News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by mikeryan on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:21PM (#2361953)
Its funny I had a similar argument with someone last week (2 weeks ago?) when the Westboro Baptist's won their supreme court case [1].

Speech is free, period. Once you try to put any restrictions on then the whole thing isn't even a slippery slope, its a frictionless cliff.

[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/03...

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jwb119 on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:47PM (#2362256)
Not really. Speech is far from free, period.

The law recognizes a wide variety of restrictions. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_in_the_United... for a few.

For a view that "There is no such thing as free speech" see Stanley Fish, etc.. http://www.australianhumanitiesreview.org/archive/Issue-Febr...

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by vacri on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:46PM (#2362594)
There's also the good ol' Free Speech Zones http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone

"You can say what you want, but we tell you where to say it."

EDIT: That being said, the US still has a very high bar for freedom of speech.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by sliverstorm on Thursday March 24, 2011 @02:40AM (#2363125)
Speech is far from free, period.

As it should be. All sorts of things that don't deserve to be protected by Freedom of Speech. For example, treason often takes the form of selling out your country with information- which is just Speech after all.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waterhouse on Thursday March 24, 2011 @04:04AM (#2363266)
If it involves, say, a high-ranking general giving loads of top-secret military information to the enemy, it's likely that not giving away such information is part of his job description, and that he is in breach of contract. Now, the law might not like punishing breach of contract with long-term imprisonment (or whatever the penalty for treason is), but you could probably work something out--e.g. if he breaks contract, then he retroactively loses all access privileges, and all those times he accessed top-secret data are now considered trespass.

(This seems in fact quite appropriate to me, because then the punishment is proportional to the extent to which the general misused the privileges given to him. If he was new to the job and they didn't show him much of anything, then they have little to complain about him breaking their trust; if he's spent ten years getting his fingers in all their data with their conditional permission, and now they realize they shouldn't have allowed him, then they have a lot to complain about.)

The case of shouting "fire" in a crowded theater can be handled similarly: Customers agree not to do that sort of thing as a condition of being allowed into the theater, and if they break that, then they are guilty of trespass. You might complain that the customers didn't agree to any such thing, and that implicit contracts are bad. Fine, then the theater can put up a sign that says "You are not allowed to falsely shout 'fire'". As a matter of fact, I have seen many fire alarms in large buildings with a sign that says something like "$NNN fine for spurious triggering of this alarm".

The point is, there is no need to count any of these situations as cases where freedom of speech breaks down. These things can be illegal without allowing any chinks into your free-speech armor; they can be punished, not because they're an illegal form of speech, but because of something else.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by sliverstorm on Friday March 25, 2011 @12:53AM (#2367315)
I don't think this works. The Bill of Rights supersedes everything else. If we took a perfectly strict and literal interpretation of the First Amendment, that would overrule any disciplinary action directed at this high-ranking general, because his actions are protected by free speech.

If we were to apply it with no exceptions, there would be NO EXCEPTIONS, and no other laws, rules or agreements would be able to overrule it.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waterhouse on Friday March 25, 2011 @09:44AM (#2368395)
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.

If the U.S. military requires its generals (as a condition of their employment and their access to top-secret info) to not give away top-secret info, and it prosecutes those who break this agreement, this is clearly not Congress making any kind of law and therefore is not prohibited by the above, so in fact a perfectly strict and literal interpretation of the First Amendment would conclude that this is totally legitimate.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by shpxnvz on Thursday March 24, 2011 @10:27AM (#2364182)
The case of shouting "fire" in a crowded theater can be handled similarly: Customers agree not to do that sort of thing as a condition of being allowed into the theater, and if they break that, then they are guilty of trespass.

Not that I disagree with your premise, but an issue with this is that people like to see punishment that fits the crime - I'd expect public outrage over a misdemeanor prosecution for an infraction that may result in loss of life.

As a matter of fact, I have seen many fire alarms in large buildings with a sign that says something like "$NNN fine for spurious triggering of this alarm".

Those fines are actually due to local ordinances. As such they are an example of government imposition on individual freedom in order to protect the public, and are a bit of a counter-example to your point.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waterhouse on Thursday March 24, 2011 @12:06PM (#2364623)
Not that I disagree with your premise, but an issue with this is that people like to see punishment that fits the crime - I'd expect public outrage over a misdemeanor prosecution for an infraction that may result in loss of life.

