News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @05:41PM (#23695122)
I am made worse off if you steal a copy of my book though. Suppose I sell the book for X dollars and the probability that any person without my book will buy it is Y. People who don't have my book have a value to me, specifically, YX dollars.

When you steal my book, you directly cost me YX dollars, which is probably an infinitesimal amount, but if everyone was allowed to freely copy the book, then it would be approximately 100% of the money to be made by writing a book.

Of course there are complications, like, you might buy it after pirating it, or, you weren't going to buy it anyway, or maybe you'll recommend it to a friend, but I think those considerations should be evaluated by the people with skin in the game - i.e the people who will make or lose money if they get it wrong.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by HideousKojima on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @05:45PM (#23695143)
You're assuming that Y is evenly distributed amongst all people, which is absolutely not the case. For example, I did most of my game pirating back in high school, when I didn't have a job (nor a car to get to a job and I lived out in the sticks) and had nothing but an allowance from my parents of ~$20 every month.

So the maximum amount I could theoretically spend on games per year? $120. The retail value of all of the different games I pirated annually? Well over $1,000, probably several thousand. So the probability of me paying for any significant portion of the games I pirated was effectively 0

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:25PM (#23695481)
I'm not assuming that at all. My model is extremely simplified so it would fit into a comment, but it doesn't need to be that simple for the general idea to hold.

Suppose you pirated a thousand games and would've legitimately purchased one. Your piracy then represents a theft of one game. Since there's no way to tell which one game you would've bought, we could simplify it to say that stole one one thousandth of a game from each publisher (assuming they were all unique publishers).

In reality, I think it's really hard to know what you would've done without access to piracy. It's almost certainly not "buy all the games" but it's also probably not "buy zero games".

I also pirated a lot of things when I was in college - partly because it was cheaper, and I was very cheap, and partly because it was easier than actually getting some things. One thing I try to do is separate my own personal bias (it can't be bad because I did it) from what seems like the clear harm and moral reasoning I laid out above. You're taking from the publishers, even if only small values, and if everyone did what you did, publishing couldn't exist as a business.

I think it makes sense that poor people would steal more frequently. They need to. It also makes sense that younger people would steal more frequently - they are less mature, think less about others, and less about the consequences. Given that, it doesn't surprise me that you and I both pirated more while younger. That said, even though it makes sense, that doesn't mean it's right.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:16PM (#23696352)
That's a lot of supposing.

Suppose instead if piracy wasn't an option the poster just played free games instead, or did something else with their time.

> but it's also probably not "buy zero games".

In this scenario, the poster may very well not have a credit card (because what's the point if you have no income, also a minor), so it might very we be the case he was physically unable to purchase these games online, especially in the era before online "gift cards" were a thing.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:22PM (#23697058)
"the maximum amount I could theoretically spend on games per year? $120"

For someone who complains about the quantity of my supposing, it's strange that you are supposing counterfactuals explicitly rejected by the OP.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:42AM (#23697807)
Max theoretically i can spend (sum of all my income after basic needs met) != max i will spend on video games. In fact, it would be insane to assume that i would spend 100% of my disposible income on one thing.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by Mindwipe on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:28PM (#23695511)
> So the probability of me paying for any significant portion of the games I pirated was effectively 0

It was literally 1 in 10.

Which is a very long way from 0%.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:21PM (#23696380)
Poster said in theory if he spent all his money he could pay for 10% of the games he pirated. It does not follow that he neccesarily would if piracy was not an option.

If i buy something for $0, and then later the cost goes up,it doesn't follow i would automatically buy it at an increased cost even if i can afford it.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by HideousKojima on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:35PM (#23696447)
I had other things to spend money on besides video games
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by Thorentis on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:38PM (#23696465)
This assumes that ideas can actually be stolen. If you release a creative work into the wild (i.e. publish it), then you have taken the risk that others will photocopy it, write it down word for word on a piece of paper, memorise it, be inspired by it and have a better more profitable idea, etc. Nobody can compel you to release work you've created, but once you release it then you've let it go.

