News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by CaptainZapp on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:26AM (#2358553)
This app may or may not be offensive. Personally (being straight) I find the idea of a "gay cure app" or "gay cure seminars" or "gay cure exorcism" despicable and repulsive.

That said, I don't believe an app shall be removed because it may be deemed offensive (by whatever standards).

Or as Voltaire put it:

"I may disagree with what you have to say, but I shall defend to the death your right to say it."

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by bad_user on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:56AM (#2358599)
Yes, but you know what's worse than removing "offensive" apps? Being selective about it.

Or rather, if you make it your missing to ban "offensive" apps and a "gay cure app" gets approved, then you look like an ass.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by henrikschroder on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:31AM (#2358682)
That makes no sense, "offensive" is an arbitrary standard anyway. By definition you're being selective about it.

I guess in this case Apple's standard is that they remove apps that are offensive to their shareholders and customers.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by bad_user on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:04AM (#2358763)
The term is subjective, yes, but an app that promises a Gay Cure is by definition offensive, no matter what definition of "offensive" you choose -- it's also medically dangerous, since gayness is not really a disease.

So if Apple pretends that it's doing this approval for the betterment of the App Store, like a Shepard blocking out impure apps from its garden, then they'd better make sure Gay Cure apps are out, otherwise they are hypocrites.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:47AM (#2358840)
> The term is subjective, yes, but an app that promises a Gay Cure is by definition offensive

By your definition - it had thousands of downloads and the organisation that produced it has thousands of members who clearly do not find it offensive and that likely extends to tens or hundreds of thousands of evangelicals (if not millions).

That's how subjective works.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by bad_user on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:02AM (#2359161)
I'm pretty sure there are thousands if not hundreds of thousands of people in the world that still think Niggers are an inferior race or that Jews are the rats that will bring this world to annihilation or that believe Xenu, the dictator of the "Galactic Confederacy", really exists and he's going to be back one day.

Any treatment / cure that is advertised as such (without BIG BOLD letters of warning) should be approved or banned by relevant organizations -- there's precedent for it, like Scientology's E-meters being required to be marked as a "religious device".

By my definition "offensive" is a notion or device that's used to spread hate or shame versus other people's condition, people which are really harmless for society as a whole -- since gayness is not really a disease.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @01:20PM (#2360310)
Don't be me wrong, I agree with your views - these are things I find offensive too, I'm just picking up the idea that something can be subjective and by definition offensive.

That's contradictory - if it's offensive by definition, there is no room for interpretation by the subject and therefore it can not be subjective.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by maurycy on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:06AM (#2358878)
Offended != offensive.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by lt on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:24AM (#2359043)
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by officemonkey on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:35AM (#2358823)
Smoking is medically dangerous.

Should Apple ban iSmokeit and other apps that facilitate smoking?

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by bad_user on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:48AM (#2359105)
Smokers also know that smoking is dangerous.

Banning apps like iSmokeit would be like imposing your morality on the rest of the world, even if there are well-behaved smokers out there that only smoke in their own private space.

On the other hand apps that help you quit smoking are OK, since smoking IS bad for you in the long-run and dependency on smoking IS a treatable vice.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by officemonkey on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:29PM (#2362178)
So, in other words, since everyone knows that smoking is bad for you, it's okay for pro-smoking apps to exist.

I understand why people were upset by the Gay-cure app, as people would be angry about an anti-vaccine app, or a pro-Nazi app.

I am not in favor of Apple's app store policy precisely because it encourages nanny-state morality on the flimsiest of moral grounds: profitability.

It reminds me of John Maynard Keynes' attributed quote: "Capitalism is the astounding belief that the most wickedest of men will do the most wickedest of things for the greatest good of everyone."

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:01AM (#2358752)
except that this is a privately owned app store. I defend Apple's right to exercise its property rights.

But not to the death. I'm busy that week.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by CaptainZapp on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:48AM (#2359107)
I'm not claiming that Apple does not have the right to curate their property as they see fit.

I, on the other hand - apart from not buying their products - have the right to observe that Apple Inc represents a bunch of unprincipled hypocrits.

I hope this helps.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:34PM (#2361779)
You certainly have the right to think and say whatever you like.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by photophotoplasm on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @03:44AM (#2358484)
It didn't deserve to be removed in my opinion. It wasn't hurting anyone by being there.

That being said, I can understand why Apple did remove it, because it doesn't make any business sense to enter a PR war over the relatively miniscule amount of profit they'd make from this app.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by defroost on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:08AM (#2358630)
How is the app "not hurting anyone"? The implication of the app in question is that if you are gay you are some kind of diseased freak that can be "cured". Churches have been trying these kinds of "pray away the gay treatments" for homosexual members, sometimes with tragic results like self-loathing, suicide, etc. I am certainly for free speech, but things like this, hate speech, or the Westboro Baptist church protesting funerals of fallen US servicemen (see God Hates Fags[1]) are really pushing the limits of what is acceptable IMHO.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westboro_Baptist_Church

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by photophotoplasm on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:15AM (#2358790)
> The implication of the app in question is that if you are gay you are some kind of diseased freak that can be "cured".