If someone got stomped to death in a stampede triggered by someone's cry of "fire", methinks the person or people who did the stomping would have a lot to answer for. You shouldn't do that even in a real fire. The only difficulty is that it may be hard to identify the culprit(s) if everyone was busy panicking about their own escape routes; and I can see how a mob, with no other targets available, might place all blame on the original "fire"-shouter.

But perhaps this "loss of life" thing is an incidental flourish, and your main point is that people, responding legitimately to a fire alarm (not stomping on people), suffer a lot of inconvenience (they drop whatever they're doing and evacuate), and the "fire"-shouter is responsible for all that and perhaps should pay for it. I agree with that. I don't see a problem with assigning a large punishment to the simple crime of trespass when the trespass has large consequences.

Suppose I gain access to a Toyota plant and press a few buttons or rearrange a few materials in such a way that a batch of several cars comes out ruined. I haven't done anything beyond simple trespassing, but I am responsible for thousands of dollars of property damage, and I can be made to pay for it, right?

So either this is a case where a trespass is a huge crime; or I can be considered responsible for massive property destruction, even though I just pressed some buttons or rearranged stuff (possibly without realizing the implications of my actions), and even though it required the actions of other people in the assembly line to completely carry out the destruction. (In the latter case, what makes me guilty and the others innocent is that I committed a crime--trespass--and they didn't.) These choices seem largely equivalent to me; the former has the drawback that you can no longer hear "trespass" and think "Oh, ah, trespass, a misdemeanor, with maximum punishment X", but perhaps this could be remedied by calling it "trespass causing major property damage". Either way, I think something similar could be made to apply to the case of a false fire alarm.

Those fines are actually due to local ordinances. As such they are an example of government imposition on individual freedom in order to protect the public, and are a bit of a counter-example to your point.

Interesting. I didn't know that. Still, couldn't you call it a form of trespass and still punish it with a fine of approximately that magnitude (see above for further discussion)?

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by shpxnvz on Thursday March 24, 2011 @04:46PM (#2365873)
Still, couldn't you call it a form of trespass and still punish it with a fine of approximately that magnitude (see above for further discussion)?

Sure you could get a fine for trespassing, or even imprisonment, but since it's a criminal offense it's at the discretion of the prosecuting jurisdiction rather than the establishment. On the other hand, the trespasser could probably be held civilly liable for damages by the establishment directly.

In fact, going back to the theatre example, I suppose the person who yells fire and causes a stampede could just as well be held liable for injury or wrongful death in a civil suit by the affected individuals, rather than reckless endangerment or manslaughter in a criminal court.

In the end, though, we'd also have to consider the cost and effort involved in individuals conducting civil suits vs. the convenience of having the government handle investigating and prosecuting it as a criminal offense.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by Macha on Thursday March 24, 2011 @05:52PM (#2366181)
> Suppose I gain access to a Toyota plant and press a few buttons or rearrange a few materials in such a way that a batch of several cars comes out ruined. I haven't done anything beyond simple trespassing, but I am responsible for thousands of dollars of property damage, and I can be made to pay for it, right?

Vandalism? Sabotage? You've done more than just trespass if you've interfered with anything in such a way as to cause damage (deliberately or otherwise).

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by ebaysucks on Thursday March 24, 2011 @07:23AM (#2363592)
you are right - the essence of freedom of speech is not that all speech should be allowed all the time and everywhere, but that "speech regulation" has to be decentralized via voluntary contracts between property owners
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by eftpotrm on Thursday March 24, 2011 @10:11AM (#2364106)
But.... that seems to be the US approach to any of a number of issues, allow legal freedom and private contracts to restrict. However all too often there seems to be no practical alternative to the restriction for many, so what value does the theoretical freedom really have?
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by orc on Friday March 25, 2011 @11:51AM (#2368981)
I am disappointed by this: "Lesser protection of commercial speech"

I would like it to be illegal for a news organization or an advertisement to lie to or mislead the public.

If you survey 1000 doctors, and 4 say yes, you better not put "4 out of 5 doctors surveyed" in your ad.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by thaumaturgy on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:17PM (#2362143)
So what, then, is the difference between my calling your phone number multiple times and leaving harassing messages ("You're going to hell! Fag!"), and what the WBC does at semi-private gatherings, like funerals?