Now, our society has decided that in order to give an incentive for people to buy books, we will make it illegal to copy books. That is arbitrary, and purely an economic decision.

If I go to a library that holds your book and memorise it, have I stolen it? What if everybody who ever wanted to buy your work decided they'd rather just read it once at a library? Is it stolen? Of course not.

When you purchase a book, you are rewarding the publisher for their time and materials in physically producing the book. The author already made their profit when the publisher bought the rights off them. If a publisher wishes to enter into a royalties agreement instead, they do so at their own risk. Society should not protect the royalty system, which I believe is unfair compared to the flat-rate payment anyway. For smaller authors, a publisher will usually work out how many copies they think they can sell, and give the author an amount proportional to that. They then bare the risk of selling less, and are exposed to the opportunity of selling more. The author has received their reward, and the publisher must do their best to sell them.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by uluyol on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:18PM (#23695419)
No, because potential sales are not sales. You never had the XY dollars to begin with.

This is what separates IP theft from physical property theft.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:26PM (#23695499)
I never said they were sales. I explicitly differentiated them from sales. They are potential sales, valued at YX and potential sales are what you lose. A sale has a value of X dollars.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by basch on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:50PM (#23695722)
That's what makes it not theft. Theft deprives the person of the original. If I have two books and you take one I have one book. If you buy one of my books and give it out, I did not have any of the books I had stolen from me.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @07:07PM (#23695843)
Theft does deprive the victim of something. As I've written above, piracy is theft as it deprives the victim of potential sales.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by missosoup on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:02PM (#23696636)
You can't deprive someone of something they may or may not have had. Copyright infringement is legally not defined as theft for this reason.

Where it gets really muddy is whether copyright infringement causes any harm at all. We've had interest groups claiming millions of dollars worth of potential sales lost and we've had studies showing that actually piracy may be a net benefit to creators due to increased market exposure.

All of this pontification can be put aside though. China does not enforce copyright or most other IP laws, and yet has a thriving entertainment, engineering, literary, etc. industry. So clearly IP protection is not critical for innovation or a healthy industry, as interest groups here would have us believe.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by salawat on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:11PM (#23697362)
No it doesn't. You can't steal something that hasn't happened yet.

E wry game I've bootleggedI've eventually gone and bought When I had the dosh and the terms were right. You can't claim you "lost me as a potential sale." Otherwise, you'd have grounds for counting everyone who didn't buy your game or whatever IP as a loss.

Until it materializes, it isn't yours to account for. Just as I can't sue a chicken for the egg inlaid, it makes no sense to allow for the legal recognition of "potential sales lost".

Especially nowadays more than ever, where one isn't even largely acquiring the thing anymore, but signing a contract to host an entertainment experience on hardware they supposedly own,but which has been in reality co-opted at the manufacturing and design level by rights holders to put in place the means of extortion from society their perceived pound of flesh with no recourse.

In fact, I'd say if it's fine for you to keep track of and argue the harm of lost potential sales, I should have a matching valid claim in potential buys I was never able to make because industry colluded to ensure that proprietary anti-features in the form of DRM were included in all the hardware I haven't subsequently purchased.

Fair's only fair after all.

I don't know about you, but I'd prefer the law stick to matters of the actual rather than hypothetical.

And before you argue there is a difference between not making something for purchase (hardware platforms sans DRM mechanisms) and not realizing a sale because of privacy, I would advise you to consider the dual nature of transactions. Value is not created, merely exchanged via fungible means. Just as I'm cheated out of DRM free hardware by collisions with industry by rights holders, so too are rights holders plagued by those who find ways around things.

I'd rather live in a world where useful information could flow freely. I'm still willing to compensate for something that genuinely entertains, enlightens, or helps me. That magnanimity goes down the hole once it turns into extortion.

And make no mistake, it always does. I've yet to see a significantly cheaper ebook than a paperback. Instead, I see them treated as roughly equivalent despite the sharp loss of utility of a DRM'd artifact.

