For a more empirical approach, I think it's worth looking at "Against Intellectual Monopoly" [1], from 2008. "Chapter 8: Does Intellectual Monopoly Increase Innovation?" [2] may be of particular interest.
[1] http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/againstfinal.ht...
Prince applauded Napster and said people could finally go back to making music for the sake of making music.
I personally don't consider any entertainment important enough to play a role in the design of society. As long as people are working themselves to death merely to sustain themselves they shouldn't be made to pay for your entertainment in any way.
That it also doesn't make any technical sense never truly occurred to me.
I recommend we decrease patent durations of all varieties by about 50% (patents should never last longer than 10 years as they do now [0]). For copyrights, there is some merit to not allowing others to take over your work during the life of the author. But for anonymous works, works that have transferred ownership from the author, and for copyright terms after the death of the author, I would agree to a similar limit of 10 years of copyright.
[0] https://www.justia.com/intellectual-property/patents/duratio....
https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/abs/10.1377/hlthaff.25.2.4...
Care to expand on that?
I would think this would make sense in some cases, like writing a story, and less sense in some others (software source code).
>Interference with copyright does not easily equate with theft, conversion, or fraud. The infringer of a copyright does not assume physical control over the copyright nor wholly deprive its owner of its use. Infringement implicates a more complex set of property interests than does run-of-the-mill theft, conversion, or fraud.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dowling_v._United_States_(1985...
.....
I do think grouping all IP into a bucket muddies the conversation. Trademark infringement, where one assumes the name of another product, possibly selling a counterfeit is closer to theft. It involves defrauding the consumer, and displaces a legitimate sale with a copy.
Copying a product, and selling it or giving it away free is one type of problem, but assuming someone elses trademark to mislead is a different magnitude of problem.
The flaw in this concept is the free-rider problem:
1. Not all new IP can be created as a side project without funding.
Suppose that I have to come up with an investment of $X million to pay for the goods and services needed to develop something.
(Even assigning existing employees to do the work is an investment, because the money used to pay them presumably could be used for something else — i.e., investing in the new thing represents opportunity cost.)
Suppose also that the resulting IP is easily copied once the new product or service is out in the open.
Without some kind of legal monopoly under IP law, copiers — who aren't burdened by my development costs — can quickly run the market price down to marginal cost.
2. A marginal-cost market price means that I can't charge enough to be able to recoup my investment while still staying competitive.
That, in turn, means that I'm unlikely to be willing (or even able) to fund the investment needed to develop the IP.
3. That's why the U.S. Constitution, article I, section 8, clause 8, allows Congress to create IP rights for limited times.
[0] https://uh.edu/engines/epi792.htm