I don't disagree with the justifications behind protecting speech, even (and especially) things that I find reprehensible. However, I think it's a bit of a lie to say that law doesn't have fine lines or distinctions.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by kenjackson on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:35PM (#2362199)
The lines in law, where they exist, tend to be fuzzy, rather than fine.

Now with that said freedom of speech is a special law. And obviously one that cuts both ways. But a key reason why the law should largely exist untampered is that even if you say something I think is offensive, I can rely on a few things:

1) If it's absurd it will be discarded by most people.

2) If it's absurd those people it would convince, probably already believe it.

3) With freedom of speech I can argue the point prior to irreversible damage.

Now there are some cases where freedom of speech don't apply and those are generally cases where the three points above don't apply. For example, the classic of yelling "Fire" in a crowded room. Someone else yelling, "there is no fire" is not likely to be heard and even if "Fire" is seemingly absurd, most people may not discard due to potential harm. Yada yada.

But outside of cases that violate the above, the law should stand. Otherwise the consequences, shutting down opposing speech, will almost certainly be worse.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by alanh on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:52PM (#2362442)
> If it's absurd it will be discarded by most people.

And yet the various flavors of creationism (all equally absurd by measures of science) have convinced half of the U.S. of their validity.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by kenjackson on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:35PM (#2362727)
I generally don't find creationism offensive. While I don't believe it, I'm not offended by it. And I think that's true for most people. It's certainly not the type of thing that ever comes up in free speech arguments. I can't think of any atheist I know (although I'm sure some exist) who want creationism banned in speech or writing.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by barefoot on Thursday March 24, 2011 @08:18AM (#2363694)
Agreed. I'm a fairly strong minded atheist and I find creationism offensive. At the same time I would defend to the death the right for creationists to have free speech.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by eftpotrm on Thursday March 24, 2011 @10:13AM (#2364118)
I could understand why one might find the teaching of creationism offensive, but what is offensive about other people holding wrong opinions? I'm sure we each think the other holds several; I'm not offended by the error I perceive you might be making.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by mostly_harmless on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:23PM (#2362694)
but that is their right to believe what they wish. If they want to believe whole-heartedly in Norse mythology, that is their right to do so. It only becomes an issue once they impose their beliefs on others. It can even be thought that atheism is a religious belief in itself. It explains all the things religion does in a unique way.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by Zak on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:51PM (#2362769)
I think the main reason yelling "fire" and the like are illegal is that such speech is intended to and does cause action on the part of others. Solicitation to commit murder, inciting a riot, making a false report of a crime, uttering a forged instrument and making (credible) verbal threats are illegal for the same reason. None of these are illegal because of the lack of opportunity for analysis or debate, but because of the direct link between speech and action.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by kenjackson on Thursday March 24, 2011 @12:26AM (#2362857)
Those are in a whole different class than I was thinking of. Those are with the express intent to further a crime. Although I guess the Fire example can fit there too, although I was thinking more of someone who thought it would be funny, but not necessarily anticipate the full breadth of consequences.

The issue though isn't a link between speech and action (PE coaches don't violate this although their barks usually directly create action). It's the link between speech and furthering a specific crime.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waqf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362213)
Well, the difference is that you're expressing your opinion, which is fine, and also harassing the guy, which is a crime.

Just as if you announced "mikeryan is going to hell! the Fag!" while chainsawing live babies you're committing a crime. The expressing of your opinion is not a crime, but the fact that you're expressing your opinion doesn't exempt you from other criminal liabilities.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by thaumaturgy on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:42PM (#2362230)
Thank you for being the only person that responded to the point (might've been my fault, maybe I wasn't clear). I think most people would say that what the WBC does is harassment; so, other than the fine legal difference between whether the harassment occurs on public grounds or private property, how is one form of harassment protected as free speech and another form of harassment not?
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by redthrowaway on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:19PM (#2362525)
The WBC are a family of lawyers. They are very careful not to step over the legal line, while inciting others to do so. They then sue any and all transgressors, and use the money to continue their campaign of finding more people to sue.

Once you're onto them, they become incredibly easy to ignore, or counter-troll if that's your game. Doing everything you can to piss them off, while still remaining within the bounds of the law, tends to send them scurrying to their next funeral.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by VladRussian on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:48PM (#2362258)
>what the WBC does is harassment

no. I'm not a lawyer, yet i'm pretty sure that what WBC does wouldn't fit harassment criteria. I suppose for the harassment the specific action needs to be targeted at the person being harassed. Without specific targeting, they just express their opinion, wrong opinion at the wrong time and place, yet not illegal.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waqf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:51PM (#2362275)
Heh, I had an unfair advantage: I didn't trouble to familiarize myself with the WBC.