Until that madness resolves, and I stop running into people who feel entitled to hypothetical sales, I see no reason to take rightholders as arguing at all in good faith.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:48AM (#23699322)
I regret joining this topic because I think it invites arguments that are only philosophical and people are generally unlikely to change their minds from what they already believe. For example, when I read your comment I already know I disagree with you, and have but to set my fingertips to the keyboard to let the disagreement flow. In the same way, I know you'll disagree with me, and it's hard for me to see how there is anything productive here.

Violating copyright takes potential sales. Those have value. For example, if you had a product worth X dollars, and people had a Y chance of buying it, you could sell the rights to your product based on that value.

Our society respects the concept of potential sales or potential value in many ways. If I lie and say that your restaurant is filled with rats, what am I costing you, if not potential sales? I could sell options contracts that have potential value. If I break the fingers of a master pianist or a surgeon I may be sued for a greater amount of damages than if I broke the fingers of any professional who doesn't need manual dexterity.

Potential value is the basis for lots of business and productive endeavors. It's why society respects intellectual property rights, to give creators a chance to earn something from their work, which, without the supporting legal framework, would be hard to monetize.

I went to Amazon and looked at a top 10 list. The first five books available in paperback and Kindle format are:

https://www.amazon.com/Best-Sellers-Books-Literature-Fiction...

https://www.amazon.com/Opium-Absinthe-Novel-Lydia-Kang-ebook..., 4.99, 10.99 https://www.amazon.com/Bone-Jar-Detective-Kirby-Book-ebook/d... https://www.amazon.com/Book-Woman-Troublesome-Creek-Novel-eb... https://www.amazon.com/Someone-Elses-Secret-Julia-Spiro-eboo... https://www.amazon.com/Where-Crawdads-Sing-Delia-Owens/dp/07...

Average Kindle price: 7.51

Average paperback price: 11.7

Kindle is, on average, 64% the cost of a paperback. Combine that with greater functionality and ease of use, and I think the Kindle format is a winner.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by basch on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:20AM (#23702421)
What everyone is saying is exactly the opposite of philosophical. This is an argument of semantics.

The existing supreme court rulings are crystal clear that they treat infringement as a different type of crime than theft, as they have different properties. No one is arguing with you about IF loss of sales can occur. They are telling you the legal definition of theft does not cover loss of potential. Hence the use of the word infringement. You are trying to redefine the word theft from its existing legal usage. Use a different word than theft.

Dowling v. United States (1985)

>interference with copyright does not easily equate with theft, conversion, or fraud. The infringer of a copyright does not assume physical control over the copyright nor wholly deprive its owner of its use. Infringement implicates a more complex set of property interests than does run-of-the-mill theft, conversion, or fraud.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dowling_v._United_States_(1985...

This isnt about what we believe. It's what the law says and how the courts have told us they choose to interpret it. It's (interpreting their interpretation) is not really a debate or an argument open to interpretation, as they were so clear there really arent multiple ways to read it. This isnt about any of us changing our minds with regard to what theft means, as its not an opinion.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:19PM (#23708006)
Do you genuinely interpret what I wrote as a claim that internet piracy met the legal definition of theft?
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by basch on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:56PM (#23726028)
I am telling you, that everyone else arguing against you is having an argument of semantics, that you are using the wrong words to make your point.

Steal and theft are the wrong words to describe a loss of potential sale.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:24PM (#23696395)
Depriving someone of a potential sale is a weird definition of theft. Generalizing it seems like it would lead to problematic outcomes.

If a critic writes a negative book review, and people do not buy the book as a result, did the reviewer "steal" from the author?

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by zucker42 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:34AM (#23699246)
If you own a taco stand and I open a pizza place next to you, I will deprive you of some potential sales. Clearly, that condition isn't sufficient to indicate theft.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by account42 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @05:08AM (#23699454)
Then you writing the book in the first place is theft as it deprives other authors of potential sales.