News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by mlyle on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:19PM (#23566666)
Huge amounts of the hydroxychloroquine debacle were dubious-- public statements about efficacy, broken early trials, etc.

But: in March, it was one of very few leads on a treatment. Building some degree of a strategic stockpile and ensuring that manufacturing was increased made sense, even if it was a long shot. It's unfortunate that this had a negative effect upon people, but if there had been efficacy having that stockpile would have been extremely beneficial.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by tom_mellior on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:57PM (#23567242)
It was never a lead. The first study pushing it was immediately recognized as broken. No better evidence ever came along. No plausible mechanism of action was proposed.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by mlyle on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:12PM (#23567430)
> No plausible mechanism of action was proposed.

?? We had computational and in vitro studies showing significant efficacy against SARS-CoV-2 at attainable serum concentrations, and had seen efficacy of HCQ against other viruses in humans. Obviously in vitro data is not the same as efficacy in people, but positive, high quality in vitro data is incompatible with "no plausible mechanism of action."

Early human research was tainted by being not randomized and tainted by clinician opinions of efficacy, which kept us from knowing for sure for quite some time that what worked in the petri dish didn't work in humans.

> No better evidence ever came along.

Yup, which is why we have largely abandoned the idea...

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by phkahler on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:11PM (#23567422)
That's simply not true. There are conflicting reports to this day. It has unfortunately become politicised to the point we will never know.

Even if it does no good, there was reason to think it may. It's not proper to criticize a decision based on information that was not available when it was made, and that's all that's happening now.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by marvin on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:31PM (#23567661)
There's so much of this from armchair experts. Unfortunately, very few of them will ever get out there and try their hand at making deliberate decisions under limited information.

Try cross-country sailplane flying. Try investing in the stock market. Go on a long sailing trip with no one to make decisions for you. Do some competitive multiplayer gaming. Try to be your very best at an activity that requires making the best possible decision based on uncertain information, adapting as that information changes and owning your mistakes.

Things look completely different when the outcome is known, when you see it on video afterwards. You need to have been in such a situation yourself to know, to have seen with your own eyes the same situation with and without the benefit of hindsight. It's startling. Just having an IQ of 120 isn't enough to appreciate this.

I would love to get the answer to whether hydroxychloroquine reduces the severity of Covid19 when given during the earliest stages of the disease. It's sad that we may now never get a good enough controlled trial that settles the question. It's a disgrace when the science is politicized to such a degree.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by tom_mellior on Thursday June 18, 2020 @06:21PM (#23568790)
> It has unfortunately become politicised to the point we will never know.

It's not politicised outside of the US. It was known to be junk science before Trump picked up on it. There is still some proper science to be done in clearly disproving all the junk claims, and don't worry, it will be done. But proper science takes time.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by thu2111 on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:04AM (#23572192)
People outside the USA do have strong opinions about Trump for better or worse.

The Lancet is a medical journal edited by a British guy who posts strongly left wing and anti-Trump stuff to Twitter all the time. The Lancet published a paper claiming HCQ was dangerous that fell apart immediately, and should never have been accepted at all (e.g. it claimed to be based on the medical records of hundreds of hospitals and something like 90% of all US COVID cases, which is implausible).

Why did such a terrible paper get published? Probably because it appeared to strike a blow against Trump's credibility which the Lancet's editor so desperately wanted. In the end it blew up in his face, though.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by tom_mellior on Saturday June 20, 2020 @09:04AM (#23583707)
> People outside the USA do have strong opinions about Trump for better or worse.

Yes, and people are saying "Trump is an idiot, and he's promoting something that doesn't work". I haven't seen people argue that "Trump is an idiot, therefore HCQ cannot work" (nor the opposite).

> Probably because it appeared to strike a blow against Trump's credibility which the Lancet's editor so desperately wanted.

That sounds like it might be a good point, I'm not familiar enough with the details, and especially not with the editor's motivations.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by tim333 on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:57AM (#23572568)
>The first study pushing it was immediately recognized as broken.

I think you are probably thinking of the first Raoult study but there was a lot of history before then including plausible mechanisms and even somewhat positive double blind trials done in Wuhan in February. It's still used in places like Thailand where they have sane policy and basically no more local transmission.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by iguy on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:07PM (#23567363)
Maybe this was clear to some, but lots of people thought it worthwhile to fund trials.

