News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by allendoerfer on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:17AM (#23599360)
I personally know people, who invested considerable amounts of money into Wirecard after the COVID-19 crash and even one, who invested last week on the day the stock took its first dip.

At the first point in time the shortselling, the FT articles and the ongoing BAFIN investigation were known. At the second point in time it was known, that they hired there buddies from KPMG, who could not find anything wrong, but even they were critizising the quality of their report, EY could not find the missing money and the public prosecutor in Munich started a criminal investigation.

They still invested. One of them is a computer scientist and CEO of a small business, the other one has a PHD in business administration and works at a big three consulting firm.

Even highly educated people seem think of investments inherently as pyramid schemes. "It fell, so it has to go up again next!" "It cannot rise further, it's already at its all-time-high." No consideration for the actual value being created. At some level, you cannot blame them, TINA and monetary policy actually make it true. Auditing and rating companies, who are supposed to help here are a joke, making it all seem like a game.

It digusts me. On one end of the spectrum, money is something real and valuable. It decides, for how long you have to work, whether you have to live in your car or what you can afford to eat that day. On the other end, it's a a surreal thing. The direction it goes is controlled by private (!) instutions with enourmous amounts of power.

I hope that more people, who did not need the money lost it, than those who needed it. I also hope, that not only Wirecard staff will get prosecuted, but auditors have to pay for this in some way.

Why do we allow auditors to be private institutions with a profit motive, who are also doing business consulting on top of it?

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by zpeti on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:47AM (#23599559)
Unfortunately the same reasoning could be applied to Hertz selling stock in a bankrupt company, which would have been impossible 5-10 years ago, but maybe even a few months ago.

I think the markets have been completely messed up by stimulus since 2008, and it's only getting worse. Governments are buying company bonds for gods sake. Stocks aren't about market pricing any more. They are some vanity metric that governments are obsessed about now to keep from falling (just like house prices).

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by Qasaur on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:00AM (#23600262)
It's not vanity, because governments have dugged themselves into a hole where pension funds and others have invested enormous amounts of money in equities (seeing as bond returns are non-existent due to the aforementioned stimulus) as well as venture capital. Allowing the market to reset and recalibrate itself would also mean wiping out a lot of pensions as well as investments from wealthy donors, which is bad for votes.

The sad thing is that this erroneous monetary policy will only stop if politicians and central bankers are willing to stomach a harsh market recalibration, but seeing as they seem to not be willing to do that judging from their recent actions so I fear that this systemic malinvestment and inequality will just get worse and worse until something breaks.

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by bildung on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:16AM (#23599812)
> I think the markets have been completely messed up by stimulus since 2008

Maybe, but OTOH the stock market returns are actually no different from pre 2008 (S&P500 in this case): https://www.macrotrends.net/2526/sp-500-historical-annual-re...

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by fennecfoxen on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:38AM (#23600679)
That's a symptom of the problem GP is alleging, though: of companies obtaining returns by mooching off the free capital provided at taxpayer expense to grow your market share at the expense of others... rather earning them them by doing hard work to build businesses that earn their profits, while paying the real costs that your unsubsidized competitors have to pay themselves.

There's been real disruption since 2008. Stock market returns don't show it, and they should. The efficient allocation of society's capital depends on honesty and fairness here, and instead this gap is papered over by government intervention, meant first and foremost to prop up politicians' careers, in an unsustainable sham. It will go better for society if we are honest about it than if we wait for everything to collapse when we are truly put to a test and find there is nothing to our prosperity but a mirage.

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by _curious_ on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:47AM (#23615496)
I concur with zpeti’s sentiment that “I think the markets have been completely messed up by stimulus since 2008, and it's only getting worse.”

And as you, Qasaur, say: “this erroneous monetary policy will only stop if politicians and central bankers are willing to stomach a harsh market recalibration, but seeing as they seem to not be willing to do that judging from their recent actions so I fear that this systemic malinvestment and inequality will just get worse and worse until something breaks.”

I think society has reached that breaking point and starting to show the cracks. Digging underneath the protests/riots/violence/standoffs in cities like Minneapolis or Seattle, as they have revealed, what you'll find is rooted in socioeconomics.

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by linuxftw on Monday June 22, 2020 @12:14PM (#23601883)
Honestly, Hertz selling stock didn't seem that crazy to me. "We need more money, or we're going under." They're basically asking for new investors to make the business solvent. How is this any different than a startup asking for more investors prior to closing shop?

Frankly, not unreasonable either. The entire travel industry was destroyed overnight, so it's entirely possible they could emerge from insolvency with an infusion of capital and be just fine. I'm not putting my money on it, but it's not the most outlandish thing I've heard either.

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by dr_faustus on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:41AM (#23599509)
The motivation of your friends to put many in Wirecard stock probably less about investment and more about gamblng. I guess, they didnt invest their life's savings but just some money the had not better use for right now. In these times of zero risk free returns (and even low returns on junk bonds), investing in distressed assets can be a good strategy if you have the stomach to lose it all.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by allendoerfer on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:47AM (#23599562)
Probably true. But to me that's still disgusting. I belong to a social class, which can put an amount of money you could use to feed a family in the first world for an entire year into a company that's probably a pyramid scheme without even blinking an eye. Just makes you think, what kind of stuff people above us could do.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by deleuze on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:37AM (#23600665)
I mean, yeah, as you point out with TINA, can you really blame them? When the Federal Reserve essentially states that it will engage in any amount of QE to keep equities afloat, how is that not a pyramid scheme?
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by mrep on Monday June 22, 2020 @11:47AM (#23601515)
How do you get that? The FED is mostly just buying our own governments debt through treasury securities and citizens home debt through mortgage back securities [0]. They haven't touched equities and have barely purchased any corporate bonds.

[0]: https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/h41.htm

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by deleuze on Monday June 22, 2020 @01:05PM (#23602664)
I never said they were buying equities. Buying bonds and pushing rates to 0 still has an impact on the TINA attitude. of the market. And, in more direct ways, if you buy junk bonds from me, then I go turn around and buy equities, it's just the Fed buying equities with a few more steps in the middle.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by mrep on Monday June 22, 2020 @02:33PM (#23603880)
Or they could sit on the cash which many people do in a recession. And again, they've barely touched junk bonds. They are mostly just buying our own governments debt through US treasury securities, the same kind that the US government has created and sold 3 trillion dollars worth this year [0], mainly to fund the CARES act.

[0]: https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/pd_debttothep...

Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by erfgh on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:49AM (#23599580)
You're inferring way too much from a couple of failed investments.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by allendoerfer on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:58AM (#23599647)
Wirecard was the biggest bank of the 4th biggest economy. So I inferred some systemic issues here.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by sveme on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:16AM (#23600414)
Biggest by market value - and that‘s because it was considered a tech company rather than a bank.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by LunaSea on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:03AM (#23600285)
Isn't Deutsche Bank the largest bank in Germany?
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by allendoerfer on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:12AM (#23600370)
Right now it is again. Deutsche Bank has a market cap of around € 17 billion, Wirecard has (as of writing this) around € 3 billion.
Re:Wirecard – The “German Enron”, and a personal history by blibble on Monday June 22, 2020 @11:50AM (#23601562)
for size comparisons: banks are typically compared by the sum of their assets (not market cap)