News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by loughnane on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:46AM (#23629304)
I get the desire to abandon google services, and have done so myself for email and search, but there isn't much to this article.

An old gmail account being noisy is probably more a function of it being old than it being a gmail account. I suspect he'd see a great improvement just starting a new email address.

Airtable has some nice functionality, but I don't think it's head-and-shoulders above sheets and this article doesn't give me any reason to change my mind.

Same things goes for Meet vs Zoom.

Honestly, despite Google's history of trashing projects I'd put my money on gmail/docs outliving hey/notion and so he might just be planting the seeds of a painful switch later. When I switched my email I did it with a domain I own so that I can avoid the same fate.

That's not to say google doesn't have problems. Privacy aside, ads as a primary source of revenue can have a negative effect on usability of their products (like search), but I wouldn't call that "squandering a 10-year lead", it's more like "failure to find a second golden goose"

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by hodgesrm on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:56AM (#23629465)
The article rings completely true to me. One simple example: folders in Google Drive.

* It's a constant struggle to keep documents in folders so that you can find them easily.

* Yeah I get that I can do google search and find docs wherever they live. But I can't find docs if I don't know that they exist.

* Moreover, I can't ensure that important documents are reliably stored in folders where everyone else can find them easily as well.

I don't understand why Google does not get how important this is for business documents. It's a breath of fresh air to use Dropbox or Box at this point.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by SenHeng on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:34PM (#23630145)
> Yeah I get that I can do google search and find docs wherever they live. But I can't find docs if I don't know that they exist.

To illustrate this point more. I used to work in a company where everyone had to submit their timesheet via docs. And if you did not keep a link or copy or whatever they call it of your own sheet, it's essentially impossible to search for it, because now there are 1000s of identically named documents.

It also happens when legal tries to share a generically named file with you and you lose the link, so you search for it and find a file that looks like it, only to realise that is HR's own special copy.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by hodgesrm on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:11PM (#23632488)
This. I wish I had thought of your example first.

We have service agreements that go through revisions. We copy the whole directory when there's a new release to ensure we don't lose old templates. At that point search on service agreements brings up a bunch of identically named documents in a listing that does not distinguish the directory location. It's actually caused us to send the wrong doc on several occasions.

Google if you are listening please fix this. Just do what everyone else does. You don't have to be creative.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by inakarmacoma on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:40PM (#23632901)
Docs has revision history.

For several of the concerns listed, I'm surprised to see how people are using the app.

Similar for asking every employee of a company to track their time in same name documents?

Perhaps poor processes and poor tool-to-solution matches contribute?

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by BeatLeJuce on Thursday June 25, 2020 @02:08AM (#23637389)
Arguably then, the documentation needs improvement. Most people learned the ropes on MS Word, and never bothered to unlearn habits/explore whatever else docs has to offer. So whenever docs has a feature that isn't present in word, I wouldn't expect people to know it's there
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by VRay on Thursday June 25, 2020 @12:26PM (#23642442)
So they're using it wrong?

/s

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by reidjs on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:48PM (#23631330)
I wouldn't call this an issue w/ google docs, just pick a consistent naming scheme like timesheet_john_smith_august_2015. Or even better, just make it so only John Smith can see John Smith's timesheets through sharing preferences.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by sz4kerto on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @02:29PM (#23631938)
Fantastic, so we're back from namespaces (directories) to prefixes.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by charwalker on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:27PM (#23631022)
That sounds more like a process issue than a technology issue. The tools to manage this exist in the tech but mixing access, not restricting access, and other issues that persist in file shares, shared email boxes, mirroring AD access for new users, etc are the same issues as an old gmail that gets 1000 spam emails a day; it's a mess that needs to be audited and overhauled which is easiest by jumping to a new system/platform when able.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by fireattack on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:05PM (#23629617)
Can you elaborate more? I have no issues to put files or Google Docs in whatever folders I want in Google Drive, and they stay where they are (after all, Google Drive has local sync. It would be unusable if they don't).
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by callmeal on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:55PM (#23631428)
The issue is when there's more than one team that needs access. There are multiple ways to share a document and the links to the original are all different (based on how it was shared: via a shared drive or via a shared folder or via a shared document link). And finding that shared document (if you don't remember how it was shared in the first place) can be a nightmare.