Well, the organisation that created this app explicitly believes that. There's nothing implicit about it.

But it's not like they're forcing this app on people. I'm assuming it's being willingly used by people who believe homosexuality is wrong and think they can stop their own homosexual urges.

If that's what they believe, let them go for it, I reckon. I don't have a right to tell them that they should be having relations that they clearly believe are wrong or immoral.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by JonnieCache on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:07AM (#2358880)
We should remember, an attempt at a "cure for gayness" is what killed Alan Turing. If you don't know who this man is and worship him to at least some extent, you don't really belong here IMO.

https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Alan_turing#C...

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by davvid on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:25AM (#2358551)
> It wasn't hurting anyone by being there

I have to respectfully disagree. I'm glad they got rid of this stupid app. It's simply hate sugar-coated with psuedo-science. Apple made the right decision.

"app store removes questionable content" -- How is this news? It's not like the app store is known for being a "free" or "open" platform in the first place.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by photophotoplasm on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:48AM (#2358587)
> I have to respectfully disagree. I'm glad they got rid of this stupid app. It's simply hate sugar-coated with psuedo-science.

If it was hateful, I agree. But I don't think the article even says what the app does, so how do we know that it was "hate sugar-coated with psuedo-science"?

I assumed this app was supposed to help "ex-gays" (or whatever they call themselves now) somehow. If that's the case, it's probably only being downloaded by people already involved in this stuff anyway.

So if they're downloading it out of their own free will, and it doesn't incite hate or violence, I don't see why it needs to be censored.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by Deestan on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:53AM (#2358593)
> if [...] it doesn't incite hate or violence, I don't see why it needs to be censored.

It incites intolerance by implying that homosexuality is a disease.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by pharrington on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:03AM (#2358617)
>it doesn't incite hate or violence

This is the limit of freedom of speech under the US Constitution. This is not the limit for morally acceptable behavior, and has nothing at all to do with a private company's control over their historically tightly and arbitrarily controlled ecosystem.

edit: not even this. Incitements of violence is the limit of constitutional free speech, not mere hatred. But to believe that propaganda claiming some people can and should be "cured" of their sexuality isn't hatred is idiotic at best.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by tosiabunio on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:24AM (#2358668)
> It's simply hate sugar-coated with psuedo-science. Apple made the right decision.

Shouldn't Apple remove all astrology apps then?

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by joesb on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:03AM (#2358759)
Is Astrology hate sugar-coated with pseudo-science?
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by mediacrisis on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:45AM (#2359318)
Vague blanket statements about possible future endeavors != hate.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by Confusion on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:10AM (#2358632)
"you can't cure gayness"

"of course you can, otherwise Apple wouldn't have approved an app that does it"

'Apple' is a name that carries authority and that can be used to lend credence to misinformation. That definitely does hurt people. Read the above as the last thing a father said to his gay son. If banning this app prevents even one tragedy, then good riddance. There are no disadvantages to applauding Apple for removing this app.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by MarkSimpson on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @03:57AM (#2358506)
Why are people downvoting this?

I'm not saying it should necessarily be upvoted or anything, I'm just wondering what part of it people are taking exception to.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by tallanvor on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:54AM (#2358739)
I downvoted because the statement "It wasn't hurting anyone by being there" is wrong. Organizations and programs that advocate the ability to cure homosexuality are responsible for a lot of harm to individuals who are either forced into their programs or go to them willingly because they think something is wrong with them. These programs have caused or contributed to suicides among the LGBT community, so to say they aren't hurting anyone is just wrong.

this article mentions this: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/12/nyregion/12group.html?_r=3...

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by westicle on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:30AM (#2358916)
A little recursive perhaps, but why on earth are people downvoting this?

Parent not only responded to the question directly and cogently, but even cited sources. I'm bewildered.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by celoyd on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:33AM (#2358564)
I did not downvote it. However, I imagine that some people think that this app does hurt people, albeit indirectly, and that this is so obvious that someone overlooking it is either a troll or oblivious.

(I am not taking that position, or any other position about the app or photophotoplasm’s comment, in this comment. I’m staying strictly on the meta level here. Void where prohibited by law. Contents may settle during shipping.)

