News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by VMG on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:18AM (#23598213)
The company who has the best latency would still beat the competitors.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by ginko on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:23AM (#23598234)
They could collect all issued transactions in a ~100ms time window, process them in a randomized order, and publish new prices after that.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by zodiac on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:40AM (#23598306)
This mechanism ("batch auctions") are not immune to rewarding low-latency connections. The details depend on the exact auction mechanism but the general idea is that you want to join the batch as late as possible (at any moment in time when you make a decision to join the batch, you are never worse off if you wait a while before joining) and low-latency connections can afford to join later.

In fact with your exact proposal, assuming everyone has a connection with at most (say) 50ms latency, no one will join the batch in the first 50ms, which (I think) magnifies the low-latency advantage.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by magicalhippo on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:50AM (#23598374)
So randomize the batch window length as well then, say 10-100ms.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by zodiac on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:57AM (#23598407)
If you make a decision to join in the (say) the 5th ms of the batch auction and you have a latency of 1ms, you are still no worse off if you decide to wait 4ms before joining the batch.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by teempai on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:13AM (#23598722)
You can solve for this with a commit and reveal scheme, where trades with hidden price and size are committed in the first period and revealed and settled in the second period.

The advantage of speed or waiting until the end is mitigated as you can receive no additional information either way.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by gspr on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:23AM (#23598232)
Are you sure about that? They would on average perhaps be a slight bit faster, but if the randomized delays are an order of magnitude larger than the latency, they may not be able to do anything useful with that advantage.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by zodiac on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:50AM (#23598368)
Well, think through some toy examples. Suppose there is a market without order matching (again, toy example) and one market participant enters an extremely mispriced order, so the first person to fill that order wins. Even in the presence of random delays, the participant with the lowest-latency connection has a higher chance of filling the order than anyone else. (There are other anomalies, e.g. participants are now incentivized to have as large a number of distinct connections and hence "chances to roll low" on the randomized delay as possible).
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by bryanrasmussen on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:41AM (#23598308)
wouldn't it be like this?

If the delays are randomized then you have as good as chance of getting them as your competitors. On delayed times you will have a bad chance of winning, but in comparison to others with the same delays your latency beats theirs, on non-delayed times your latency beats non-delayed competitors and really beats delayed competitors.

Thus in the end the best latency should win biggest on non-delayed trades, and on delayed trades lose least.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by gspr on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:43AM (#23598320)
Unless that uncertainty now means that your time and resources is best spent elsewhere than shaving ms off your latency.