Sometimes you don't have a choice - we are a small team, and we're pretty good about using a shared drive and a shared folder. But sometimes you have to share a document with an external collaborator (or someone in another firm shares a document with you). And if you forgot how that document was shared, then google makes it practically impossible to find the original.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by Drew_ on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @05:22PM (#23634026)
The only problem I see here is that either you guys are not using a file structure that makes sense to everyone or you're sharing links for random things and the people receiving those links are losing/ignoring them. Neither of these things sound like problems with Google Drive to me.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by gumby on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:56PM (#23630582)
> One simple example: folders in Google Drive.

Tell me about it! The local Scout troop uses google docs for routine stuff like flyers, sign up sheets etc. I continue to routinely see unrelated material there: kids’ homework, doctor’s patient records, once a marketing plan for $BIG_SV_COMPANY etc. It’s not like there are one or two clueless souls: several documents a week show ip from all sorts of different people.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by lern_too_spel on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @02:35PM (#23632026)
You're not the only one. Organizing documents in Google Drive is a huge pain. When I create a folder, I often want to put multiple existing documents in it. I find the documents by searching, and each time, the "Move to Folder" modal makes me navigate the directory hierarchy to find my new folder instead of having it available as a recently-accessed folder like Gnome does.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by hodgesrm on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:21PM (#23632617)
Seen that one too. The fact you can't do quick batch operations across many documents makes me crazy.

Google Docs has so much potential. Google should just spin it off into a separate company and let it find its own way. Making it conform to Google notions of search has crippled the design.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by deelowe on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:05PM (#23629612)
I'm confused. Doesn't shared drives solve this problem? You can set up a group, created a shared drive for that group, and then everyone has access to what's stored within it.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by milesskorpen on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:49PM (#23630452)
Shared Drives are a disaster, because the files in them are removed from your personal drive which makes them less discoverable for you.

They work when highly managed (e.g., our training team for sales org) but not for product development teams in my experience.

The expanding symlink functionality makes everything worse, because people think they're moving folders, but they're not, and permissions don't get rationalized. Ugh.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by MperorM on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:19PM (#23629852)
I don't really understand this sentiment, here's how my drive looks:

https://i.imgur.com/UUUboTd.png

does your drive look significantly different from this?

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by txcwpalpha on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:27PM (#23630004)
Mine does. I agree wholeheartedly with the parent commenter.

My personal G Drive looks similar to yours. It looks like your Drive is mostly used by you, and not many (if any) other collaborators. The problem is that my work G Drive is an utter clusterfuck because of the numerous different ways that documents can be shared between people/teams. There are shared folders, shared drives, individually shared documents, and probably more. And each one of them shows up in a completely different place than the others.

If you're working with one specific team, you can likely get that entire team to conform to one way of doing things (everyone puts documents in this shared folder). But once you start involving 10s/100s of teams, thousands of individuals, etc... some teams use "Shared drives" (which show up on the left panel under "Shared drives"), some teams use shared folders (which show up in your folders list), some teams use individually shared documents (which show up in any number of random places, with the only reliable way of getting back to it is to find the email where they shared it with you). Some teams use shared drives internally within their team, but because they don't want to share the entire drive with an outside collaborator, they will share only a specific folder/file. The entire sharing mechanism becomes a mess and impossible to track and keep organized.

G drive is nice in many aspects, but the sharing is one in which IMO it allows far too much flexibility. The nice thing about file systems of yesteryear like Sharepoint (ugh, ew) is that they at least said "this is the folder tree. use it, because you don't have any choice" which at least encouraged some modicum of structure. G Drive instead says "here's a sandbox, do what you want" which sounds nice in theory, but in practical use is a mess when you have 1000+ people building their own personal sandcastle.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by MperorM on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:59PM (#23630632)
That does sound awful!