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by willstraf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:46PM (#2362046)
> "it doesn't make any business sense to enter a PR war over the relatively miniscule amount of profit they'd make from this app."

unless I'm mistaken, it was a free app (with no ads), so they made no money off of it.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by rflrob on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @03:36AM (#2358469)
I really don't know how good the "offensive to large groups of people" standard is. If there were a Qur'an app, might not a large group of (racist, xenophobic) people find the idea of a book dictated by an angel to be offensive? Fortunately, Apple is a corporation and need not concern itself with being as exactingly fair as the federal government.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by tallanvor on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @03:43AM (#2358482)
Apple doesn't actually have to be fair at all. They do, however, have to keep their shareholders happy, and that means they have to be careful not to do things that will significantly hurt sales.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by credo on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:27AM (#2358555)
However, the perception of being unfair can potentially hurt Apple.

I'm sure a number of religious conservatives are going to be unhappy with Apple's removal of the app.

People like me (who think the app is absurd and are not religious conservatives) may not like the removal of a religious perspective even though we disagree with it (as long as the app doesn't violate any laws, advocate violence etc.)

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by timdorr on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:24AM (#2358547)
Create some litmus test apps, then. Put up a "Christian Cure" and "Muslim Cure" app and see if they get taken down or rejected. It would be interesting to see the results.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by statictype on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:46AM (#2358584)
I'm sure they would get removed. Those sound just as offensive.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by gradschool on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:05AM (#2359398)
Not that interesting because they'd be obvious trolls. How about an app that purports to give support and counseling people who are questioning their sexuality, in two versions, with one for straight people who think they might be turning gay, and the other for gay people who think they might be turning straight? If one of them is denounced as homophobic and the other is approved, you could be on to something.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by beej71 on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:46PM (#2362419)
"Straight Cure".
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by tomjen3 on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @03:40AM (#2358475)
More to the point, apple would never have approved the sceptics annotated bible.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:57AM (#2358745)
I think its fine if apps making fraudulent claims are removed.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by sigzero on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:37AM (#2358932)
Except there are thousands of people that would say it isn't fraudulent. I am not defending it, but "offensive" here is subjective.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:46AM (#2358946)
If they can present peer reviewed evidence of its efficacy then it should stay, otherwise they shouldn't be allowed to make false medical claims.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by spindritf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:26AM (#2359487)
What about an app "curing shyness"? Would you expect a peer reviewed evidence of its efficacy?

IMVHO that's a ridiculous standard for a lifestyle app.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:55AM (#2359634)
I'm only arguing in favor of applying this standard of curation to apps that provide medical advice, I wouldn't currently apply the same standard to other industries.

This is as much for social signaling reasons as anything else. For whatever reason, the medical industry is responsible for more spam and hucksterism than all other industries combined, so if you don't curate what people are providing then the entire app store loses it's value and credibility really fast.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by gte910h on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:38AM (#2359539)
So you're saying bye bye hypnotism apps too?

And bye bye business books?

I think the app is absurd, but I think the call for apple to censor it is wrong.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:32PM (#2361770)
I guess fraud combined with the oppression of fellow humans is probably what pisses people off about this app.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by gte910h on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:55PM (#2362072)
Yeah, but doing something because it pisses you off instead of because it's right is the mentality of the lynch mob and the totalitarian gov't.

I think its crap we don't have gay marriage, I think Exodus is laughable and a bad idea, but I think the idea they should be censored even worse.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Thursday March 24, 2011 @12:40AM (#2362882)
This is a private business, not government. It isn't a lynch mob when someone decides not to do business with you. This isn't censorship.

When the government prohibits you from speaking, that's censorship.

When the New York Times decides to deliver some ideas over others, its not censorship. They own the printing press, they can use it for whatever they like.

The iOS platform has ads, crossword puzzles and a set of ideas. It has the same rights as anyone else to decide what its going to disseminate.

Freedom of the press rests on property rights, in this case the right to use your property to promote the values you choose.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by gte910h on Thursday March 24, 2011 @01:59PM (#2365169)
Entities other than governments can censor. Government censorship is the worse type, but others are also bad.

It's completely the mentality of a lynch mob when you say "go get em boys, they did something we dislike" without stopping to say "Wait, should what they do be allowed? Could banning this have repercussions for other cases? Do I have the full story or just a filtered side of it".

The lynch mob is about the attempted boycott and press pressuring the press to pressure Apple to censor the app.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Friday March 25, 2011 @05:07PM (#2370367)
People have the right to object to things and people have the right to choose what they're going to promote. These are legitimate actions citizens can and should take when they encounter evil.

There's no lynch mob. A lynch mob decides to ignore due process of law and take the law into its own hands and carry out a sentence it thinks is justified.

In this case, the citizens are only doing what they are allowed to do.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by stretchwithme on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:03AM (#2358990)
Fortunately, Apple is able to reach an opinion of their own.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by fredBuddemeyer on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:26AM (#2358807)
why not get out of the judgment business, it's a loser.

just let (a significant number of) users report "potentially offensive apps" and make a category out of it. if the ratio is overwhelming then (users) ban the app.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by kristofferR on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:16AM (#2359215)
How's this app any different from apps "curing" judaism or blackness? It isn't.

