Sloppy compared to, say, crocodiles, which largely haven't changed in hundreds of millions of years. We humans aren't well designed for our current use cases, as we changed a whole bunch of our behaviors in the last few hundred thousand years.
> Where would you put the urethra, for example?
I'd leave that up to a biomedical engineer. Perhaps they'd rig up a system like reptiles and birds have, where the useful water gets reabsorbed and they excrete urea crystals.
> Sure they have some failure modes, but they also are succeeding trillions of times a day.
Again, this is true for spaghetti code. It is a mistake to think "spaghetti = broken". Spaghetti = hard to understand/maintain.
Crocodiles > humans >>>>>>> spaghetti code.
End of story, unless your spaghetti code only fails a very small amount, I guess. Not what I assume most people think when they think of it.
Many of your examples are contrived. Sure they have some failure modes, but they also are succeeding trillions of times a day.
I’d bet a lot of money a “human designed human” would not perform better, except for taking ideas from other humans, and only when done in very limited cases.