Thankfully we use Box and regular office at my workplace, so I have not had to experience that side of Drive.

Would it be fair to say Drive is very well suited for small organisations, but has trouble scaling?

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by txcwpalpha on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:05PM (#23630711)
I think it's great for small teams and small organizations who will likely naturally come to a standardized way of doing things. I think it also can be great for larger organizations as long as that organization has a decent way to encourage (and ideally enforce) a standard way of organizing file shares. It's definitely a challenge once you start losing that structure, though.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by charwalker on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:32PM (#23631088)
Yeah, I think that if there are strong norms or rules on organization and structure then it can work really well for any size team. But as soon as 1 person or project starts to deviate (no matter how good the intentions) it can quickly drop into a mess like any free for all file share. My team at work technically owns this one file server that is open to most of the company and has been an easy duping ground. Like, project X needs a share, stick it on [Server] vs the effort to set up a new share on an appropriate server (there are many others including department specific).

We have a project slated for late this year or early next to audit the file server and shares then permission to begin migrating shares my team doesn't own to other servers. I'm so ready for that.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by alanbernstein on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:26PM (#23629977)
I have the same problem, but I suspect the true cause is sharing a folder structure with other people, without defining/enforcing any conventions on organization.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by milesskorpen on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:51PM (#23630481)
Sure, I've got the same buttons ... but I've got >150,000 files in my Drive managed by >2,000 colleagues assembled over 6+ years, including files inherited from colleagues/reports who have left with their own approaches to file management, which turns it all into a massive disaster.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by lordgrenville on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:23PM (#23630969)
> a breath of fresh air to use {Drop,}box at this point
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by jurassic on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:52AM (#23629391)
> An old gmail account being noisy is probably more a function of it being old than it being a gmail account. I suspect he'd see a great improvement just starting a new email address.

Hey's screener feature shows there's a lot of room to innovate on giving users control of their attention beyond the filters and labels that Gmail has deemed sufficient for more than a decade now. Setting up forwarding to use Hey as a read client for my incoming gmail email has shown me that my address being old and public is not the problem.

Inbox had bundling that was a promising direction, but that seems to have been scrapped when they shut that client down. I'm not a tinfoil hat person and don't really mind being tracked, but it doesn't surprise me that a company that makes its living off monetizing attention would never lead on giving control of it back to users.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by kikki on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:25PM (#23632677)
I watched the HEY video and I don't get it - the screener feature is not innovation - it's a block list with a different name. Gmail has this. The way Jason hyped up every feature and then you realise it's something that already exists with a special "product name" (Imbox, really?). I can see why people buy into the marketing speak but look a little deeper.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by jurassic on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:57PM (#23633112)
Gmail does not have this. Hey inverts the default behavior to one that is consent-based, and things can only reach your inbox if you thumbs up the first time they send something to you. This is not some minor technical point, it is at the core of Hey's value proposition. In Gmail, the default is that everything gets to you and it's up to you to play whackamole with filters and unsubscribes, requiring several clicks each time.

In addition to the simple whitelist behavior, on the initial Hey screening you can (with a single click) route second-tier messages into Feed and Paper Trail, which is a much better UX than what you can build in gmail by creating a filter for every sender that labels + autoarchives.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by kikki on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @04:55PM (#23633765)
Look a little deeper. Your "screener" section is an inbox. You can either whitelist or blacklist messages that come into here. In your Gmail inbox, you can also block addresses and never see them again. It is the same interaction - no matter what marketing spin you put on it.

If that's HEY's value proposition, then they're in for a rude awakening. Personally, I think the proposition is simply using something other than Gmail, which is a fine enough reason without needing to put any marketing spin on it. $99 for an alternative though is a difficult ask.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by ImprobableTruth on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:46PM (#23635999)
The entire point is that it's separated, that you have two separate inboxes. The underlying mechanism is the same, but the user experience is quite different. In my opinion it's similar to Roam in that the framing leads to a different workflow, even though neither has any truly revolutionary "technical feature".

