue if the wrong people die in a crash as a result of non-compliant parts.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by IfOnlyYouKnew on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:55PM (#23709839)
Bullshit populist conspiracy drivel. Any plane or helicopter crash is big news and gets scrutinized quite extensively.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by ashtonkem on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:35PM (#23709035)
Depends on your jurisdiction. The FAA can be a real stickler about things having the right paperwork.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by baybal2 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @08:19PM (#23708477)
> no complex turbomachinery.

The turbomachinery is by far more simpler than high performance piston engines.

A car engine of 200kw only needs to give peak power for a few seconds of acceleration, and can be electronically safeguarded from outside of envelope operation.

An avia engine of 200kw needs to be able to operate on its full rated power continuously, for longer continuous periods of operation, be many times as reliable as a car engine, be lighter than a car engine, be engineered to accommodate, and survive failures, and be engineered free of governor mechanisms of any kind that may fail on take off (engine governor having to deliver demanded performance even if it has to waste the engine)

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by sudosysgen on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:09PM (#23709555)
There are 200kw car engines that in reality can be pushed to ~600kw with minimal modification. I'm sure you could run a 2JZ at 80% for thousands of hours.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by cameldrv on Thursday July 02, 2020 @12:15AM (#23709955)
I wouldn't bet on it. The safety record of auto engines converted for aircraft use (generally in homebuilt/experimentals) is not very favorable. Auto engines are designed to cruise at 10% power or less with brief excursions to higher power. An aircraft engine runs at 75% power for hours continuously, and even with modifications, auto engines historically have not delivered the reliability of the essentially 1930s designs of aircraft piston engines.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by sudosysgen on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:52PM (#23727512)
Sure, and a 2JZ can run at over 100% for 10 hours non stop (in endurance races, at 300% with a duty cycle over 30%)

Most car engines are engineered for weight savings and efficiency instead of reliability. Not all.

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:18PM (#23708918)
When we’re in the realm of aircraft engines, I’d like to imagine continuous rated power isn’t also peak power?

Is this not the case?

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by dpe82 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:21PM (#23709631)
Depends on the aircraft and engine. Some (like my little Rotax 912ULS) has a peak power at which I can only operate at for 1 minute during takeoff. I typically cruise around 70% peak.

I believe in Helicopters you're often running at 90%+ max rated power, but on an engine that's derated from its true maximum power.

Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by slavak on Thursday July 02, 2020 @07:41AM (#23712106)
Your Rotax is limited to 5 continuous min. at 5800 rpm, or a max continuous RPM of 5500. There's no setting at which you are limited to only 1 min.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by dpe82 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:25AM (#23777181)
Ah yes you're correct. I use 1 minute as my personal limit so I don't grow accustomed to running it too hard for too long, but the operator's manual indeed states 5 minutes above 5500. I have a fixed pitch prop, which means I typically can only spin the prop at those speeds during cruise anyhow.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by jaclaz on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:25AM (#23711760)
Generally speaking on combustion (piston) engines the max torque (and efficiency) is at revs between 2/3 and 3/4, sometime 4/5 of power peak revs, and in "static" applications (i.e. when you don't have an accelerator that you use continuously) such as aviation but also power generators, hydraulic loaders and excavators, etc. they normally are operated (continuously) at those levels range (around max torque).
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by ashtonkem on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:36PM (#23709044)
I can’t speak to helicopters, but light aircraft engines tend to run at 80% of peak; peak is only used for takeoff and go around, to my knowledge. (Not a pilot)
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by latchkey on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:58PM (#23708312)
More impressive are the people who'd ride in one of these.
Re:Moldova Shuts Down Bootleg Helicopter Factory by manquer on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @08:16PM (#23708442)
It is matter of availability and price for any customer , particularly a desperate one ( organized crime groups in war affected regions ?)

FAA and certifications have improved safety a lot , most people however would still get on a unmodified 737 MAX if it was cheapest/only option available .