It's pretty clear that nazism, racism, gaycism and other hateful applications shouldn't be allowed on the Apple App Store.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by willstraf on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:52PM (#2362062)
> "It's pretty clear that nazism, racism, gaycism and other hateful applications shouldn't be allowed on the Apple App Store."

Yes, exactly. I'm not sure if that above statement was an attempt at sarcasm, but it's completely true, they shouldn't be allowed.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by corin_ on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:15AM (#2358644)
A part of me does support totally free speech, but the other part of me is what made me one of the demonstrators against the Oxford Union when they had invited David Irving and Nick Griffin, and also that made me be one of the many people who emailed Apple (or, more specifically, Jobs) to complain about this app.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by megablast on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:18AM (#2358652)
Most of us feel the same way, but surely free speech is so much more important than these other issues.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by corin_ on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:26AM (#2358674)
I've tried to have that debate between my two opinions so many times, but haven't managed to find a way to be OK with people who are racist or homophobic.

I'd still defend the right to call me stupid, to call all British people stupid (my country), and many other things. But some hatred goes too far over the line for me to not want to try and prevent.

I'm not particularly up on legal systems, but I believe that in both the US and the UK the law is with me, to an extent at least - while freedom of speech is promised, there are also laws against types of "hate speech"?

Plus, freedom of speech says that they should be able to have that opinion and to say that opinion, not that they have the right to have third parties promote that opinion. Extending that is why I had the right to complain to Apple, and, while their removing the app isn't exactly a case of "free speech", it is a case of them being able to chose what their company sells based on moral choices.

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by wlievens on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:37AM (#2358825)
Classifying blatant racism under free speech can have actual consequences too. Consider the genocide in Rwanda in which racist radio programmes encouraged massive killings. You could say that everyone's responsible for their own actions, nobody forced anyone to grab machettes and kill their neighbours, but somehow that argument falls apart when you're dealing with mass hysteria.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by electromagnetic on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:34AM (#2358821)
AFAIK in both the US and UK you can still say whatever you want quite freely. Where the issue comes up is when people try to incite hatred, because all our laws fall under everyone else's rights being above our own.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by halostatue on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:22AM (#2359039)
There's a great aphorism that applies here: In theory, theory and practice are the same.

So it is with regard to free speech, and it's a thorny wicket. In a free marketplace of ideas, people are able to hear all viewpoints and select the most rational ones. Unfortunately, there are studies that seem to suggest that the repetition of a falsehood reinforces the ideas contained therein for at least some of the population. The best I can find quickly are "How Warnings About False Claims Become Recommendations: Paradoxical Effects of Warnings on Beliefs of Older Consumers"[1] and "Metacognitive Experiences and the Intricacies of Setting People Straight: Implications for Debiasing and Public Information Campaigns"[2]. (Look at the birther movement. There's an insane number of people in the U.S. who believe something to be true that is not only nonsensical but has been absolutely proven false. To many of these people, the means by which things were proven false has only reinforced their insane belief—and the more they repeat it, the more often they have a chance to convince others of their insanity being true, even though objectively it isn't.)

We know that words can wound deeply; look at the concerns over "cyber-bullying" and the reports of preteen suicides over some of those cases. As a parallel, it's illegal in every country with the concept of freedom of speech to incite a riot (even though the rioters are the ones causing the damage). As wlievens said, there's often direct consequences to hateful speech[3] that are deeply tragic.

Like corin_, I'm divided on this matter. I grew up American and emigrated to Canada as an adult. Canada has hate speech laws that can be fairly described as "prior restraint" and wouldn't pass muster in America. Those offend me as an American. But the level of discourse in Canada is, I think, better for such prior restraint. Obviously, one must be cautious in how one applies such things, but the improved discourse pleases me as a Canadian.

This is a long way to say: no, I don't think that free speech is more important than these other issues just because it's free speech. It's a complex problem without an easy hard-line solution that can be applied effectively. Because of the effects of repetition, sometimes the best way to stop hateful or stupid speech is to squelch it. And sometimes, it's the right thing to do.

[1] pdf: http://www.cerog.org/lalondeCB/CB/2005_lalonde_seminar/how_w... [2] pdf: http://sitemaker.umich.edu/norbert.schwarz/files/07_aep_schw... [3] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2358825

Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by michaelcampbell on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:01AM (#2358984)
Offensive or not, it's just snake oil and should be removed based on that alone.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by FirstHopSystems on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:51AM (#2358590)
Looks like Apple has cured the the 'Gay Cure' app.
Re:Apple removes "Gay Cure" app from iTunes by FirstHopSystems on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:17PM (#2362140)
Down Voting "Really?" I will try to be more elegant when mentioning Apple removed the Gay Cure app? Maybe throw something in there about lean methodology and MVP next time.