Try cross-country sailplane flying. Try investing in the stock market. Go on a long sailing trip with no one to make decisions for you. Do some competitive multiplayer gaming. Try to be your very best at an activity that requires making the best possible decision based on uncertain information, adapting as that information changes and owning your mistakes.
Things look completely different when the outcome is known, when you see it on video afterwards. You need to have been in such a situation yourself to know, to have seen with your own eyes the same situation with and without the benefit of hindsight. It's startling. Just having an IQ of 120 isn't enough to appreciate this.
I would love to get the answer to whether hydroxychloroquine reduces the severity of Covid19 when given during the earliest stages of the disease. It's sad that we may now never get a good enough controlled trial that settles the question. It's a disgrace when the science is politicized to such a degree.
It's not politicised outside of the US. It was known to be junk science before Trump picked up on it. There is still some proper science to be done in clearly disproving all the junk claims, and don't worry, it will be done. But proper science takes time.
The Lancet is a medical journal edited by a British guy who posts strongly left wing and anti-Trump stuff to Twitter all the time. The Lancet published a paper claiming HCQ was dangerous that fell apart immediately, and should never have been accepted at all (e.g. it claimed to be based on the medical records of hundreds of hospitals and something like 90% of all US COVID cases, which is implausible).
Why did such a terrible paper get published? Probably because it appeared to strike a blow against Trump's credibility which the Lancet's editor so desperately wanted. In the end it blew up in his face, though.
Yes, and people are saying "Trump is an idiot, and he's promoting something that doesn't work". I haven't seen people argue that "Trump is an idiot, therefore HCQ cannot work" (nor the opposite).
> Probably because it appeared to strike a blow against Trump's credibility which the Lancet's editor so desperately wanted.
That sounds like it might be a good point, I'm not familiar enough with the details, and especially not with the editor's motivations.
Even if it does no good, there was reason to think it may. It's not proper to criticize a decision based on information that was not available when it was made, and that's all that's happening now.