To me 63M doses of a cheap drug sounds like a really small bet. We should be willing to make lots of them, on the slightest hope, knowing that most will be wasted. Get 50 experts and fund anything which gets 2 votes.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by justin66 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:11PM (#23567419)
> Maybe this was clear to some, but lots of people thought it worthwhile to fund trials.

"A lot of people are saying..."

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by iguy on Thursday June 18, 2020 @05:06PM (#23568037)
A policy of funding a domestic trial of anything which anyone else is trying anywhere in the world wouldn't be crazy, actually. We're not trying to only make safe bets; the cost of not having a solution is 1000 deaths a day.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by justin66 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @06:03PM (#23568635)
> A policy of funding a domestic trial of anything which anyone else is trying anywhere in the world wouldn't be crazy, actually.

It seems rather crazy to me, but perhaps more importantly, it is a strategy that - implemented literally - would result in the US leadership being very easily led by others "anywhere in the world" in matters of drug research, a situation which would be very amenable to manipulation for profit.

That's obviously wrong. We want the US leadership to be very easily led by Fox News personalities and whatever is popping on Twitter.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by sharkmerry on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:12PM (#23567435)
I think the issue was, as another commenter stated, it has current uses for patients and the price almost doubled. So people had shortages or couldnt afford needed medicine. because of a (apparently) dubious study
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by iguy on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:20PM (#23567525)
Sure, that's bad. There's no point spending money chasing existing stock of the drug within the country, if it's useful it will all get used anyway.

But a $100M or whatever check to ramp up production, or to buy wholesale stock from elsewhere, that would have been worth writing on day 1. Even on extremely flimsy evidence, given the huge daily costs of this thing. Run the careful trials at the same time as building a huge factory which you probably won't need.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by sharkmerry on Thursday June 18, 2020 @07:17PM (#23569219)
> buy wholesale stock from elsewhere

The issue im presenting is they are buying them to be prepared to treat Americans IF it worked. But because they bought so many so quickly, it put Americans in a position where they weren't able to have medicine they needed. The government has a responsibility to balance current needs with possible immeidate future needs, it doesnt seem like they did.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by iguy on Thursday June 18, 2020 @07:49PM (#23569456)
It would be interesting to understand better how shortages came about. Was there enough time for a global price rise to have filtered through to retail customers?

Or was there enough retail panic-buying to generate shortages? If everybody with a prescription tried to buy 3 months worth, because they are scared of shortages, then I bet there would be shortages. (Isn't that exactly what happened with toilet paper?)

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by tim333 on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:45AM (#23572467)
I suspect it was panic buying that drove prices up. You can't go and just buy 63M doses on the market as there isn't that much lying around normally - it was probably produced to order. I know Novartis donated 30M pills and was offering to supply 130M.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by mlyle on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:17PM (#23567496)
Yes, that is really unfortunate.

Hopefully not too many people did without needed medicine.

Probably there will be some suffering relating to stockpiling of steroids (dexamethasone, methylprednisolone), that we're now learning -do- work in the severely ill, too.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by SomeoneFromCA on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:20PM (#23567527)
Central Asian countries, Uzbekistan in particular uses chloroquine (not hydroxy) to treat Covid patients. The official sources are highly unreliable, but overall the death rate is very low, even if you multiply it by 100.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by rpiguy on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:24AM (#23573735)
Same in Bangladesh and other countries.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by osrec on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:41PM (#23566981)
Did they stockpile remdesivir in the same quantities, given its actual efficacy?
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by bioinformatics on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:46PM (#23567057)
remdesivir is a quite new drug and really hard to manufacture. Also HCQ is a very old drug, created on WWII and really easy to manufacture.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by pnutjam on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:26PM (#23567594)
Did they stockpile PPE? It's proven effective for this pandemic and many other situations; however the feds let the stockpile dwindle for no good reason.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by thu2111 on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:05AM (#23572203)
I thought the jury was still out on masks at least. The WHO keeps changing its mind about them, as do other governments.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by pnutjam on Saturday June 20, 2020 @07:04PM (#23588188)
It's not, nobody is changing their mind. There were some efforts to reserve masks for front line medical workers. That muddied the issue, but masks protect you from spreading a sickness you may now know you have and provide a minimal amount of protection from catching covid-19.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by thu2111 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:23PM (#23630972)
Nobody is changing their mind? That's obviously nonsense. There have been so many reversals it made the news.

https://nypost.com/2020/06/06/who-reverses-position-on-face-...