But by my reasoning, the difference would be legal precedents stating that pickets are legal (irrespective of what you use them to promote) and repeated unsolicited telephone calls are not (irrespective of what you say).

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jules on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:54PM (#2362288)
That's not entirely true. You can't write "God Hates Blacks" (per the Racial Hatred Act) but you can write "God Hates Fags". There seems to be no logical basis for this difference.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by russell_h on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:43PM (#2362748)
To clarify: are you talking about the U.S. or another country (a moment on Google suggests maybe Australia?). I'm almost certain that writing "God Hates Blacks" (or waving a sign saying that, etc) is perfectly legal in the United States.

See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech#United_States

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jules on Thursday March 24, 2011 @08:45AM (#2363812)
Sorry, you are correct. I Googled "anti discrimination laws US" and didn't check that the page it gave me was actually about the US.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by Duff on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:52PM (#2362279)
It is more about the "how" and less about the "what".

If I called you 500 times and simply said "Hello, hello, hello", that is still harassment. The WBC people apply for permits and protest on public property. What they say isn't relevant.

In general, your actions and intent are more germane than the content of your speech. That's a concept critical to free speech -- controversial or offensive is far more important to protect than typical conversation.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by VladRussian on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:35PM (#2362202)
WBC does it on public property.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by praptak on Thursday March 24, 2011 @04:32AM (#2363304)
True. But I don't think the crux of the matter is in the ownership of the piece of ground they happen to stand on.

There is a strong argument against exercising the freedom of speech the way they do. The right to speak freely should not trump the right to stop listening. This is not the case here. Whoever attends the funeral has their right to stop listening seriously limited.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waterhouse on Thursday March 24, 2011 @05:10AM (#2363353)
Actually, that is the crux of the matter. If you're at a party and making an obnoxious ass of yourself, the other partygoers can't kick you out. What they can do is go to the host and ask that he kick you out, which he can do if he so decides. If the host happens to be you (or someone sympathetic to you), then their only recourse (beyond attempting to persuade you to cut it out) is to leave themselves. The avenues of legal recourse are entirely determined by ownership of the piece of ground they are standing on.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by iamdave on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:47PM (#2362599)
The difference?

The difference is a small, but visible and under appreciated line between free speech and verbal assault.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by lwat on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:33PM (#2362189)
Funerals are public, or at least the WBC is on public ground when they protest at funerals.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by calpaterson on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:28PM (#2362177)
Well, it's hardly ever a "frictionless cliff". Lots of countries (plenty of them in the EU) have restrictions on free speech, but they haven't yet turned into autocracies.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by VladRussian on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:30PM (#2362182)
>Speech is free, period.

There is situations when one fundamental right conflicts with another fundamental right. Your statement is that the fundamental right of free speech must always take precedence.

I see how fundamental right of a child for the privacy of his/her body [ note: a child can't give an informed consent to waive the right ] can be given priority over somebody else's fundamental right for free speech.

Unfortunately, in the case of fetish animal torture videos the Supreme Court took the side of the scum.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by enjo on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362216)
You could also argue that the "speech" in that case was that of the child, and it was most definitely not freely given.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by AngryParsley on Thursday March 24, 2011 @06:19AM (#2363480)
note: a child can't give an informed consent to waive the right

I don't think the consent argument holds water. We force children to do things without their consent all the time. We make kids go to school. Corporal punishment of children is legal in most states, both by parents and teachers. Children usually don't consent to such things, but we do it them anyway.

Sorry for nitpicking one thing out of your comment, but the "children can't consent" argument really gets to me.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by shpxnvz on Thursday March 24, 2011 @10:40AM (#2364257)
It's not an argument, it's a fact of law.

There are certain activities that, by various state and local laws, require consent. Entering into a contract or getting married, for instance. A minor legally cannot consent to these things.

That doesn't extend to everything a child may do or be forced to do.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by vacri on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:10PM (#2370901)
How does this relate to what Gaiman is talking about? How does the drawing of manga violate a child's privacy? There are no children involved, unless they're reading the manga, and the pictures aren't going to leap off the page and violate the child's physical privacy.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jules on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362212)
Comics don't violate a fundamental right.