News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by thaumaturgy on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:17PM (#2362143)
So what, then, is the difference between my calling your phone number multiple times and leaving harassing messages ("You're going to hell! Fag!"), and what the WBC does at semi-private gatherings, like funerals?

I don't disagree with the justifications behind protecting speech, even (and especially) things that I find reprehensible. However, I think it's a bit of a lie to say that law doesn't have fine lines or distinctions.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by kenjackson on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:35PM (#2362199)
The lines in law, where they exist, tend to be fuzzy, rather than fine.

Now with that said freedom of speech is a special law. And obviously one that cuts both ways. But a key reason why the law should largely exist untampered is that even if you say something I think is offensive, I can rely on a few things:

1) If it's absurd it will be discarded by most people.

2) If it's absurd those people it would convince, probably already believe it.

3) With freedom of speech I can argue the point prior to irreversible damage.

Now there are some cases where freedom of speech don't apply and those are generally cases where the three points above don't apply. For example, the classic of yelling "Fire" in a crowded room. Someone else yelling, "there is no fire" is not likely to be heard and even if "Fire" is seemingly absurd, most people may not discard due to potential harm. Yada yada.

But outside of cases that violate the above, the law should stand. Otherwise the consequences, shutting down opposing speech, will almost certainly be worse.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by alanh on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:52PM (#2362442)
> If it's absurd it will be discarded by most people.

And yet the various flavors of creationism (all equally absurd by measures of science) have convinced half of the U.S. of their validity.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by kenjackson on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:35PM (#2362727)
I generally don't find creationism offensive. While I don't believe it, I'm not offended by it. And I think that's true for most people. It's certainly not the type of thing that ever comes up in free speech arguments. I can't think of any atheist I know (although I'm sure some exist) who want creationism banned in speech or writing.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by barefoot on Thursday March 24, 2011 @08:18AM (#2363694)
Agreed. I'm a fairly strong minded atheist and I find creationism offensive. At the same time I would defend to the death the right for creationists to have free speech.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by eftpotrm on Thursday March 24, 2011 @10:13AM (#2364118)
I could understand why one might find the teaching of creationism offensive, but what is offensive about other people holding wrong opinions? I'm sure we each think the other holds several; I'm not offended by the error I perceive you might be making.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by mostly_harmless on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:23PM (#2362694)
but that is their right to believe what they wish. If they want to believe whole-heartedly in Norse mythology, that is their right to do so. It only becomes an issue once they impose their beliefs on others. It can even be thought that atheism is a religious belief in itself. It explains all the things religion does in a unique way.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by Zak on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:51PM (#2362769)
I think the main reason yelling "fire" and the like are illegal is that such speech is intended to and does cause action on the part of others. Solicitation to commit murder, inciting a riot, making a false report of a crime, uttering a forged instrument and making (credible) verbal threats are illegal for the same reason. None of these are illegal because of the lack of opportunity for analysis or debate, but because of the direct link between speech and action.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by kenjackson on Thursday March 24, 2011 @12:26AM (#2362857)
Those are in a whole different class than I was thinking of. Those are with the express intent to further a crime. Although I guess the Fire example can fit there too, although I was thinking more of someone who thought it would be funny, but not necessarily anticipate the full breadth of consequences.

The issue though isn't a link between speech and action (PE coaches don't violate this although their barks usually directly create action). It's the link between speech and furthering a specific crime.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waqf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362213)
Well, the difference is that you're expressing your opinion, which is fine, and also harassing the guy, which is a crime.

Just as if you announced "mikeryan is going to hell! the Fag!" while chainsawing live babies you're committing a crime. The expressing of your opinion is not a crime, but the fact that you're expressing your opinion doesn't exempt you from other criminal liabilities.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by thaumaturgy on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:42PM (#2362230)
Thank you for being the only person that responded to the point (might've been my fault, maybe I wasn't clear). I think most people would say that what the WBC does is harassment; so, other than the fine legal difference between whether the harassment occurs on public grounds or private property, how is one form of harassment protected as free speech and another form of harassment not?
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by redthrowaway on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:19PM (#2362525)
The WBC are a family of lawyers. They are very careful not to step over the legal line, while inciting others to do so. They then sue any and all transgressors, and use the money to continue their campaign of finding more people to sue.

Once you're onto them, they become incredibly easy to ignore, or counter-troll if that's your game. Doing everything you can to piss them off, while still remaining within the bounds of the law, tends to send them scurrying to their next funeral.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by VladRussian on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:48PM (#2362258)
>what the WBC does is harassment

no. I'm not a lawyer, yet i'm pretty sure that what WBC does wouldn't fit harassment criteria. I suppose for the harassment the specific action needs to be targeted at the person being harassed. Without specific targeting, they just express their opinion, wrong opinion at the wrong time and place, yet not illegal.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waqf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:51PM (#2362275)
Heh, I had an unfair advantage: I didn't trouble to familiarize myself with the WBC.

But by my reasoning, the difference would be legal precedents stating that pickets are legal (irrespective of what you use them to promote) and repeated unsolicited telephone calls are not (irrespective of what you say).

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jules on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:54PM (#2362288)
That's not entirely true. You can't write "God Hates Blacks" (per the Racial Hatred Act) but you can write "God Hates Fags". There seems to be no logical basis for this difference.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by russell_h on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:43PM (#2362748)
To clarify: are you talking about the U.S. or another country (a moment on Google suggests maybe Australia?). I'm almost certain that writing "God Hates Blacks" (or waving a sign saying that, etc) is perfectly legal in the United States.

See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech#United_States

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by jules on Thursday March 24, 2011 @08:45AM (#2363812)
Sorry, you are correct. I Googled "anti discrimination laws US" and didn't check that the page it gave me was actually about the US.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by Duff on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:52PM (#2362279)
It is more about the "how" and less about the "what".

If I called you 500 times and simply said "Hello, hello, hello", that is still harassment. The WBC people apply for permits and protest on public property. What they say isn't relevant.

In general, your actions and intent are more germane than the content of your speech. That's a concept critical to free speech -- controversial or offensive is far more important to protect than typical conversation.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by VladRussian on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:35PM (#2362202)
WBC does it on public property.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by praptak on Thursday March 24, 2011 @04:32AM (#2363304)
True. But I don't think the crux of the matter is in the ownership of the piece of ground they happen to stand on.

There is a strong argument against exercising the freedom of speech the way they do. The right to speak freely should not trump the right to stop listening. This is not the case here. Whoever attends the funeral has their right to stop listening seriously limited.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by waterhouse on Thursday March 24, 2011 @05:10AM (#2363353)
Actually, that is the crux of the matter. If you're at a party and making an obnoxious ass of yourself, the other partygoers can't kick you out. What they can do is go to the host and ask that he kick you out, which he can do if he so decides. If the host happens to be you (or someone sympathetic to you), then their only recourse (beyond attempting to persuade you to cut it out) is to leave themselves. The avenues of legal recourse are entirely determined by ownership of the piece of ground they are standing on.
Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by iamdave on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:47PM (#2362599)
The difference?

The difference is a small, but visible and under appreciated line between free speech and verbal assault.

Re:Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? by lwat on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:33PM (#2362189)
Funerals are public, or at least the WBC is on public ground when they protest at funerals.