Different authorities can't even agree:

https://abcnews.go.com/Health/cdc-offer-conflicting-advice-m...

The mask situation is absurd, one more failure on top of so many others for the global health establishment.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by pnutjam on Thursday June 25, 2020 @08:46AM (#23640037)
Wrong! https://www.cnn.com/videos/health/2020/06/23/anthony-fauci-m...

The masks were alway recommended to slow transmission.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by thu2111 on Friday June 26, 2020 @11:42AM (#23653235)
By whom do you think they were always recommended? Because that absolutely hasn't been true for the WHO and CDC, as the links I already gave you show. The WHO has changed its position on masks, and has been in conflict with the CDC on the same topic.

That video you linked to doesn't in any way disagree with anything I've said, nor rebut the point. In fact it supports it. It's just a video of Anthony Fauci talking about why he changed his position on masks: without admitting to it directly, he 'explains' that he wanted to ensure medical workers had access to them. But he is on record as having recommended against masks in the past. Here's Snopes saying so:

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/fauci-masks-no-longer-need...

In the March 2020 clip, Fauci said: “Right now in the United States people SHOULD NOT BE walking around with masks … You should think of healthcare providers who are needing them and the people who are ill.” (my caps)

https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-c...

He also acknowledged that masks were initially NOT RECOMMENDED to the general public so that first responders wouldn’t feel the strain of a shortage of PPE. (my caps)

Now many countries have introduced face mask requirements (which is dumb, but clearly a change of position).

Not only has mask advice changed but it's changed for dumb reasons: there's no scientific evidence masks work to stop SARS-CoV-2 transmission, especially not the cloth masks being actually deployed. This article investigates what's really known about this tactic:

https://off-guardian.org/2020/06/06/coronavirus-fact-check-6...

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by adventured on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:47PM (#23567072)
They're very different contexts. Gilead doesn't have such a large stockpile or production capability for Remdesivir. Everything Gilead had was turned over to the government.

From May 3rd:

"Gilead CEO says remdesivir will be available to patients this week: ‘We’ve donated the entire supply’"

"Gilead expects to produce more than 140,000 rounds of its 10-day treatment regimen by the end of May and anticipates it can make 1 million rounds by the end of this year."

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/03/gilead-ceo-says-remdesivir-a...

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by ars on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:55PM (#23567219)
Between 2006 and 2014 we spent FAR FAR more money stockpiling Tamiflu which does absolutely nothing.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-roche-hldg-novartis-searc...

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by mc32 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:55PM (#23567207)
That one is difficult to manufacture, so the effort necessary would be much higher.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by dumbfoundded on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:43PM (#23567013)
No, President Trump didn't hold any shares of the manufacturers.

The company behind its production is donating its stockpile to the US Government: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexandrasternlicht/2020/05/03/...

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by bioinformatics on Thursday June 18, 2020 @03:47PM (#23567063)
You only watch CNN too?
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by makomk on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:23PM (#23567570)
Wrong mainstream news outlet. The stupid conspiracy theory about Trump pushing hydroxychloroquine because he owned shares in its manufacturer was mostly the New York Times' doing. (This lead to the rather unusual spectacle of Snopes debunking a nonsensical online conspiracy theory pushed by the NYT... and there was plenty wrong with it, from the utterly miniscule size of Trump's indirect shareholding via a mutual fund to the low amount of money to be made from it to the fact that apparently that company was no longer selling it in the US anyway, some of which the NYT were clearly aware of.)
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by trhway on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:18PM (#23567501)
>if there had been efficacy

there have been efficacy all along against lupus/etc. Yet ephemeral unproven chance of efficacy against coronavirus was chosen over well known benefit for the already suffering people. That looks extremely illogical and kind of cruel to me. Not surprising though given that it isn't logic nor compassion that drives the government actions these days.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by mlyle on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:22PM (#23567552)
Unproven chance of reducing mortality and reducing overload on critical health care system was chosen against well known disease management with multiple alternative drugs.

Not that even this was intended, but it's unsurprising that efforts to stockpile and allocate supplies don't work perfectly.

Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by cm2187 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:05PM (#23567337)
And we are about to do exactly the same thing with vaccines, to preemptively produce them before we even know they are safe or useful.
Re:U.S. Stockpiled 63M Now-Useless Doses of Hydroxychloroquine by gsibble on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:03PM (#23567322)
My point exactly. Made total sense to stockpile it.