News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by HideousKojima on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @05:45PM (#23695143)
You're assuming that Y is evenly distributed amongst all people, which is absolutely not the case. For example, I did most of my game pirating back in high school, when I didn't have a job (nor a car to get to a job and I lived out in the sticks) and had nothing but an allowance from my parents of ~$20 every month.

So the maximum amount I could theoretically spend on games per year? $120. The retail value of all of the different games I pirated annually? Well over $1,000, probably several thousand. So the probability of me paying for any significant portion of the games I pirated was effectively 0

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:25PM (#23695481)
I'm not assuming that at all. My model is extremely simplified so it would fit into a comment, but it doesn't need to be that simple for the general idea to hold.

Suppose you pirated a thousand games and would've legitimately purchased one. Your piracy then represents a theft of one game. Since there's no way to tell which one game you would've bought, we could simplify it to say that stole one one thousandth of a game from each publisher (assuming they were all unique publishers).

In reality, I think it's really hard to know what you would've done without access to piracy. It's almost certainly not "buy all the games" but it's also probably not "buy zero games".

I also pirated a lot of things when I was in college - partly because it was cheaper, and I was very cheap, and partly because it was easier than actually getting some things. One thing I try to do is separate my own personal bias (it can't be bad because I did it) from what seems like the clear harm and moral reasoning I laid out above. You're taking from the publishers, even if only small values, and if everyone did what you did, publishing couldn't exist as a business.

I think it makes sense that poor people would steal more frequently. They need to. It also makes sense that younger people would steal more frequently - they are less mature, think less about others, and less about the consequences. Given that, it doesn't surprise me that you and I both pirated more while younger. That said, even though it makes sense, that doesn't mean it's right.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:16PM (#23696352)
That's a lot of supposing.

Suppose instead if piracy wasn't an option the poster just played free games instead, or did something else with their time.

> but it's also probably not "buy zero games".

In this scenario, the poster may very well not have a credit card (because what's the point if you have no income, also a minor), so it might very we be the case he was physically unable to purchase these games online, especially in the era before online "gift cards" were a thing.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:22PM (#23697058)
"the maximum amount I could theoretically spend on games per year? $120"

For someone who complains about the quantity of my supposing, it's strange that you are supposing counterfactuals explicitly rejected by the OP.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:42AM (#23697807)
Max theoretically i can spend (sum of all my income after basic needs met) != max i will spend on video games. In fact, it would be insane to assume that i would spend 100% of my disposible income on one thing.
Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by Mindwipe on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:28PM (#23695511)
> So the probability of me paying for any significant portion of the games I pirated was effectively 0

It was literally 1 in 10.

Which is a very long way from 0%.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by bawolff on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:21PM (#23696380)
Poster said in theory if he spent all his money he could pay for 10% of the games he pirated. It does not follow that he neccesarily would if piracy was not an option.

If i buy something for $0, and then later the cost goes up,it doesn't follow i would automatically buy it at an increased cost even if i can afford it.

Re:EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archi... by HideousKojima on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:35PM (#23696447)
I had other things to spend money on besides video games