News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by VladRussian on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:30PM (#2362182)
>Speech is free, period.

There is situations when one fundamental right conflicts with another fundamental right. Your statement is that the fundamental right of free speech must always take precedence.

I see how fundamental right of a child for the privacy of his/her body [ note: a child can't give an informed consent to waive the right ] can be given priority over somebody else's fundamental right for free speech.

Unfortunately, in the case of fetish animal torture videos the Supreme Court took the side of the scum.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by enjo on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362216)
You could also argue that the "speech" in that case was that of the child, and it was most definitely not freely given.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by AngryParsley on Thursday March 24, 2011 @06:19AM (#2363480)
note: a child can't give an informed consent to waive the right

I don't think the consent argument holds water. We force children to do things without their consent all the time. We make kids go to school. Corporal punishment of children is legal in most states, both by parents and teachers. Children usually don't consent to such things, but we do it them anyway.

Sorry for nitpicking one thing out of your comment, but the "children can't consent" argument really gets to me.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by shpxnvz on Thursday March 24, 2011 @10:40AM (#2364257)
It's not an argument, it's a fact of law.

There are certain activities that, by various state and local laws, require consent. Entering into a contract or getting married, for instance. A minor legally cannot consent to these things.

That doesn't extend to everything a child may do or be forced to do.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by vacri on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:10PM (#2370901)
How does this relate to what Gaiman is talking about? How does the drawing of manga violate a child's privacy? There are no children involved, unless they're reading the manga, and the pictures aren't going to leap off the page and violate the child's physical privacy.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jules on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362212)
Comics don't violate a fundamental right.