If you think this is just "marketing spin", I think you're simply not part of the target demographic, which is people that have currently have issues with e-mail.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by agentdrtran on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @04:45PM (#23633656)
Gmail does not have something like Hey's screener.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by eloisant on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @04:56PM (#23633780)
I'm using hey right now as my main email, forwarding from gmail and using the full trial to decide before I buy.

There are a lot of features I like, but I don't really get all the fuss about the screener. You're still getting those emails, they're not getting in your "imbox" but you still have to review them.

In practice it doesn't seem to make a big difference with gmail "mark as spam".

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by ImprobableTruth on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:42PM (#23635970)
>You're still getting those emails, they're not getting in your "imbox" but you still have to review them.

Sure, but the point is that you can do this only occasionally (e.g. once a day), whereas with gmail they take up space and attention in your inbox until you get to them.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by hinkley on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:40PM (#23630301)
Last spring I sat down to binge re-watch a TV series and just went back through my inbox looking for every mailing list I was on, unsubscribe, and then delete all previous messages. Probably took 8 hours total, but I deleted thousands of messages and now I get about 6 messages a day in my inbox, most of them from humans or services I just recently used. It’s worth my time to look at it again.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by mostlysimilar on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:52PM (#23630508)
I do this every few months and it feels amazing each time. Even if I'm intentional about unchecking the marketing email boxes, somehow I still end up on dozens of mailing lists.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by jasonv on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:03PM (#23630686)
I've recently been bothered because I hate all my email clients (except Outlook, weirdly enough, but I don't want to use Outlook with my Gmail accounts, because tag support isn't awesome...) and realized, of course, half my problem is I'm trying to manage too many emails I have no interest in reading.

There are a lot of newsletters I like, though.. for things related to fitness and outdooring, that are wholly in the "sign up for this virtual version of the event you were interested in!" and I've simply resigned myself to unsubscribing from all of them. I'll figure all this out later, but so much email feels like the parts of the web and RSS I work hard to avoid.

So, unsubscribe it is...

(That said, I've been trying HEY, and I don't like it [Such. Big. Fonts.] but I do like their "bundle" feature, and I wish I could set tags in Gmail to auto-delete after //n// days... that would make some things nicer to live with.)

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by hinkley on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:12PM (#23630806)
I have separate folders for these 'someday' mailing lists. It's like your attic. If you really needed the stuff it would be downstairs, but until you run out of space you can't convince yourself to get rid of any of it.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by SenHeng on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:27PM (#23630003)
We recently switched from Meet back to Zoom, because Zoom lets you use your speakers while Meet requires everyone to use a headset.

Zoom does some kind of active noise-cancelling where it will avoid picking up whatever the person on the other end just said, preventing the echo effect. Meet doesn't, it picks up everything. So if you use a speaker, everything the other person says gets repeated back at them.

When Meet recently announced noise-cancelling, we got really excited, only to be disappointed when they were referring to cancelling of background noises and not of participants.

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by agustamir on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:48PM (#23630438)
> Zoom lets you use your speakers while Meet requires everyone to use a headset

Really? Is that restriction on desktop or mobile? I've been using speaker mode on meet(mobile) for a while now. Or is it implicitly imposed by you due to lack of noise cancelling features?

Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by mdoms on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @05:57PM (#23634329)
No this is definitely not correct for mobile or web platforms. You 100% do not need a headset, although you should use one because Meet's echo cancellation is pretty aggressive and causes all kinds of problems without a headset.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by SenHeng on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:13PM (#23635782)
It's not a technical imposition, if that's what you're asking. We can use speakers with Meet, but then everyone now hears themselves speaking.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by laxatives on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:38PM (#23631183)
How did you transition your email address? I've wanted to get off, but I can't do that without wiping all of my previous conversations or losing contact with many people.
Re:Google Blew a Ten-Year Lead by loughnane on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @02:36PM (#23632037)
I still have the old emails in gmail, I just moved to protonmail for new things and put up a vacation autoresponder. letting people know I don't use it anymore.

I might migrate, but honestly I don't go through old emails almost ever, so I'll prob just export an .mbox and deal with importing it sometime in the future if I ever need it.